The 'other guy: Some of Canada's most infamous murderers who nearly got away with it

Almost 30 years after Guy Paul Morin, left, was wrongly convicted in the 1984 murder of nine-year-old Christine Jessop, this week he got his first glimpse of the real killer, Calvin Hoover.

Not every wrongfully convicted murderer gets to look the other guy in the eye.

Stephen Truscott, 75, for example, does not know who killed his classmate Lynne Harper in 1959, a murder for which he was wrongly sentenced to die, and served a decade in prison, before his 2007 acquittal and apology from Ontario for the miscarriage of justice.

Some do, eventually. David Milgaard spent 23 years in prison for the 1969 murder of Gail Miller, and had his conviction overturned in 1992, fully seven years before the real killer, Larry Fisher, was convicted with a DNA match.

Some are never quite sure. Robert Baltovich was cleared in the 1990 murder of his girlfriend Elizabeth Bain, in part for evidence supporting the unproven defence theory she was Paul Bernardo’s first murder victim.

Guy Paul Morin got his first glimpse of the other guy this week, nearly 30 years after he was wrongly convicted in the 1984 murder of nine-year-old Christine Jessop. He got to see a dated mugshot of Calvin Hoover, and learn from police that this real killer was dead. The case was closed by a DNA match, between semen found in Jessop’s underwear and blood taken during an autopsy after Hoover’s 2015 death.

This shows, according to Toronto Police, that it was Hoover, not Guy Paul Morin, who was there at that rural property 50 kilometres east of Jessop’s home in Queensville, Ont., where her body was discovered in a roadside copse of trees, back facing up, legs unnaturally twisted, naked but for white socks with blue trim, with her clothing strewn around.

 Nine-year-old Christine Jessop was sexually assaulted and stabbed to death in 1984.

The test was the final result of a genealogical analysis by an American lab that used the crime scene DNA to build a possible family tree based on available genetic information of millions of other people. The Toronto Star reported police had a judge approve the test before a final match was made.

“I am relieved for Christine’s mother, Janet, and her family, and hope this will give them some peace of mind,” Guy Paul Morin said in a statement through his lawyer. “I am grateful that the Toronto Police stayed on the case and have now finally solved it. When DNA exonerated me in January, 1995, I was sure that one day DNA would reveal the real killer and now it has.”

Few people can truly say anything like that.

Sometimes, for the wrongly accused, the other guy is actually a woman, or even a youth. Sometimes his identity is obvious. He may even be a co-accused, sitting right there in the same courtroom.

In the best-known such case, the 1971 killing of 17-year-old Sandy Seale in Nova Scotia, Donald Marshall, Jr., then 16, and a Mi’kmaw youth, was wrongly accused of stabbing his friend to death late at night in a Sydney park. He described the real killer Roy Ebsary to police, only to be disbelieved and wrongly convicted in a racist legal catastrophe that set the precedent for government compensation. Marshall, served 11 years in prison before Ebsary was convicted of manslaughter and served a year. Both men are now dead.

Sometimes there is no other guy at all. William Mullins-Johnson, for example, was convicted for a murder that never took place and spent 11 years in prison. His four-year-old niece, Valin, died in his care, which only became a false charge of murder through the twisted and false expert testimony of Charles Smith, a disgraced forensic pathologist.

In another case spoiled by Smith, Louise Reynolds spent two years in prison for the death of her two-year-old daughter Sharon, whose injuries from mauling by a pit bull were misinterpreted by Smith as an attack with scissors.

For many wrongful convictions, though, there is someone else out there, someone guilty who was wrongly overlooked.

Patterns of wrongful convictions reflect a society’s dominant ways of thinking about victims and perpetrators, and what sort of person is likely to be which. Public support for prosecutions also reflects thinking about police, and the likelihood that their suspect actually did it.

