An Experiment in Wisconsin Might Reveal the Key to Defeating Trump

No state has haunted the Democratic Party’s imagination for the past four years like Wisconsin. While it was not the only state that killed Hillary Clinton’s presidential hopes in 2016, it was the one where the knife plunged deepest. Clinton was so confident about Wisconsin that she never even campaigned there. This year, it is one of the most fiercely contested states. The Democrats planned to hold their convention in Milwaukee, before the coronavirus pandemic forced its cancelation. Donald Trump is also making a strong play for Wisconsin.

Trump’s weaknesses with the electorate are familiar: Voters find him coarse, and they deplore his handling of race, the coronavirus, and protests. One recent YouGov poll found that just 42 percent of Americans approved of his performance as president, while 54 percent disapproved. But when the pollsters asked about Trump’s handling of the economy, those attitudes reversed: 48 percent approved and 44 percent disapproved, despite the havoc wreaked by the pandemic.

The high marks that voters give Trump’s economic record are a key obstacle to Democratic efforts to win back Wisconsin and other upper-midwestern states. But a surprisingly effective progressive effort this spring to undermine Trump’s approval ratings on the economy provides a model for how the president’s opponents can hurt Trump where he’s strongest—and maybe even tip the election to Joe Biden.

[David A. Graham: Brace for the blue shift]

Changing voters’ minds is famously difficult. Recent national campaigns have spent more effort on increasing turnout—getting sympathetic voters to go to the polls—than on winning over new supporters. Political scientists and pollsters have found that as the country grows more negatively polarized, fewer true swing voters are up for grabs.

But the Wisconsin effort, notable for both its approach and its scale, seems to have found some success. From February to May, the advocacy group Opportunity Wisconsin, with help from a progressive advocacy organization based in Washington, D.C., called the Hub Project, managed to do remarkable damage to Trump’s standing with a group of persuadable voters. The effort sought to identify voters who took a favorable view of Trump’s record on the economy but who might still be receptive to alternative perspectives, then spent weeks targeting them with messages arguing that the economy was actually not working for Wisconsin, and that Trump’s policies weren’t helping.

“The most impressive thing is that they clearly had some effect in changing how people think about Donald Trump, and that’s just really difficult to do,” says David Broockman, a political scientist at UC Berkeley who studies persuasion. “For a real program to have effects on what people think about Trump in the field, not an artificial setting like a focus group, is quite impressive. There’s very little I’ve seen this election cycle that has found that.”

Research by Broockman and Yale’s Josh Kalla from earlier this year showed that while messages about Biden could swing voters’ opinions about him, views about Trump were almost immovable.

The Opportunity Wisconsin push was built on a combination of tactics old and new, simple and sophisticated. The group is official nonpartisan, and does not disclose its donors. But Meghan Roh, a former Democratic House and Senate staffer who is the group’s program director, told me it was formed out of a concern that progressive organizations weren’t speaking effectively to people in Wisconsin. Trump’s strong economic numbers in the state jumped out as a perfect example.

As my colleague Ronald Brownstein reported in 2019, citing Hub Project research, a potentially crucial group of voters approves of Trump’s handling of the economy, but is skeptical of his overall performance. The president’s numbers on the economy remain a rare bright spot for him, even amid coronavirus-induced economic devastation. Just a few months ago, there was routinely a double-digit spread between those who approved and disapproved of his handling of the economy—but Trump's numbers remain narrowly positive, according to RealClearPolitics’ average.

The national trend holds true in Wisconsin. In a recent Marquette Law School poll, 51 percent of Wisconsinites approved of Trump’s handling of the economy, versus 46 percent who did not. (In the same poll, respondents favored Biden over Trump, 48 percent to 42 percent.)

With Trump even more embattled than he was a year ago, these voters who approve of Trump on the economy but not on much else are even more crucial in November. Opportunity Wisconsin saw this as a classic chance to attack an opponent’s strength, rather than his weakness.

