Tools
Change country:

Arizona’s Audit Continues to Be a Chaotic Mess

If you’ve forgotten about the Arizona “audit” of Maricopa County’s votes in the 2020 election, you can be forgiven. At times, it seems like the audits’ backers have forgotten about it too.

Arizona state-Senate Republicans launched the process this spring as a response to false claims of election fraud spread by several of themselves, as well as former President Donald Trump. The Senate hired Cyber Ninjas, a firm run by a “Stop the Steal” backer that has repeatedly declined to offer any evidence it is qualified for the job. The process was originally expected to conclude by May 14. This was a hard deadline, because the coliseum rented for the count was due to hold another event. But the count missed that deadline, and the process resumed later in May.

May turned to June, and Donald Trump was reportedly telling people that he expected to be reinstated to the presidency in August, once the audit proved that fraud had tainted the election results. (Never mind that there remains no evidence of widespread fraud, and that there’s no mechanism for a former president to be reinstated mid-term.) By July, the due date was mid-August.

[David A. Graham: Republicans’ phony argument for election audits]

Now August is past, and Trump hasn’t been reinstated—and neither has the public seen the results of the audit. In fact, it’s been hard for the public to have any sense of what’s going on at all. I spent several days this week trying to get answers from several of the principals and couldn’t get any closer to an answer. Finally, on Thursday, a spokesperson for Arizona Senate Republicans said the findings of the audit would be released in a public hearing on September 24. That would be five months after the audit began, nearly 11 months after the election, and four months after the initial scheduled completion date.

And who knows if they’ll even meet the new deadline. Officials said late last month that the audit was supposed to be complete. On August 23, Arizona Senate President Karen Fann said the final report was delayed because members of the Cyber Ninjas team had fallen ill with COVID-19. Nonetheless, Fann said she expected the state Senate to begin reviewing a partial report two days later. But that never happened. The Arizona Mirror reported later that week that no report, partial or not, had actually been delivered. A spokesperson for the audit, Randy Pullen, told me yesterday the reports have not yet been delivered to the state Senate.

This kind of disorganization has been typical for the Arizona audit, which was troubled from its inception. (Election-security experts bristle at the very use of audit, noting that the term has a specific meaning in both industry parlance and state law, one this exercise doesn’t match.) In addition to Cyber Ninjas CEO Doug Logan’s prejudice on the result, Cyber Ninjas had no experience running an operation of this size. That became clear as the audit missed deadlines and outside observers noted not only serious flaws in how the audit was being conducted, but also changes in the procedure on the fly, which undermine the reliability of the count. The audit is being funded largely by private money, which keeps taxpayers off the hook but also raises questions of influence and farms out a governmental function to conservative donors.

At times, officials have been said to be going beyond looking at ballots to pursue bizarre conspiracy theories, like reviewing whether bamboo threads were on ballots, a nod to a claim that boxes of ballots had been flown in from China. Ken Bennett, the Senate’s liaison to the audit, briefly announced that he was resigning his post before reversing himself. Cyber Ninjas has implied that it has found discrepancies in its work, but the company has not made public what they are or how large they are. Maricopa County’s elected leadership, which is GOP-dominated, has repeatedly refuted sloppy claims made by the auditors.

The U.S. Department of Justice and Arizona Secretary of State Katie Hobbs have both logged numerous objections to the audit, but so have Republican election officials from other states. The audit has even taken friendly fire. State Senator Michelle Ugenti-Rita, a Republican who supported the exercise at the start, said in July that she had changed her mind. “Sadly, it’s now become clear that the audit has been botched,” she tweeted. “The total lack of competence by [Fann] over the last 5 months has deprived the voters of Arizona [of] a comprehensive accounting of the 2020 election. That’s inexcusable, but it shows what can happen when Republicans do not take election integrity deadly serious.”

The only real information to emerge has been about the procedures for the audit, not its results, and those have come thanks to court decisions, as judges rule that the Senate or Cyber Ninjas must turn over information about its procedures. On Wednesday, Fann instructed Cyber Ninjas to release records, after the Senate lost a case in the Arizona Supreme Court over withholding them.