In this way of thinking, the notion that there is some other guy out there is often a paper tiger, dismissed out of hand as the flailing excuse of a caught killer, or the strategic fiction of his defence counsel. Sometimes, though, he becomes inevitably real.

The murderer of Christine Jessop has always existed as an anonymous presence, an evil lodestar in the life of Guy Paul Morin, and others like him who did time for someone else’s murder.

For the Canadian public, though, they leap onto the stage as if from nowhere.

 David Milgaard, left, spent 23 years in prison for the 1969 murder of Gail Miller before his wrongful conviction was overturned in 1992, seven years before the real killer, Larry Fisher, right, was convicted.

That is how Calvin Hoover entered the ranks of Canada’s worst child killers in an instant on Thursday. Police appealed for information about him, because hard experience has shown that killers tend to repeat.

Through his ordeal, Morin endured stereotypical thinking and tunnel vision that painted him as a creep. He suffered under the bogus authority of forensic science about microscopic hair comparison. He was belittled by efforts to blame him for his own misfortune, for the folly of talking to cellmate witnesses, for the suggestion he compounded his own misfortune or even brought this on himself.

Sometimes in wrongful convictions there seems to be an aspect of this shared blame. Romeo Phillion wrongly confessed to killing Leopold Roy, an Ottawa firefighter, in the early 1970s, and spent 31 years in prison before charges were withdrawn in 2010. Even as Marshal was being rightly acquitted, an appeal court called him “the author of his own misfortune.”

But this kind of justification of a miscarriage of justice — in which the accused shares some of the blame — seems more like a society trying to justify the wicked consequences of its first instincts, that this “weird” clarinet player Morin was surely the sort of guy to steal the little neighbour girl.

People tend not to believe in the other guy, the family friend.

Hoover’s revelation as the true murderer of Christine Jessop took two major DNA discoveries. The first, back in 1995, was negative for Guy Paul Morin, and it slapped Canada in the face.

“If Canada had capital punishment, Guy Paul Morin would simply be dead,” wrote the journalist Kirk Makin in his 1998 book about the case, Redrum The Innocent .

The second came just now, with the sickening realization that Christine Jessop’s murderer went unpunished for more than 30 years, and now, forever. This time, the other guy got away.