[Read: Wisconsin's warning for the November election]

“There was this perception that the president’s economic strength was based on the stock market or jobs numbers, but when you drilled down a little more and had conversations with people about their own experience, they did not see any benefit from the president's tax law or his opposition to raising the minimum wage,” Roh says.

The plan was to figure out how to convince voters in Wisconsin, on a large scale, that Trump’s handling of the economy was actually worse than they thought. Opportunity Wisconsin and the Hub Project started with a survey of 27,000 voters, designed to identify persuadable Wisconsinites.

Then Opportunity Wisconsin conducted focus groups around the state, trying to identify voters who might be persuadable and the values that mattered to them. They zeroed in on people who were sympathetic to conservative economic ideas but also concerned about what they saw in their own families and communities. For example, some participants talked about the importance of low taxes and reducing regulation, but also complained that the cost of living was rising too quickly and the economy was working only for the wealthy.

Drawing on this research, the Hub Project selected roughly 500,000 voters to target in a larger push, using voting history and consumer data in addition to standard demographic data. For the purposes of measuring how effective its work was, it split the whole into a treatment group, which would receive targeted messages, and a control group, which would not.

Identifying a group of persuadable voters is not the same as knowing both what messages to send them and how to send them. Opportunity Wisconsin found messengers who could speak to local issues around the state—meatpacking in Green Bay, farming in the Driftless Area. A man in Green Bay described being unable to make his rent, even as the company whose factory he worked in got big tax breaks under the 2017 tax cuts. A Wauwatosa woman recounted how she got a second job to pay off her student loans, but then lost both of her jobs due to the pandemic. “President Trump only started to acknowledge this crisis after Wall Street started to suffer,” she said.

Then Opportunity Wisconsin launched a big effort to push these messages out from February to May. The group featured the stories it gathered in videos posted on social media and in paper fliers sent to mailboxes—roughly one a week for 11 weeks, an unusually large volume. Some of the messengers told their stories at gatherings, alongside officeholders such as Senator Tammy Baldwin and Lieutenant Governor Mandela Barnes, both Democrats. (These gatherings were planned to be held in person around the state, but most of them had to be switched to digital because of the pandemic.)

[Read: ‘I am stunned’: Wisconsin Democrats’ improbable victory]

The Hub Project then conducted a new survey of the large group to measure the effects of the messages. The results surprised even the groups: The push knocked Trump’s approval on the economy down by 2.3 percent, approval of his tax cuts down more than 5 percent, and belief that his policies helped the Badger State down more than 8 percent. (The 2016 race in Wisconsin was decided by less than 1 percent of voters, or about 23,000 votes.) The effects were larger than those of most Trump-focused persuasion efforts, and the use of a control group means the results are highly reliable.

What the numbers don’t explain is why this worked so well: Was it the tailored local messages? The heavy volume of mail? Some combination of the two? The results do, however, provide some proof of concept. “The central thesis of this program was: Can we identify a group or groups of Americans who are open to hearing a progressive argument about the economy? And if we make that argument, can we win that argument?” says Bryan Bennett, the director of polling and analytics at the Hub Project. “This says yes.”

The results open new lines of research for campaign groups such as Opportunity Wisconsin and for scholars of persuasion such as Broockman. But the most pressing question for the election is what effect the campaign might have had on Trump’s chances. Opportunity Wisconsin didn’t measure voter preference, and there’s no easy way to know whether souring voters on Trump’s economic policies is enough to get them to change their vote. Persuasion effects also tend to decay closer to Election Day, as voters are bombarded with messaging from all sides.

“The big question is how significant the economy is in voter decisions, as opposed to cultural issues,” Charlie Sykes, a longtime Wisconsin conservative commentator and prominent Trump critic, told me. The president has already made clear he intends to emphasize wedge social issues in the remaining weeks of the campaign. The question is whether voters buy it. “I look at those numbers and think, If this is the one thing that’s holding Trump up, then he’s in a lot of trouble. Because if you knock out that leg, what’s he got left?”

