Amy Comey Barrett, Trump’s Supreme Court nominee, has a years-long record of ruling against immigrants
Judge Amy Coney Barrett in 2018. | Rachel Malehorn via Wiki Commons At the Seventh Circuit, she backed one of Trump’s key immigration policies. Judge Amy Coney Barrett, President Donald Trump’s pick to replace the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg on the Supreme Court, has been an obstacle to the advancement of immigrant rights during her time on the Seventh Circuit — and if confirmed, may continue to impede immigrant rights on the Supreme Court. Barrett has helped to advance Trump’s policies during her three years as a federal appellate judge. She sided with Trump in a case over Trump’s policy imposing a wealth test on the millions of immigrants who seek to come to the US annually. In her whopping 40-page dissent in that case, she laid out why the US has the right to block people who it deems likely to become dependent on public assistance in the future — even if they have never used public assistance in the past. She has also repeatedly refused to review cases brought by immigrants applying for humanitarian protections and other immigration benefits who claimed they had been wrongfully denied. Some of those decisions may have negative repercussions for future such applicants; given that they set a precedent to be followed by judges in lower courts, these refusals could make it harder for immigrants to challenge an adverse decision from a consular officer on their visa application or obtain deportation relief from an immigration judge. If confirmed by the Senate, as is expected, Barrett could help Trump achieve his vision of an immigration system that is primarily concerned with keeping people out, particularly those from low-income backgrounds — and one that increasingly rewards skills and wealth over family ties to the US. (Though he has even imposed restrictions on skilled immigrants amid the pandemic.) The Supreme Court has upheld some of Trump’s signature immigration policies, including his travel ban policy. But it has also thwarted him at key moments: It has temporarily prevented him from ending the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, which has allowed more than 700,000 young unauthorized immigrants to live and work in the US, and blocked him from putting a citizenship question on the 2020 census, which experts said would depress response rates in immigrant communities. In those rulings against Trump, Chief Justice John Roberts joined the court’s liberals and cast deciding votes. But Barrett could tip the scales in favor of conservatives on high-profile immigration cases going forward, including one challenging Trump’s policy to exclude unauthorized immigrants from census population counts that will be used to redraw congressional districts in 2021 that will likely come before the justices by the end of the year. Here are some of the key immigration decisions Barrett has issued so far: She sided with Trump over one his its key immigration policies: The public charge rule. Perhaps Barrett’s most pivotal immigration ruling was her dissent in the case Cook County v. Wolf, in which the Seventh Circuit temporarily prevented the Trump administration from implementing its so-called “public charge” rule that created barriers to low-income immigrants seeking to enter the US. Published last year by the Department of Homeland Security, the rule establisheda test to determine whether an immigrant applying to enter the US, extend their visa, or convert their temporary immigration status into a green card is likely to end up relying on public benefits in the future. The rule has given immigration officialsmore leeway to turn away those who are “likely to be a public charge” based on an evaluation of 20 factors, ranging from the use of certain public benefits programs — including food stamps, Section 8 housing vouchers, and Medicaid — to English-language proficiency. It represents one of President Trump’s biggest blows to legal immigration so far. In June, a majority of the Seventh Circuit voted to strike down the rule, arguing that it “set[s] a trap for the unwary by penalizing people for accepting benefits Congress made available to them.” In her 40-page dissent, Barrett said that she would have upheld the rule, arguing that those challenging it had set forth an exceedingly narrow definition of what it means to be a “public charge” that isn’t consistent with federal law. “Congress’s willingness to authorize funds to help immigrants who encounter unexpected trouble is perfectly consistent with its reluctance to admit immigrants whose need for help is predictable upon arrival,” she wrote in her dissent. The rule went into effect again earlier this month following another federal court ruling. It has affected immigrants applying for green cards nationwide and at consulates abroad, as well as those applying for temporary visas overseas such as tourists, business travelers, students, and skilled workers. The administration hasn’t released detailed data on how many people have been affected by the rule. But Julia Gelatt, a senior policy analyst at the nonpartisan think tank Migration Policy Institute, told Vox that 69 percent of the roughly 5.5 million people who were granted green cards over the past five years would have had at least one negative factor under the rule — which officials could have used as justification to reject their applications for immigration