Load more
Read full article on: nationalpost.com
Durham coronavirus case spike could bring more restrictions to the region
Durham's top doctor is warning residents about the risk of heading back into Stage 2 as the region is not meeting several key monitoring health indicators.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Eight new coronavirus cases confirmed in Simcoe Muskoka, local total at 1,210
Of all the COVID-19 cases in the region, 85 per cent -- or 1,024 -- have recovered, while three remain in hospital.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Watch the second U.S. presidential debate between Joe Biden and Donald Trump: Live video
Watch Biden and Trump face off for a second time right here at 9 p.m. ET The post Watch the second U.S. presidential debate between Joe Biden and Donald Trump: Live video appeared first on Macleans.ca.
Macleans.ca - Canada's national...
Indigenous fisheries won’t have long-term impact on lobster conservation, biologist says
“That’s really the role of science – do decide what is true and what isn’t.”
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
‘How many people have to die’: Cote-des-Neiges–NDG mayor calls for overhaul of busy crossing
The borough mayor of NDG is calling on the city of Montreal to invest millions to redo an intersection considered dangerous.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Kids In Fort McMurray Can Once Again Receive Free Books From Dolly Parton
Dolly Parton continues to represent one of the few bright spots in this otherwise miserable year — this time, by bringing free books to the children of Fort McMurray, Alta.The country music legend’s Imagination Library monthly program delivers books to kidsfrom birth to age 5. It’s been active in Canada since 2006, but the Wood Buffalo branch hit a “funding gap” last year, a spokesperson told HuffPost Canada. The program relies on local fundraising initiatives, and when that funding dried up last October, over 1800 of the Fort McMurray kids enrolled in the program haven’t been receiving books. But as of Wednesday, it’s back with a new corporate sponsor (Telus) and a grant from the Canadian Red Cross and Employment and Social Development Canada. Kids in the Fort McMurray area will start getting their books again as of Nov. 1.“I am so excited to bring my Imagination Library back to the children and families of Fort McMurray!” Parton said in a press release. “It is such an important time to share the gift of books and reading with as many children as we can.”Parton started the program in part because of the low literacy rates in the rural area Tennessee where she grew up. Her own father never learned to read.“I created the Imagination Library as a tribute to my Daddy,” she wrote on the organization’s website. “He was the smartest man I have ever known but I know in my heart his inability to read probably kept him from fulfilling all of his dreams.”Most Canadian provinces and territories are part of the Imagination Library program, including Ontario, British Columbia, Manitoba, New Brunswick, Nova Scotia and Yukon. The books sent to Canadian kids include local authors and relevant topics. Some of the books on this year’s list include “The Darkest Dark,” by astronaut Chris Hadfield; a numbers book inspired by “Anne of Green Gables”; Sharon, Lois and Bram’s classic “Skinnamarink”; and “Encounter” by Anishinaabe writer Brittany Luby.Parton is certainly going above and beyond to try to keep 2020 afloat. Earlier this week, her rendition of the folk song “Bury Me Beneath the Willow” brought talk show host Stephen Colbert to tears.Sometimes you just need a good cry, even if it’s on national television
Huffington Post Canada - Canadian News...
A progressive federal budget and how to pay for it
Ed Broadbent and Brittany Andrew-Amofah: To 'build back better' Canada will need childcare, pharmacare, a green recovery—and new measures to sustain them The post A progressive federal budget and how to pay for it appeared first on Macleans.ca.
Macleans.ca - Canada's national...
Japanese clothing chain Uniqlo bets on downtown retail revival with new store
Uniqlo’s arrival, announced a year ago, may serve as a shot in the arm for Montreal’s central core.
Montreal Latest News, Breaking Headlines...
Is Ontario’s regional staged approach working amid the province’s second wave of COVID-19?
Many Ontario regions neighbouring coronavirus hot spots are still in Stage 3, prompting concerns that they'll become destinations for visitors looking to access services that aren't available in modified Stage 2.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Kelowna man arrested after three-day crime spree: RCMP
Bradford Cummins, 56, started his string of crimes on Oct.11, when he allegedly broke into a home in the 2000-block of Richter Street in Kelowna.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Trial of Will Jordan continues for third day; blood alcohol of victim was never tested