Load more
Read full article on:
Bryson DeChambeau in US Open hunt despite ‘pathetic’ self-critique
Bulked-up Bryson DeChambeau generally has operated under a “Big Hitter, the Lama” mindset since the PGA Tour restarted earlier this summer, hauling off and smashing historically long drives without regret or apology. “Caddyshack” references aside, DeChambeau’s decision to eschew his mighty driver for a hybrid on the final hole Sunday may have cost him an...
Lincoln Project fiercely condemns possible SCOTUS nomination by Trump
The Lincoln Project, a conservative political action committee, joined the masses in posting a message noting their condolences for the loss of Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, on twitter Friday.
Dallas Stars top Tampa Bay Lightning for 1-0 lead in Stanley Cup Final
Dallas' Joel Hanley, Jamie Oleksiak and Joel Kiviranta scored in the first two periods and the Stars survived the Lightning's third-period surge.
Miami Hurricanes unveil incredible 2020 Turnover Chain after Al Blades Jr.'s interception
The Miami Hurricanes unveiled their 2020 Turnover Chain on Saturday night when Al Blades Jr. intercepted Louisville's Malik Cunningham.
Tigers manager Ron Gardenhire retires: ‘I have to take care of myself’
DETROIT — Ron Gardenhire mostly maintained his jovial demeanor this season. As recently as Friday night, he was needling a reporter while discussing a strategic decision from the late innings. Less than 24 hours later, Gardenhire announced his retirement. This year was taking more of a toll on the 62-year-old Detroit Tigers manager than he’d...
Griffin Yow, 17, gets his first MLS goal as D.C. United rallies to a 2-2 draw with Toronto FC
The teenager's goal in the 88th minute gave scuffling D.C. a draw with Toronto FC at Audi Field.
Simi Valley's Matthew Wolff leads U.S. Open heading into final round
At 21, Matthew Wolff is looking to win his first major after skillfully navigating treacherous Winged Foot to take a two-stroke lead heading into Sunday.
Raju: This could complicate a lame-duck session even further
CNN's Manu Raju examines how Republican stances on filling Supreme Court vacancies have changed throughout the years, and are coming to a head following the death of Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg.
Congress releases scathing report on Boeing 737 Max
In a newly released report on Boeing’s 737 Max, congressional investigators heavily criticized the airplane manufacturer for ignoring blatant flaws in its system. The report also lays blame on the FAA for not thoroughly investigating the plane that led to the deaths of 346 people. Kris Van Cleave has more.
Election officials prepare for historic numbers of mail-in ballots
Anticipating a historic surge of mail-in ballots this November, local election officials are ramping up preparation to meet the demands. Some states are looking into changing laws to make processing easier. Major Garrett reports.
Candace Owens accuses Amazon of damaging her new book: ‘This is unacceptable’
The outspoken Owens took to Twitter to accuse the retail giant's employees of damaging her tome, "Blackout."
Twitter reacts to Khamzat Chimaev's 17-second KO of Gerald Meerschaert at UFC on ESPN+ 36
Twitter reacts to Khamzat Chimaev's 17-second KO of Gerald Meerschaert at UFC on ESPN+ 36        Related StoriesUFC on ESPN+ 35 reactions: Winning and losing fighters on social mediaBellator 246 reactions: Winning and losing fighters on social mediaUFC on ESPN+ 36 play-by-play and live results (5 p.m. ET)
Donald Trump Says 29 Presidents Were Allowed a Supreme Court Nomination In The Final Year of a Term
"Think of it, 29 times. Every single time, nobody said, 'Oh, let's not fill the seat.' We won the election," Trump said.
Tropical Storm Beta threatens Gulf Coast
The Gulf Coast is on watch yet again for another tropical storm. There have been so many storms this season that forecasters are now using the Greek alphabet to name them.
Video: Khamzat Chimaev KOs Gerald Meerschaert in just 17 seconds at UFC on ESPN+ 36
The Khamzat Chimaev hype train gained more steam when he knocked out Gerald Meerschaert in 17 seconds at UFC on ESPN+ 36.        Related StoriesVideo: Khamzat Chimaev KOs Gerald Meerschaert in just 17 seconds at UFC on ESPN+ 36 - EnclosureUFC on ESPN+ 36 results: Johnny Walker rallies, finishes Ryan Spann in short, wild fightUFC on ESPN+ 36 results: Johnny Walker rallies, finishes Ryan Spann in short, wild fight - Enclosure