benefits. She dismissed a man’s claim for humanitarian protections In August 2018, Barrett refused to review a Salvadoran citizen’s petition for humanitarian protection in the US, which had been dismissed by immigration judges who didn’t find him to be a credible witness. Gerson Alvarenga-Flores had testified that he fled El Salvador after witnessing his friend’s murder at the hands of criminal gang members, who consequently threatened him. After he was apprehended at the border and detained, he claimed that he feared returning to his home country and applied for several forms of humanitarian protection, including asylum and protections under the Convention Against Torture. The immigration judge in his case found inconsistencies in Alvarenga’s testimony: He once claimed that he had been attacked by gang members while in a taxi and, on another occasion, said he was approached by them on a bus. Alvarenga explained that he gave the testimony in English, even though he does not speak English, which could have led to the confusion. But the judge nevertheless concluded that his account of being targeted by gangs wasn’t credible, without even considering whether he would have deserved humanitarian protection. Writing an opinion on behalf of a panel of Seventh Circuit judges, Barrett deferred to the immigration judge, agreeing that Alvarenga was unable to provide an adequate explanation for the discrepancies in his account. “These two encounters with gang members were crucial to Alvarenga’s claim that gang members were likely to torture him if he returned to El Salvador, yet he could not keep the facts straight with respect to either one,” she wrote. She ruled against a US citizen challenging his wife’s visa denial In January 2019, Barrett refused to reconsider a case brought by a naturalized US citizen, Moshin Yafai, whose wife Zahoor Ahmed, a citizen of Yemen, was twice denied a green card. The consular officer had denied Ahmed’s green card on the grounds that she allegedly tried to smuggle her two children across the border, even though Ahmed and her husband had provided documentation to the embassy that their children had died in a drowning accident. Writing the Seventh Circuit’s majority opinion, Barrett found that the consular officer nevertheless did not appear to act in bad faith and even asked for more information, “suggest[ing] a desire to get it right.” That meant that her court couldn’t review the consular officer’s decision, she said. The ruling could make it harder for visa applicants to challenge arbitrary denials down the line. Generally, courts can’t review the decisions of consular officers, who interview applicants for immigration benefits and decide whether or not to approve their visas or green cards. There is a narrow exception in the law that allows a US citizen to challenge a consular officer’s decision if it infringes on one of their constitutional rights. But it’s not clear whether one of those constitutional rights is to live with one’s spouse in the US, as Yafai had argued, she said. “The status of this right is uncertain,” she wrote in the opinion. “Even if the denial of Ahmed’s visa application implicated a constitutional right of Yafai’s, his claim fails because the consular officer’s decision was facially legitimate and bona fide.” She voted to deport a man who maintained lawful permanent residency for 30 years In June 2019, Barrett cast the deciding vote in a Seventh Circuit case resulting in the immediate deportation of a Mexican immigrant who had been a lawful permanent resident of the US for three decades and first arrived in the US at age 10. He had been convicted for drug crimes resulting in a more than 10 year prison sentence, but because his mother was a US citizen, he believed he had a right to remain in the US. The immigrant, Ruben Lopez Ramos, was not given the chance to argue that his deportation violated his rights under the Constitution’s Equal Protection clause. A short, one-paragraph order sealed his fate, claiming that his argument was “irrational” and had “little chance of succeeding.” One of Barrett’s colleagues, dissenting, argued that Ramos should have been given his day in court, noting that, due to a now-repealed law, he would have derived US citizenship from his mother had she lived in the US prior to his birth and he could not have been deported. Ramos argued that he was subjected to differential treatment under that law in violation of his Equal Protection rights. “He might be right,” US Circuit Judge David Hamilton wrote. Ultimately, however, due to Barrett’s vote, the Seventh Circuit never considered the issue.
9 m
The fantasy baseball players who made or wrecked your season
There’s no denying 2020 has been a weird year, with good news seeming to come about as often as trucks delivering Purell hand sanitizer (not the off-brand stuff) to your local drug store. Though there were many obstacles along the way, baseball’s 60-game season will be completed on Sunday. This is amazing news! Your fantasy...
Column: It's never too early to say 'I told you so' about Rams
If you think the Rams were overhyped, think again. Times columnist LZ Granderson knows the score.
McConnell: Trump 'could not have made a better decision'
White Sox P Cordero suspended 3 games for hitting Contreras
Major League Baseball suspended Chicago White Sox reliever Jimmy Cordero for three games Saturday and fined him an undisclosed amount for hitting the Cubs' Willson Contreras with a pitch.