[David A. Graham: The unfolding disaster in Arizona]

Yet the actual report remains missing in action. Perhaps that’s not such a bad thing: The process has been so flawed that the results are practically meaningless. In fact, the temptation would be to write the whole thing off as slapstick, if the stakes weren’t so high. As Trump’s claims about reinstatement show, the Arizona audit is the bleeding edge of Republican efforts to cast doubt on the American system of elections as a whole.

Meanwhile, several other states have undertaken their own reviews of the 2020 results, despite no evidence of serious fraud that would have affected the result there, either. In Pennsylvania, legislators authorized a subpoena that appears to violate state law. County clerks in Wisconsin have been baffled by requests from an investigator hired by the speaker of the state assembly. In many cases, officials have explicitly said they were inspired by what’s happening in Maricopa County. That seems to include importing the inefficacy and chaos that has characterized Arizona’s audit.


Read full article on: theatlantic.com
Texas lawmakers pass new congressional maps that bolster the GOP
Texas Republicans approved redrawn U.S. House maps that favor incumbents and decrease political representation for growing minority communities, even as Latinos drive much of the state's growth.
9 m
npr.org
What to watch on Tuesday: ‘Queens’ on ABC
Tuesday, October 19, 2021 | “The Boulet Brothers’ Dragula” returns on Shudder
washingtonpost.com
'Munsters' reboot director Rob Zombie reveals first look at stars
"The Triumph of King Freak" singer Rob Zombie shared a few behind-the-scenes photos from his upcoming reboot of "The Munsters," confirming the cast.
foxnews.com
Buffalo Bills suffer sickening loss to Tennessee Titans with failed fourth-down gamble
The Bills have now lost two games in a row to the Titans, the latest a heartbreaker for Buffalo when Josh Allen slipped on a quarterback sneak.       
usatoday.com
North Korea fires a ballistic missile into the sea in its latest test
Hours after the U.S. reaffirmed its offer to resume diplomacy on North Korea's nuclear weapons program, the North fired a ballistic missile into the sea, the South Korean and Japanese militaries said.
npr.org
Banged-up Justin Turner available to start for Dodgers in NLCS Game 3
Turner is banged up, but the Dodgers are planning on his availability to start Game 3 of the NLCS on Tuesday at Dodger Stadium.
nypost.com
Nearly 100 unvaccinated staff at Yale New Haven Health lose their jobs
Nearly 100 employees in the Yale New Haven Health system lost their jobs Monday because they failed to get a COVID-19 vaccine, officials said.
foxnews.com
North Korea fires at least one ballistic missile off eastern coast
North Korea has fired at least one ballistic missile from its eastern coast, according to South Korean and Japanese officials. CNN's Paula Hancocks has more.
edition.cnn.com
Bill Gates daughter required guests be vaxxed, get tested before $2M wedding
Jennifer Gates required all guests who attended her extravagant $2 million wedding celebration in Westchester to be fully vaccinated and get a negative COVID test before being allowed into the party of the year.
nypost.com
Philadelphia-area straphangers who may have filmed rape could face charges: report
Authorities in Pennsylvania are working to determine if passengers who witnessed an alleged rape on a suburban Philadelphia train line not only didn't call 911 but may have filmed the incident.
foxnews.com
'He died in my arms.' Twelve months on, a mother's agonizing wait to find out why her son died at Lekki toll gate
When Adesola heard about the shooting at the Lekki toll gate in Lagos on October 20, 2020, she immediately thought of her son who had earlier left home to join the hundreds of young people protesting against police brutality at the site.
edition.cnn.com
A year on, a mother's agonizing wait to find out why her son died at Lekki toll gate
When Adesola heard about the shooting at the Lekki toll gate in Lagos on October 20, 2020, she immediately thought of her son who had earlier left home to join the hundreds of young people protesting against police brutality at the site.
edition.cnn.com
Rangers’ Artemi Panarin picks perfect time for first goal of season
Heading into the Rangers’ matchup with the Maple Leafs on Monday, Artemi Panarin had only recorded two shots on net in the previous three games.
nypost.com
One year after Lekki toll gate shooting, victim's mother wants honesty from Nigerian government