Blood was never submitted for toxicology analysis and no one noticed until months later — when it was too late.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Chuckegg Creek wildfire declared out after 17 months
The wildfire near the town of High Level started on May 12, 2019 and was caused by lightning.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Quebec sends ‘swat teams’ to control outbreaks of COVID-19 in 4 long-term care residences
The emergency field teams are being sent to bring COVID-19 outbreaks in four CHSLDs under control and eliminate further spread of the virus.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
West Island couple create COVID-19-friendly Halloween yard
A West Island couple have decided to go ahead with their haunted Halloween yard this year but are adapting it to make it COVID-19-friendly.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
‘It’s complete incompetency’: Frustration over lost Okanagan COVID-19 test
Interior Health is apologizing for losing a West Kelowna woman's COVID-19 test.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Former Sport Manitoba CEO and president Jeff Hnatiuk begins a new journey
Jeff Hnatiuk makes the jump from the Sport for Life building on Pacific to a new gig on Broadway in the span of one day.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Heather Scoffield: Hey Ottawa, there’s a pandemic. No one cares about your silly political games right now
The deep and impatient anger on Parliament Hill is simply not reflected in the mood of voters with COVID-19 on their minds, Heather Scoffield writes.
thestar.com | Toronto Star | Canada's...
Rick Salutin: The death cult around Donald Trump
In old Hollywood films, a human sacrifice is made by a priest to a god for a community. In Trump’s case that’s excluded. A greater being would obliterate his fragile sense of worth. It must be he who’s supreme and sacrifices others.
thestar.com | Toronto Star | Canada's...
Hamilton’s fraud and waste hotline hailed as an early success
The hotline gives staff, contractors and the public a confidential way to report wrongdoing on the part of City of Hamilton employees or departments.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Coronavirus: Curfews, restrictions expand across Europe as cases rise
Italy, Greece and France have all placed curfews amid the pandemic.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Mute buttons and plexiglass: Inside the final 2020 debate
The mute button is among a handful of changes implemented by the nonpartisan debate commission to help ensure a better sense of safety and order following the raucous opening debate 23 days ago.
thestar.com | Toronto Star | Canada's...
Moe meets supporters at “The Big Honkin’ rally for a strong Saskatchewan” in Regina
thestar.com | Toronto Star | Canada's...
Fraser Health doctor says multi-day events like weddings linked to higher cases of COVID-19 in B.C.
The CEO of Fraser Health says people should stick to the same six people beyond those in their household to keep cases low.
Vancouver News, Top Stories, Breaking...
Street preacher who allegedly broke Vancouver man’s leg charged with aggravated assault
A warrant has been issued for Dorre Love's arrest, police said Thursday.
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Gilead virus therapy remdesivir gains approval from FDA
Regulators had granted an emergency-use authorization for remdesivir earlier this year, and since then the drug has become a widely used therapy in hospitalized COVID-19 patients.
thestar.com | Toronto Star | Canada's...
Doug Ford Whips Out Cream Metaphor In Rant About Insurance Companies
Ontario Premier Doug Ford unleashed a figurative food fight with the insurance industry Thursday. “I’m fed up with these guys ... They have made a fortune over all these years,” he said during his daily press briefing. “They’re absolutely just refusing to insure people. We don’t play that game … You guys don’t get to get all the cream and gravy and the whipped cream and just slough off everything else and say, ‘We aren’t going to insure it.’”He said he’s heard stories of insurance companies refusing to insure shops and banquet halls.Since the COVID-19 pandemic began, some businesses have sued insurance companies for refusing to pay out claims related to government-ordered shutdowns. Rates are also rising for some companies, like gyms and restaurants, because the cost of insurance is based on the policy holder’s risk exposure, lawyer Scott Hawryliw told The Canadian Press. Earlier: Premier Ford pays homage to former rival Kathleen Wynne. Story continues after video. But one MPP said the issue came along before the pandemic.Independent MPP Jim Wilson asked the government Wednesday about skyrocketing insurance rates in his riding of Simcoe—Grey.