President Trump contradicts health officials on vaccine distribution timeline
As the nation approaches 200,000 coronavirus deaths, President Trump continues to insist vaccines will be available for mass distribution by April, contradicting the claims of health officials. CDC Director Robert Redfield said one would most likely be ready by late 2021. Michael George reports.
Dolly Parton remembers RBG in poetic message
Legendary country music singer and actress Dolly Parton paid tribute to the late Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg in a tweet Saturday.
Why China is a threat to the US — and the entire free world
Beijing is accusing Washington of “hegemony and provocation” — for telling the truth about China’s ever-more-aggressive moves toward hegemony and provocation. It’d be laughable, except the Chinese Communist Party’s increasing crackdowns at home and influence-seeking abroad are no joke. China’s criticism was an answer to the Pentagon’s latest “China Military Power Report,” which notes the...
Supreme Court vacancy shakes up presidential election
This Saturday, President Trump continued his campaign trail with a rally in Fayetteville, North Carolina, as voters anxiously speculated who he might pick to replace the late Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Democratic nominee Joe Biden has not announced any potential picks should he be given the opportunity to nominate a Supreme Court justice. Nikole Killion reports.
Republicans pushing ahead to fill Ginsburg’s vacated seat
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell is vowing to hold a vote on President Trump’s eventual Supreme Court nominee, despite blocking former President Obama’s pick during an election year. Democrats are pushing back, insisting the vote be held after the November election. Nancy Cordes has more.
Party leaders indicate that if they win the majority, they may retaliate against Republicans by pushing to expand the court
It was an October day on Saturday, exactly one month early
Our highs and lows for Sept. 19 matched those for Oct. 19.
Remembering the legacy of Ruth Bader Ginsburg
Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg died Friday at the age of 87 after battling pancreatic cancer. Ginsburg was an icon in the fight for women’s rights even before she became a Supreme Court justice. Paula Reid has more on her groundbreaking career and legacy.
"CBS Weekend News" headlines for Saturday, September 19, 2020
Here's a look at the top stories making headlines on the "CBS Weekend News with Major Garrett."
Women vow to continue RBG's legacy
"It is our time to fight. This is our future and the future of the next generation," one woman said.
UFC on ESPN+ 36 results: Johnny Walker rallies, finishes Ryan Spann in short, wild fight
Needing a win, Johnny Walker delivered Saturday night in Las Vegas.        Related StoriesUFC on ESPN+ 36 results: Johnny Walker rallies, finishes Ryan Spann in short, wild fight - EnclosureUFC on ESPN+ 36 results: Mackenzie Dern sweeps, submits Randa MarkosUFC on ESPN+ 36 results: Mackenzie Dern sweeps, submits Randa Markos - Enclosure
Torch-inspired Tokyo skyscraper to become Japan's tallest building
The 390-meter-high (1,279 feet) skyscraper, inspired by a flaming torch, is set to become Japan's tallest tower when it opens in 2027.
1 h
Torch-inspired Tokyo skyscraper to become Japan's tallest building
1 h
Why the country needs a filled Supreme Court for the 2020 election: Goodwin
By telling Senate Republicans Saturday they have an obligation to fill “without delay” the Supreme Court seat left vacant by the death of Ruth Bader Ginsburg, President Trump sets in motion a process that could dominate the remaining weeks of the presidential election. The issue will further galvanize core supporters for both sides, but if...
1 h
Toobin: The Supreme Court is not paralyzed by a vacancy
A fierce political battle is underway over who will replace Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg's seat and when a vote will take place. CNN's Jeffrey Toobin explains how the Supreme Court cases are decided when only eight justices are seated.