It's been a year since Nigerian forces opened fire on peaceful protests at the Lekki toll gate in Lagos. At the time, a CNN investigation into what happened sent shock waves around the world. We found that the Nigerian army had fired live rounds into the crowd, killing and wounding several people. Witnesses also told CNN the authorities blocked ambulances from reaching the scene. Twelve months on, and a judicial hearing is finally expected to share its findings. Stephanie Busari reports.
edition.cnn.com
Angelina Jolie, Salma Hayek, Gemma Chan, Kumail Nanjiani attend Marvel's 'Eternals' LA premiere
The movie stars Angelina Jolie, Richard Madden, Gemma Chan, Kumail Nanjiani and Salma Hayek as immortal heroes. "Eternals" hits theaters on Nov. 5.       
1 h
usatoday.com
How your fantasy football team can navigate Browns’ injury woes
Nick Chubb missed Week 6 with a calf injury, and Kareem Hunt, already dealing with ankle and wrist issues, left Week 6 with a calf injury of his own.
1 h
nypost.com
NJ school slammed for response when 2 females named homecoming king, queen
A New Jersey high school sparked controversy after its students picked two girls as homecoming king and queen – and administrators reacted by adding two boy winners.
1 h
nypost.com
North Korea fires at least one ballistic missile
North Korea fired at least one ballistic missile from its eastern coast on Tuesday morning, according to South Korean and Japanese officials.
1 h
edition.cnn.com
In an age of self-interest, Boris Johnson's secret COP26 weapon may have to be shame
It's now less than two weeks until Boris Johnson welcomes the world to Glasgow, Scotland, where he will host the COP26 international climate talks at a crucial moment in our planet's history.
1 h
edition.cnn.com
In an age of self-interest, Boris Johnson's secret COP26 weapon may have to be shame
Given the severity of the climate crisis, one might assume that agreement on key issues would be simple. But politics and science have a complicated relationship and, in 2021, multilateralism relies as much on political self-interest as it does on facts.
1 h
edition.cnn.com
Foreign policy and muscle cars: Joe Biden and Colin Powell's decades-long friendship
Joe Biden was waiting on a desolate, darkened Afghan tarmac in 2002 when bad news arrived from Washington: He and his entourage were being blocked by the Pentagon from taking a spare seat on a departing military cargo plane.
1 h
edition.cnn.com
Out of office and off the ballot, Trump's influence still looms
The two candidates in the Virginia governor's race are talking more about Donald Trump, the former President, than they are about Joe Biden, the White House's current occupant.
1 h
edition.cnn.com
Out of office and off the ballot, Trump's influence still looms
The two candidates in the Virginia governor's race are talking more about Donald Trump, the former President, than they are about Joe Biden, the White House's current occupant.
1 h
edition.cnn.com
January 6 committee takes aim at Bannon and tries to save Congress' power to investigate
The January 6 committee's anticipated vote on Tuesday citing Steve Bannon for criminal contempt of Congress may be one of the last chances for lawmakers to seek meaningful consequences for former President Donald Trump's attempt to effectively stage a coup.
1 h
edition.cnn.com
Jan. 6 committee takes aim at Bannon and tries to save Congress' power to investigate
The January 6 committee's anticipated vote on Tuesday citing Steve Bannon for criminal contempt of Congress may be one of the last chances for lawmakers to seek meaningful consequences for former President Donald Trump's attempt to effectively stage a coup.
1 h
edition.cnn.com
Carolyn Hax: She resents her job and her landlady and is planning to ‘disappear’
She can afford to retire and wants to know if there’s any reason she shouldn’t quit her job without notice and abruptly move out of her rental.
1 h
washingtonpost.com
Miss Manners: You can’t snub someone who’s already snubbed you
Reader aims to use the ultimate social weapon against someone, but it may be too late.
1 h
washingtonpost.com
Hints From Heloise: Memorial service features mementos for the guests
Reader selected a black-and-white photo to remind her of her friend.
1 h
washingtonpost.com
Ask Amy: Mom’s needs must take a back seat
Reader deals with husband’s terminal cancer diagnosis, while Mom demands attention.
1 h
washingtonpost.com
Top 5 quarterback performances of Week 6: Kyler Murray leads Cardinals to 6-0 record
Second-year quarterback Joe Burrow had another terrific performance for the Cincinnati Bengals in their 34-11 win over the Detroit Lions, but it wasn’t good enough to crack the top five performances this week.
