Canadian Banks Urged To Cut Rates, Suspend Payments As Profits Soar

The headquarters of CIBC in downtown Toronto, with a TD Canada Trust tower and the RBC complex on the right.

Canada’s major banks are making bigger profits today than they were before the COVID-19 pandemic, and some consumer advocates say they should be carrying more of the cost of supporting struggling households and businesses.

They are calling on Canada to follow Australia and Britain’s lead in charging “excess profit” taxes on banks, while urging lenders to cut their customers a break in a time of crisis.

As of midday Friday, nearly 80,000 people had signed a petition organized by Democracy Watch calling on the banks to halve their interest rates to consumers and suspend debt repayments for anyone who needs it. 

The petition also calls for a cap on bank CEOs’ salaries, and for independent audits of banks’ books to see how much profit they charge in each section of their business ― a move consumer advocates say would expose “gouging” where it exists.

Watch: Canada’s banking industry ‘not motivated to innovate.’ Story continues below.

 

Credit card interest rates are “so obviously an area of gouging,” said Duff Conacher, co-founder of Democracy Watch. “The (banks’) prime lending rate has gone down by almost seven percentage points since 2010, and credit card rates have dropped zero percentage points.”

Canada’s big six banks raked up a total $13.9 billion in profit in the first quarter of fiscal 2021, which ended Jan. 31, up some 14 per cent from the same period a year earlier, before pandemic lockdowns had begun.

Each of the Big Six saw their profits rise, led by CIBC (up 34 per cent) and Bank of Montreal (up 27 per cent).

Much of that increase came from trading ― thanks to a booming stock market ― and from much lower provisions for loan losses. Retail banking ― the part of banks’ business that deals with regular consumers ― showed little growth over the year.

Some progressive voices, such as the NDP, have suggested a temporary “excess profit tax” on businesses that see a windfall during the pandemic. Conacher would like to see a permanent new tax on banks, similar to the ones the U.K. and Australia have instituted in recent years.

The U.K charges an 8-per-cent surcharge on bank profits, while Australia in 2017 launched an additional tax on the total amount of lending on the books of its big four banks, amounting to about 10 per cent of their profits.

Laws like that are “a way of recognizing that the banks have enormous market share and are gouging,” Conacher said.

You go around Toronto, a lot of the Money Marts are in former bank branch locations. They just stepped right in. It’s just ridiculous.Duff Conacher, Democracy Watch

Rather than an arbitrary cap on credit card interest rates, as some U.S. states have done, Conacher would rather have the banks submit to independent audits of their books that would show exactly how much money they make in each section of their business, something they don’t need to do under current reporting laws.

“If an auditor-general released a report showing a 2,000-per-cent profit margin (in some part of a bank’s business), people would be outraged. Interest rates would come down the next day,” Conacher told HuffPost Canada.

Canada’s lenders offered some emergency support to their retail customers at the start of the pandemic, dropping credit card rates to around 11 per cent, from their regular 20-per-cent range, for customers in financial trouble. 

They also allowed deferrals of up to six months on mortgage payments, which 15 per cent of mortgage borrowers took advantage of at the peak last summer. But interest continued to accrue on those mortgages, meaning those borrowers will end up paying more than they otherwise would. 

Discrimination in lending

Democracy Watch is also calling on Ottawa to catch up with the U.S. on laws against discriminatory lending practices. 

The group is calling for audits of banks to reveal lending according to race, gender and neighbourhood.

If that happens, “I think we’ll find discriminatory patterns of lending based on race, including (against) Indigneous people, and based on gender,” Conacher said.

“And you’ll see that banks essentially do take money out of some neighbourhoods and don’t lend back to them.”

Conacher notes Canada has no equivalent to the U.S. Community Reinvestment Act, a 1977 law that requires banks to reveal how much lending they do in low-income neighbourhoods, and to rectify the situation if they are not reinvesting in certain communities where they have customers.

Conacher is calling on the federal government to require banks to reopen branches in low-income neighbourhoods, which they were allowed to close in the 1990s under then-Finance Minister Paul Martin.

Those bank branches were often replaced by predatory payday lenders, Conacher said.

“You go around Toronto, a lot of the Money Marts are in former bank branch locations. They just stepped right in. It’s just ridiculous.”

Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland’s office did not immediately respond to a request for comment for this story.

The federal Liberals have taken some flak from the left on the issue of banks, with the NDP last summer saying the government has done little to stop banks from “profiteering” amid the pandemic.

“During the Second World War, there were laws against profiteering,” NDP Finance Critic Peter Julian said. “We need similar leadership from the federal government at this critical time.”