“In the case of the Green Briar community in Alliston, they saw modest annual rate increases in the period leading up to 2018. Then out of nowhere, and with no claims, they were shocked to learn of their premium doubling to almost $16,000 in 2019,” Wilson said during question period at Queen’s Park. “Incredibly, it doubled again in 2020, to almost $30,000. Now, as a new year approaches, Green Briar is looking at another potential doubling, to $60,000, and that’s if they can get the insurance at all.”He called the insurance industry’s conduct “near criminal” and asked if the government would bring in more regulation on policy pricing. Finance Minister Rod Phillips said he’s aware of the “difficult matter” and had been meeting with affected customers, the industry and the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario.He also said his government’s new proposed law, Bill 218, which protects businesses from lawsuits related to COVID-19 exposure, will address “one of the factors that’s affecting the insurance industry.”An association representing long-term care homes has said homes are having trouble renewing their insurance because they are liable to be sued for exposing residents to COVID-19.Ford said Thursday that he’s heard about insurance companies just refusing to insure stores and banquet halls.“I can assure you that … The people are the priority,” he said. “Not the big insurance companies making gazillions of dollars.”READ MORE... Ford Defends Law That Makes It Harder To Sue For COVID-19 Exposure Even Without An Election, Trudeau Hits The Campaign Trail (Analysis) Ford Pays Homage To ‘Super Nice’ Wynne After She Says She Won’t Run Again
Huffington Post Canada - Canadian News...
U.S. Election 2020: Trump and Biden going head-to-head in Nashville in final presidential debate
You can watch the livestream of the debate at 9:00 p.m. ET here as part of the Star’s 2020 U.S. Election coverage.
thestar.com | Toronto Star | Canada's...
Your Social Media Rants And Racy Pics Are Costing You Job Opportunities
If you’re looking for a new job, you may want to pull down those racy pics or angry rants at your ex-boss from your Facebook page.Hiring managers are increasingly looking at applicants’ social media profiles in the hiring process, and of those who do, more than half ― 52 per cent ― have said something they found online caused them not to hire a candidate, according to a new survey of 500 Canadian hiring decision-makers.Seven in 10 hiring managers are now scouring the web to look into the people applying, according to the survey, carried out by The Harris Poll for human resources firm Express Employment Professionals.“Something as simple as typos in social media posts could cost you an interview,” said Bruce Hein, an Express franchise owner in Sarnia, Ont. Watch: How to cope with the loss of a job. Story continues below. Just don’t shut down or hide your social media presence ahead of a job search; that could backfire in some cases. The survey found a quarter of hiring managers won’t consider someone without a social media presence.But you should remove any pictures of excessive alcohol drinking or drug-taking, Express Employment recommends.“Remove any comments or posts in which a job seeker is complaining, ranting, swearing, bullying or otherwise communicating in a harsh manner towards others,” the company said in a report. Those types of comments make a job candidate look like they can’t handle pressure. Also, “delete those racy and saucy pictures from Cancun. If you wouldn’t want grandma to see it, then take it down.”RELATED Ontario Workers Protest Mid-Pandemic Layoffs For 72 Nursing Home Staff Canada Sees Record High Level Of Youth Not In School Or Work: StatCan Canada’s Low Earners Lost 1 In 5 Jobs, High Earners Gained Work In Pandemic That’s especially important if you’re looking for work where you would be acting as the face of your company, either with customers or suppliers, Hein said in an interview with HuffPost Canada.“We have to be cognizant of what we’re putting out there for everybody to see and hear,” he said.These days, it’s also important to be aware of the impact of any political messages you may be sending online, said Brent Pollington, an Express franchise owner in Vancouver. Employers may be sensitive to online comments that could be seen as discriminatory against particular groups.“Someone who’s got a MAGA hat on in a photo, some employers may be all over that person and want to hire them, and others may not want anything to do with them and the candidate wouldn’t even know it,” Pollington said.‘You’ve got choices to make’As an HR consultant, Pollington says he has seen “an employee terminated without cause … as a result of some less than favourable decisions they made on social media. They were in a position that was significant enough to have an impact on their customer base. The business had to make a critical decision.”The more prominent or senior the position, the likelier it is that social media presence will matter in the hiring process, Pollington told HuffPost Canada.Ask yourself what you want employers to see, he suggested.“You’ve got choices to make. You have the opportunity to go through your social media and make sure your social media aligns with the company where you’re applying.”
1 h
Huffington Post Canada - Canadian News...
COVID-19 cases confirmed at 2 Saskatoon schools