1 h
Woman helping teachers get school supplies
1 h
UFC on ESPN+ 36 results: Mackenzie Dern sweeps, submits Randa Markos
Mackenzie Dern promised a slick submission win over Randa Markos at UFC on ESPN+ 36, and that's exactly what she delivered.        Related StoriesUFC on ESPN+ 36 results: Mackenzie Dern sweeps, submits Randa Markos - EnclosureUFC on ESPN+ 36 video: Damon Jackson upsets Mirsad Bektic on 3 days' noticeUFC on ESPN+ 36 video: Damon Jackson upsets Mirsad Bektic on 3 days' notice - Enclosure 
1 h
Ex-NBA guard Ty Lawson banned from Chinese team for ‘inappropriate comments’
Former NBA player Ty Lawson has been banned from the Chinese Basketball Association after allegedly making derogatory and offensive Instagram posts regarding Chinese women, according to multiple reports. The Fujian Sturgeons — the Chinese team Lawson has played for since 2019 — said the 32-year-old Lawson will no longer be on the team, severing ties...
1 h
Ginsburg's Death A 'Pivot Point' For Abortion Rights, Advocates Say
The death of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg sets up a brutal nomination fight, and abortion rights is likely to be a contentious issue.
1 h
'RBG' documentary filmmakers reflect on Ruth Bader Ginsburg's extraordinary life
Directors Julie Cohen and Betsy West spent years with the late Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg to make their Oscar-nominated film 'RBG.'
2 h
How the Supreme Court operates with only 8 justices
A nomination battle is brewing in the wake of the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg's death Friday. While it is unclear how long there will be a vacant seat, the Supreme Court will almost certainly begin its new term on Oct. 5th with eight members.
2 h
RCMP says letter containing ricin sent to White House
Initial information indicated the letters originated in Canada, the Royal Canadian Mounted Police said.
2 h
Dutch pursuit of torture case against Syria prompts terror accusation from Damascus
The Syrian government accused the Dutch government of supporting terrorism on Saturday in response to the Netherlands' invocation of an anti-torture convention against Damascus.
2 h
Donald Trump Jokes: 'Sleepy Joe' Biden Will Get 'Big Fat Shot in the Ass' Before Debate
"Don't underestimate him, look, he's been doing this for 47 years," Trump said. "You never know. They give him a big fat shot in the ass and he comes out, and for two hours he's better than ever before."
2 h
News Analysis: RBG's successor could push the Supreme Court to end abortion rights and Obamacare
Democrats could win the election and lose the Supreme Court for a generation
2 h
Lakers might start Dwight Howard for Game 2 vs. Nuggets
Reserve center Dwight Howard had a critical impact in the Lakers' series-opening win over Denver. Coach Frank Vogel said the veteran might start Game 2.
2 h
Christina Anstead splits from husband Ant Anstead after nearly 2 years of marriage
Christina Anstead and her husband Ant Anstead are calling it quits.
2 h
California cool, Matthew Wolff takes detour to US Open lead
Matthew Wolff might be too young to realize he's supposed to hit fairways to have a chance to win the U.S. Open. Or maybe he's so good it doesn't matter.
2 h
Stream It Or Skip It: ‘Gemini Man’ On Amazon Prime Video, Where Will Smith Plays A Sniper On The Run From His Younger Self
Ang Lee's ground-breaking sci-fi action thriller gifts the world with two Will Smiths.
2 h
Falcons' Hayden Hurst helps get TV director's puppy life-saving operation
Atlanta Falcons tight end Hayden Hurst donated thousands of dollars to a TV director’s online fundraiser to help save the family’s puppy.
2 h
Lawrence, No. 1 Clemson overwhelm The Citadel 49-0
 Trevor Lawrence threw for three touchdowns in just nine passing attempts, and No. 1 Clemson beat The Citadel 49-0 on Saturday.
2 h
Canada unveils COVID-19 'gargle, spit' test, first of its kind
The test will first aim to help children return to school, but officials hope to roll the test out for wider public use.
2 h
Longtime baseball pro scout Gary Hughes dies at 79
Gary Hughes, a beloved professional scout for numerous big league organizations during a 54-year career, has died in Northern California after a battle with cancer. He was 79.
2 h