1 h
foxnews.com
Australian state could fire more than 40 police staff for refusing a Covid-19 vaccine
A total of 43 police staff in the Australian state of Victoria have been stood down from duty and could face being fired after they failed to comply with a Covid-19 vaccine mandate, Victoria Police said.
1 h
edition.cnn.com
More than 30 police officers could be fired for refusing Covid-19 vaccine
A total of 43 police staff in the Australian state of Victoria have been stood down from duty and could face being fired after they failed to comply with a Covid-19 vaccine mandate, Victoria Police said.
1 h
edition.cnn.com
Texas lawmakers pass new congressional maps bolstering GOP
Texas Republicans approved on Monday redrawn U.S. House maps that favor incumbents and decrease political representation for growing minority communities, even as Latinos drive much of the growth in the nation’s largest red state.
1 h
foxnews.com
Braves wary of relinquishing another NLCS lead against Dodgers
In last year’s NLCS, the Braves won the first two games and extended that lead to 3-1 before the Dodgers rallied for three straight victories to win the pennant.
1 h
nypost.com
North Korea has fired at least one ballistic missile from the country's east coast, authorities say
North Korea fired at least one ballistic missile from its eastern coast on Tuesday morning, according to South Korean and Japanese officials.
1 h
edition.cnn.com
North Korea has fired at least one ballistic missile from the country's east coast
North Korea fired at least one ballistic missile from its eastern coast on Tuesday morning, according to South Korean and Japanese officials.
1 h
edition.cnn.com
Dave Roberts defends Dodgers' pitching changes against Braves despite criticism
Dodgers manager Dave Roberts says the club is used to criticism over its unique personnel decisions and adds fan critique of NLCS pitching changes is good for the game.
1 h
latimes.com
Homer-happy Red Sox rout Astros in Game 3 to grab ALCS lead
It began, in concept, as a Yankees nightmare. In practice? No one’s suffering more in this American League Championship Series than the Astros.
1 h
nypost.com
Who Is Zalmay Khalilzad? Biden's Envoy for Afghanistan Resigns After Messy Troop Withdrawal
Zalmay Khalilzad was appointed Special Representative for Afghanistan Reconciliation under the administration of former President Donald Trump in 2018.
1 h
newsweek.com
Hannity: Biden 'vilifying' police, medical professionals for not complying with vaccine mandates
Sean Hannity said vaccine mandates are vilifying the exact people who were lauded for their bravery and professionalism during the worst early days of the coronavirus pandemic.
1 h
foxnews.com
Schwarber, Red Sox slam Astros 12-3, lead ALCS 2-1
Tapping his wrist to mimic Correa’s Game 1 celebration, Rodriguez rode four more Boston homers — including Kyle Schwarber's record-setting grand slam — to a 12-3 victory Monday night as the Red Sox took a 2-1 lead in the best-of-seven AL Championship Series.
1 h
foxnews.com
Mary Kay Letourneau felt remorse about relationship with 12-year-old student
An infamous ex-Washington State teacher who raped a 12-year-old student -- and later married him -- was riddled with guilt over their relationship before her 2020 death, a report claims.
1 h
nypost.com
Titans stop Josh Allen on crucial 4th down to hold on for win, fans debate whether Bills made right play
The Buffalo Bills found out Monday night football is truly a game of inches.
1 h
foxnews.com
Tennessee Titans stuff Buffalo Bills on fourth down to win instant MNF classic
The Tennessee Titans stunned the red-hot Buffalo Bills, 34-31, at Nissan Stadium on "Monday Night Football" with a brilliant goal-line stand.      
1 h
usatoday.com
'DWTS': JoJo Siwa beats Amanda Kloots' top score, Olivia Jade shocks in bottom 2 of 'Grease' night
Break out the leather jackets and poodle skirts, "Dancing With the Stars" fans! It's "Grease" night. Find out which celebrity dancer got eliminated.      
1 h
usatoday.com
Kyle Schwarber’s Red Sox tee off on the Astros again to grab a 2-1 lead in the ALCS
Read more
1 h
washingtonpost.com
5 tons of cocaine worth $232 million seized by Portuguese authorities
More than five tons of cocaine worth an estimated $232 million was seized off a 79-foot yacht by Portuguese authorities in the Atlantic Ocean on Sunday.
1 h
nypost.com
Federal Judge Allows University of North Carolina to Continue Race-Based Admissions Policy
The judge said that even 70 years after the college's first Black students were admitted, they still experience isolation and stereotypes.
1 h
newsweek.com