Two Saskatoon school divisions have each reported a case of COVID-19 in their schools.
1 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Feed Nova Scotia excited about Halifax Burger Week as it kicks off this weekend
Burger Week is one of the biggest fundraising events of the year for Feed Nova Scotia.
1 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Anti-gay preacher charged with assault in Vancouver's West End
Dorre Love faces one count of aggravated assault and a warrant has been issued for his arrest
1 h
Vancouver News, Top Stories, Breaking...
Coronavirus: Guelph reports 7 new COVID-19 cases with 2 in hospital
After seeing no hospitalizations for several days, two people in Guelph, Ont., are now being treated for COVID-19.
1 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Kim Kardashian Gets Painfully Real With David Letterman About Paris Robbery
Kim Kardashian thought she was going to die in 2016, when armed robbers burst into her hotel room in Paris and stole millions of dollars’ worth of jewels while holding her at gunpoint.The “Keeping Up With the Kardashians” star spoke about the terrifying incident in Wednesday’s episode of David Letterman’s new Netflix show, “My Next Guest Needs No Introduction.”She got emotional reliving the ordeal, as did her mom and her sisters, who were sitting in the audience with Kanye West.″[One of the masked robbers] grabbed me and I was wearing a robe and I wasn’t wearing anything under it,” Kardashian said, starting to cry. “‘OK, this is the time I’m going to get raped. Just deal, like, it’s gonna happen. You know? Like, just prepare yourself,’” she recalled thinking to herself. “So I did.”The KKW Beauty founder said the man then bound her with zip ties and duct taped her mouth and eyes. She kept telling the concierge, who was also in the room, to tell the men that she had a family waiting for her at home.Kardashian said she tried to bargain with the robbers, telling them they could take anything they wanted and she’d never turn them in.“I saw [a robber] have a gun out to me, and I was like, ‘OK, this is it,’” Kardashian said, adding that she just kept thinking about her older sister, Kourtney, who was also in Paris at the time and sharing a hotel room with Kardashian, but was out at a club that night.“I kept on thinking she’s going to come home and I’m going to be dead in the room,” Kardashian said. “And she’s going to be traumatized for the rest of her life if she sees me.”Against all odds, Kardashian survived physically unscathed, but emotionally and mentally scarred for years. The reality star said she’s “totally fine now,” but can only sleep if there are six security guards around the house. Still, Kardashian said she thinks it’s better that the incident happened to her instead of anyone else in her family.“I remember calling all my sisters from the car ― we were on a conference call. I said, ‘Guys, just thank God that was me,’” she said.″‘I am very mentally strong and that would have fucked all of your lives up for the rest of your life,’” she added as the audience laughed.Kardashian has previously said that she blamed herself for the robbery after living a “flashy” lifestyle and “oversharing my every move on social media.” But she told Alec Baldwin in 2018 that she’s “grateful” the incident occurred.“There was a lot of me that measured who I was by how much I had. I thought, ‘Oh, I’m worth so much.’ That needed to change in me,” she said on “The Alec Baldwin Show,” adding that she was “grateful for the experience.”“Even though it was horrific and I wouldn’t wish it upon anyone, it really did deeply change me to where now I feel like I can get back to myself,” Kardashian said. RELATED Kim Kardashian Is Starring In A ‘PAW Patrol’ Movie 20 Famous Kids Who Made The 2010s The Cutest Decade Yet 8 Ways The Kardashians Have Bettered The World. Yes, Really.
1 h
Huffington Post Canada - Canadian News...
Unregistered psychotherapist in Toronto charged in sexual assault investigation, police say
Toronto police alleged a woman was sexually assaulted during therapy sessions between 2011 and 2014.
1 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
Housing prices soar in Northumberland County
The average sale price of a home in Northumberland County soared to $595,559 in September.
2 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...
COVID-19 case numbers in Quebec at a deadly level, premier says
The chances of easing health measures soon are low, Legault says, urging Quebecers to work from home if possible.
2 h
Montreal Latest News, Breaking Headlines...
Vancouver police release video of suspect in robbery at gunpoint
Police say on Oct. 9 a man approached a young woman near Mainland and Helmcken streets, pointed a gun at her, and demanded she hand over her purse.
2 h
Vancouver News, Top Stories, Breaking...
Governments announce public inquiry into Nova Scotia mass shooting
Nova Scotia and Ottawa have established the inquiry into April's mass shooting, the province announced on Thursday afternoon.
2 h
Global News | Latest & Current News -...