Oregon environmentalist George Atiyeh confirmed dead in Beachie Creek Fire, family says
Aniese Mitchell, Atiyeh's daughter, confirmed his death on Facebook.
Voters' poorly marked ovals could lead to contested ballots
Two decades ago, hanging chads on Florida ballots became the unlikely symbol of a disputed presidential election
Trump nominates Amy Coney Barrett to replace Ruth Bader Ginsburg on Supreme Court
President Trump has named Judge Amy Coney Barrett as his choice to replace late Associate Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg on the Supreme Court — a long-sought victory for conservatives and the anti-abortion movement. “I stand  before you today to fulfill one of my highest and most important duties under the United States Constitution,” Trump said....
How Trump, Biden are preparing for first presidential debate
Ahead of the first debate-stage matchup between President Donald Trump and his Democratic challenger Joe Biden, each campaign is promising a stark contrast in policy, personality and preparation
Amy Coney Barrett: Talented judge, popular professor brings solid conservative credentials
Her nomination to the seat held for 27 years by liberal Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg makes Barrett's nomination the most contentious in decades.
LeMahieu batting title, Voit HR crown near as Yanks win
DJ LaMahieu moved into position to become the first player to earn undisputed batting titles in both leagues, Luke Voit hit his major league-leading 22nd homer and the New York Yankees rediscovered their power in a 11-4 win over the Miami Marlins on Saturday.
The President selects the conservative federal appeals court judge for the US Supreme Court
Trump nominates Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court. What happens next in Senate confirmation process
Now that Trump has named Amy Coney Barrett as his nominee to the Supreme Court, the Senate can start its nomination process.
No. 5 Florida beats Ole Miss 51-35 in Kiffin's debut
Kyle Pitts caught four of Kyle Trask's six touchdown passes and No. 5 Florida spoiled the head coaching debut of Mississippi’s Lane Kiffin with a 51-35 victory Saturday.
Trump nominates Amy Coney Barrett for Supreme Court
President Donald Trump announces the nomination of Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court to fill the vacancy left by the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg.
Donald Trump Nominates Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court
President Donald Trump nominated Judge Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court on Saturday evening, igniting what is set to be a titanic fight in the Senate over filling the seat left open after the death of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, just weeks before Election Day. With Barrett standing beside him in the Rose Garden,…
Nix, No. 8 Auburn pull away from No. 23 Kentucky, 29-13
Bo Nix threw for 233 yards and three second-half touchdowns, including a pair to Seth Williams, and No. 8 Auburn scored twice in the fourth quarter to pull away from No. 23 Kentucky for a 29-13 victory Saturday in the season opener.
Who is Amy Coney Barrett, Trump's pick for the Supreme Court?
President Trump on Saturday announced Judge Amy Coney Barrett as his nominee for the Supreme Court
Who Was the First Female on the Supreme Court? Trump Becomes 5th President to Nominate a Woman
Women only account for 3 percent of the total Supreme Court justice nominees but they've been confirmed every time the Senate has voted.
No. 21 Pitt's holds off No. 24 Louisville 23-20
Kenny Pickett threw for 220 yards and two touchdowns, and No. 21 Pittsburgh sacked Louisville quarterback Malik Cunningham seven times in a 23-20 victory on Saturday.
Amy Coney Barrett, a disciple of Justice Scalia, is poised to push the Supreme Court further right
If Barrett is confirmed, her vote on cases involving health care, abortion, immigration, gun control and many other issues could prove decisive.
New York Reports Over 1,000 New COVID Cases for First Time in 113 Days
There were 1,005 positive COVID-19 cases counted on September 25, Governor Andrew Cuomo announced Saturday. Nearly 100,000 tests were conducted statewide, keeping the positivity rate at 1 percent.
5 Things to Know About Amy Coney Barrett, Donald Trump's Supreme Court Pick
Trump nominated Barrett on Saturday afternoon.
Donald Trump Nominates Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court
The president's choice demonstrates he did not waver from the idea of choosing Barrett to replace Ginsburg with another woman on the Supreme Court.
Amy Coney Barrett named President Trump's third Supreme Court nominee
Amy Coney Barrett, a Catholic, law professor and Court of Appeals judge, is President Donald Trump's pick for his third Supreme Court nomination.
Amy Coney Barrett confirmation fight: Senate GOP has math on their side
Senate Republicans have the math on their side when it comes to the confirmation of Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court.