ALSO ON HUFFPOSTLow-Income Canadians Face 'Abusive' Lending Rates Even In PandemicBank Of Canada Warns Of 'Excess Exuberance' In Housing MarketCanada's Job Losses In 2020 Were All In Low-Paid Work: Report
Read full article on: huffingtonpost.ca
Winnipeg Jets blank Canucks 5-0, will play Oilers in first round of playoffs
The Winnipeg Jets blanked the Vancouver Canucks 5-0 Tuesday and locked up third place in the North Division, which means a first-round playoff matchup with the Edmonton Oilers.
5 m
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
What will Calgary’s mosquito season be like? It all comes down to rain
Warm temperatures combined with lots of moisture create ideal breeding environments for mosquitoes, but that's just not something that has been happening too often this spring.
9 m
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
U.S. gas stations report shortages as Colonial Pipeline shutdown continues
The Colonial Pipeline, the biggest fuel pipeline in the U.S., delivering about 45 per cent of what is consumed on the East Coast, was hit on Friday with a cyberattack.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Victoria police investigating after remains found in Gorge Waterway
The remains, which consist of a partial cranial bone, were found by recreational divers in February.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Will Canada see a spike in influenza cases after COVID-19? Experts weigh in
Will Canada see a low number of cases again, or a spike in infections? Here's a look at what experts say could happen.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Metro Vancouver gang violence raises questions about police effectiveness, accountability
Metro Vancouver is the only large urban area in the country without a unified police force as the region is divided up between municipal forces and the RCMP.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Raptors drop 115-96 decision to Clippers
Toronto Raptors coach Nick Nurse hopes his players keep the frustration of this bizarre NBA season front of mind when they head into the off-season.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Allowed only to wave from afar, families want long-term care homes to accept visitors again
In Quebec, all long-term care residents have received both COVID-19 vaccine doses, and families say it is time to reopen the doors and let them in to see their loved ones.
CTV News | Top Stories - Breaking News -...
19 rescued dogs from Lebanon arrive in Canada
A dog rescue group has brought over 19 rescued dogs from Lebanon to Canada
CTV News | Top Stories - Breaking News -...
Aritzia maintains most of 4th quarter revenue due to growth of e-commerce sales
Aritzia earned $16.1 million for the three months ended Feb. 28, down from $21.7 million a year earlier.
1 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Wildfire still uncontained in RM of Piney as unfavourable conditions continue
A wildfire in the RM of Piney remains active and uncontained, and officials say it's one that won't be easily extinguished.
1 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Canada’s COVID-19 case count shrinks to late March levels as vaccinations expand
Provincial health authorities also confirmed another 32 people have died after testing positive for COVID-19.
1 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Bruce Arthur: Why pausing AstraZeneca was the right move — and why you probably were right to get it
It feels like a mess. But as risks and supplies change and new information emerges, there is logic to the province’s move.
1 h
thestar.com | Toronto Star | Canada's...
Message in a bottle found on Manitoulin Island brings strangers together
A message in a bottle thrown into Lake Huron more than 4 years ago has made its way back where it came from. And on its journey it brought two families together.
1 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Coalition says users were shut out of drug decriminalization proposal | 'Vancouver Model' gets panned
“We cannot abide by the phony ‘Vancouver Model’ of decriminalization and refuse to be tokenized in petty political bids,” reads the letter from groups representing users.
2 h
Vancouver News, Top Stories, Breaking...
Police looking for suspect after series of knifepoint robberies in downtown Calgary
Each time, a man approached a woman, showed a knife and robbed the victim of their cash, wallet or purse, according to police.
2 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
#ICYMI: Roberge under fire, Legault on Habs, language charter reforms, more
In brief: A selection of today's reports on montrealgazette.com
2 h
Montreal Latest News, Breaking Headlines...
‘His eyes started closing’: Okanagan Lake rescue caught on camera
"I tried to keep it light, but inside I was like, 'Oh no, this guy needs help right away."
2 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
No charges for officer who struck man with cruiser during arrest in Toronto: police watchdog
The SIU said the incident happened on the evening of April 12, 2020 when officers were called to the area of King and Bathurst streets for reports of a robbery.
2 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Inside the oil sands site that has seen Canada’s largest workplace COVID-19 outbreak
When a Calgary oil sands contractor took a job last month at Canadian Natural Resources Horizon Oil Sands work site, he knew there was a chance he could get sick.
2 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
As subject-free offers rise in B.C.’s hot real estate market, experts call for cooling off period
A Vancouver-based home inspector says buyers who submit condition-free offers and forgo a home inspection are gambling with their future.
2 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
‘It was a hell of a run.’ The Raptors’ playoff miss marks the end of an unprecedented era in Toronto sports
It’s not like this season, with the relocation and a terrible start and the impact of a COVID-19 breakout, is the start of any rapid descent on the court. But whoever returns next season, whatever the team looks like, the memory of the current disappointment shouldn’t be forgotten.
2 h
thestar.com | Toronto Star | Canada's...
University of Saskatchewan announces incoming chief athletics officer
Shannon Chinn will take over as the chief athletics officer on June 15.
2 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
What does 'cheugy' mean? The term that took off on TikTok, explained
A new word to describe people who are a bit out of fashion has taken over social media. Like it or not, you might be cheugy.
2 h
CTV News | Top Stories - Breaking News -...
UN gang killer Cory Vallee should get a new trial: defence lawyer
Judge who convicted gangster erred on witnesses’ credibility, late video disclosure, Eric Gottardi tells B.C. Court of Appeal
2 h
Vancouver News, Top Stories, Breaking...
Vaughn Palmer: Seat redistribution is a wake-up call for B.C. Liberals
Opinion: Party must figure out how to attract voters in B.C.'s urban majority
2 h
Vancouver News, Top Stories, Breaking...
Alberta justice minister apologizes after accusing feds, provincial NDP, media of wanting COVID-19 disaster
"I would like to offer an apology for my recent comments on my personal Facebook account," Kaycee Madu tweeted. "My comments were wrong."
2 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
CAQ government to table reforms to French Language Charter Thursday
After immigration and state secularism, the CAQ government is poised to send Quebec into a long debate about language. On Thursday the government will table what it calls "robust," changes to Bill 101.
2 h
Montreal Latest News, Breaking Headlines...
Edmonton police search for suspects in cellphone fraud investigation
Police said when a woman arrived to sell the phone, the man confronted her about the previous purchase.
2 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
COVID-19: Outdoor gear dwindles well before summer starts in Saskatchewan
Gear like bikes and kayaks is hard to come by as demand spikes and supplies dwindle.
3 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...