Women’s March co-founder blasts Kentucky AG after Breonna Taylor decision
"You are a coward, you are a sellout," Tamika Mallory, the founder of United Freedom and one of the organizers of the 2017 Women's March, said during a rally in Louisville Friday.
Newt Gingrich: Amy Coney Barrett and Democrats' big dilemma
President Trump’s nomination of Judge Amy Coney Barrett creates a real dilemma for the Democrats.
Jessica Tarlov: Trump nominates Amy Coney Barrett for Supreme Court and Democrats must get to work
It has been just a little over a week since the death of Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Trump has kept his word.
John Yoo: Amy Coney Barrett and Dems – Left will try to turn one of her greatest strengths into her weakness
President Donald Trump has kept his campaign promise and nominated an outstanding conservative woman for the Supreme Court.
LSU star Derek Stingley Jr. ruled out for Mississippi State game after being hospitalized Friday
LSU CB Derek Stingley Jr. will miss Saturday's game against Mississippi State after being hospitalized Friday with a non-COVID-related illness.
Dennis Quaid Responds to Reports He is Involved with a Secret Plot to Re-Elect the President
Dennis Quaid spoke to Dr. Anthony Fauci about the importance of wearing masks during the coronavirus pandemic. Now the actor is accusing the press of needlessly politicizing the conversation.
Sen. Mike Braun: Confirm Amy Coney Barrett without delay
Judge Amy Coney Barrett is a consummately qualified jurist.
Tom Cotton Creates 'War Room' to Defend Trump's Supreme Court Nominee
Sen. Tom Cotton (R-AR) has launched a "Supreme Court War Room" to help Republicans defend President Donald Trump's Supreme Court nominee against attacks from those on the left.
Hero K9 Officer Catches Suspect During Marijuana Raid
A U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) Forest Service K9 officer is being hailed a hero for catching a suspect during a marijuana raid in August.
New Yorkers can now text emergencies to 911 rather than phoning it in
A 51-year-old South Bronx man was torn about what to do when he saw an angry young man with a pistol in his backpack fighting with another person at a crowded neighborhood deli. He was worried about gunshots — but was wary about calling 911. “I used to be a knucklehead myself,” said the witness,...
Students are traveling thousands of miles to take SAT amid COVID-19 cancellations
As SAT and ACT exams are canceled across the country — or full due to limited seating — high-school seniors are traveling thousands of miles to take the college admissions tests.
Nats stay mum on Dave Martinez contract details, but team and manager appreciate the stability
A person with knowledge of the terms of the deal said Dave Martinez is set to remain the Nationals’ manager through 2022.
Watch Live: Donald Trump Announces His Choice to Fill Supreme Court Vacancy
The announcement is scheduled for 5:00 p.m. EST.
‘Power Rangers’ Exclusive: It’s The ‘Avengers: Endgame’ of Mighty Morphin’ Team-ups in This ‘Beast Morphers’ Sneak Peek
Dino Thunder, Dino Charge and the OG Mighty Morphin' Power Rangers all team up with the Beast Morphers.
Amy Coney Barrett's Expected Supreme Court Nomination Sets Up Battle Over Her Role in Election Lawsuits
Democratic senators argue she cannot possibly be viewed as impartial in potential legal challenges over the presidential election.
Utility futility: Answer Man explores the wild world of utility pole numbers
A pole can last decades and be used by many utilities. That’s why there’s no easy system.
How Trump laid groundwork for election result mayhem
CNN's Ana Cabrera looks back at the ways President Donald Trump has laid the groundwork for election rigging claims since 2016.
Prince fined bassist for mistakes and ‘cheated’ him out of millions, memoir reveals
For Mark Brown, the head games began with a cold call from Prince in 1981. And they ended, six years later, with the bassist — rechristened BrownMark, by Prince — confident that the rock star had derailed him out of millions in songwriting royalties. As related in BrownMark’s new memoir, “My Life in the Purple...
Analysis: Spencer Rattler starts strong, but struggles late as No. 3 Oklahoma is shocked by Kansas State
Freshman quarterback Spencer Rattler, an early Heisman Trophy favorite, threw for four touchdowns but had three interceptions and key misses late.
Four-time All-Star, San Francisco Giants cult hero Hunter Pence announces retirement
Pence played 14 years in the majors, winning World Series titles with the Giants in 2012 and 2014.