Listen: Fires Outside, Virus Inside

While in California, Katherine Wells has been wearing two masks—one for the coronavirus, and one for the wildfire smoke—but she isn’t sure how to interpret the air quality warnings. James Hamblin, her co-host on the podcast Social Distance, wants to know how air pollution like smoke interacts with COVID-19.

They called John Balmes, a pulmonologist who’s studied inhaled pollutants for decades and serves as the physician member of the California Air Resources Board. Listen to their conversation here:

Subscribe to Social Distance on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or another podcast platform to receive new episodes as soon as they’re published.

Here is a transcript of their conversation, edited and condensed for clarity:

Katherine Wells: I know there have been summers with some of these elements before, but is this surprising to you?

John Balmes: Well, yes and no. It’s certainly the worst air quality I’ve experienced since I moved to the Bay Area in 1986. But it doesn’t really surprise me. This wildfire season was predicted to be particularly bad because of the drought we had. And it was predicted to be hot and dry this summer. What was unexpected were the lightning strikes.

Wells: Last week, that orange day, was surreal. What was your experience of that as a person living there?

Balmes: Well, you know, I’m a big Tolkien fan so it seemed like Mordor that day. The sun looked like the Evil Eye of Sauron. The air quality wasn’t even that bad that day though, because that light was [created by] the smoke plume up high blocking out the sun. We had heavy fog in the marine layer protecting the air we breathe from being really bad. It wasn’t good, but it was actually Friday of last week where there was more sun but the air quality got into “purple,” very unhealthy for everyone.

Wells: When you say “purple” ... I’ve come out to California just recently and the air quality indicators are all new to me. Can you orient me a little bit?

Balmes: Sure. Your listeners should get familiar with ... that will give the Air Quality Index for your location. Zero to 50 is green, and that’s healthy air. Fifty-one to 100 is yellow, that’s moderate, which can start to be a problem for people with preexisting lung disease or heart disease. One hundred and one to 150 is orange, and that’s when it’s especially harmful to people with preexisting heart and lung disease.

At 150 one to 200—red—it becomes unhealthy for everyone. Even people without heart and lung disease may experience symptoms. And then 201 to 300, that’s purple, that’s definitely unhealthy for everyone at that point. Even healthy people are advised not to exercise outdoors. Most healthy people will not experience symptoms in the red zone.

James Hamblin: And with the AQI, when you talk about people getting sick, you’re talking about having short-term symptoms, versus having long-term effects from levels of exposure?

Balmes: Yes, the AQI is focused on short-term effects, but those short-term effects can be serious for people with preexisting lung and heart disease.

Wells: That is really good to know. I spent a couple of hours outside at 150 and now I feel like I have a cold.

Balmes: That could be related to being outside in the bad air quality. One of the risk factors for smoke exposure is an increased risk of lower respiratory tract infections. That’s acute bronchitis and pneumonia, which is particularly problematic in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Hamblin: Does it increase your risk of having more severe disease once you’ve been infected, if you’ve been living in a place that has high levels of exposure to particulate matter versus someplace else?

Balmes: Yes, there’s a building evidence with regard to air pollution, and particulate matter in particular, and COVID-19. The best studied association is severity of COVID-19, including one study out of Harvard, that I believe is actually getting published just this week, where they looked at county-level data. Counties with more chronic exposure to PM2.5—particulates that are 2.5 microns or smaller—had more COVID-19 deaths.

And that’s chronic exposure, not acute heavy exposure. But other studies from China and Italy, for example, suggest that short-term levels of PM2.5 do increase the risk of severe COVID-19. What is less clearly understood, but there are some studies that are suggestive, is whether exposure to air pollution and particulate matter in particular increases your risk of getting the infection. There are good reasons to suspect that it would increase your risk of infection, but that’s not been as well established as the severity of COVID-19.

Hamblin: And what most people are really afraid of is getting a severe case. And you’re talking about where the air-quality index might be on the low or safe side, but people have just been chronically exposed to it; that’s the sort of effect that might put you at risk of more severe COVID-19 if you do contract the virus.

Balmes: Yes, the Harvard study, that was actually surprising because that was a U.S. study. It’s not in New Delhi. It wasn’t during wildfire season. U.S. PM2.5 levels aren’t that bad compared to many other parts of the world. And there was still an increased risk. There was an 8 percent increased risk for every one microgram per meter cubed—that’s the unit of measurement of PM2.5. And that was actually a pretty strong effect.

Hamblin: Wow.

Wells: In terms of practical advice for how to handle this, even if it goes on for a month, you can get an air purifier, you can not go outside. But if you live in an area that has even slightly elevated air pollution for years, I mean ... have you spent time in communities with elevated air pollution?

Balmes: I’ve done research all over the world with regard to air pollution and have been in India, for example, and in cities in Africa, where there is often a lot of biomass smoke from cooking on solid fuels outdoors. We do know a lot about chronic exposure to PM2.5. And there are all sorts of health effects related to that exposure. The Global Burden of Disease, which comes out every couple of years, has listed PM2.5 as the most important environmental risk factor for death and disability worldwide. And in places like India, it’s a huge component of disease burden.

In terms of wildfire smoke, we just don’t have those kinds of chronic exposure studies because the community hasn’t been exposed chronically before. In general, that’s not entirely true there. There was an air inversion in Northern California over the Yurok Reservation. They had bad air for like a month. And the CDC actually used that to study weather masks and air purifiers helped with regard to respiratory symptoms.

And that study showed that if people stayed indoors, they did better. It also showed that the HEPA air purifiers worked. What they found, somewhat surprisingly, was wearing a respirator like an N95 ... I think they weren’t officially N95s then but ... wearing a respirator didn’t actually protect you.

Wells: What?

Balmes: Their feeling was that people went outdoors, thinking they could spend as much time as they wanted … that was the handwaving answer to why that might have occurred. We do know that N95s protect people from wildfire smoke. Unfortunately, cloth masks don’t. Cloth masks, which we’re wearing to protect others from the wearer transmitting the virus, work for that. But they don’t protect against inhaling fine particles because those 2.5 microns sized particles go right through the weave of a cloth mask.

A surgical mask is better. That will get you about 20 to 30 percent reduction in wildfire smoke. P.M. 2.5. But an N95 will get 95 percent reduction if it fits you properly. And even if you haven’t been properly fitted, it probably will give you 80 percent reduction or so. The trouble is N95s aren’t necessarily available to the general public now because of their reservation for health-care workers and other first responders. But a type of N95 that is available is an N95 with an exhalation valve, which is actually more comfortable to wear.

Wells: Right, so I have one of those, but I’ve been wearing that. And then a cloth mask over it for COVID-19.

Balmes: Perfect. You’re great. That’s the way you should do it.

Wells: But it’s not comfortable! (laughs)

Balmes: (laughs) I didn’t say it was comfortable. But it protects you and it protects others.

Wells: I want to protect everyone and also be comfortable at the same time. But it doesn’t seem like that’s going to be the case.

Balmes: I can tell you that if you’re just walking, you don’t have to worry about infecting others with an N95 with an exhalation valve.

Wells: Oh, really?

Balmes: You have to breathe hard enough to open the valve. If you’re exercising—if you’re jogging or cycling—that will open the valve. If you’re just walking, it won’t. As a matter of fact, we’re trying to get CDC to not be so strict about the use of N95s with exhalation valves for the public. I’m totally fine with health-care workers not using them, but, you know, there’s a grocery store that won’t let me in unless I put masking tape on or wear another mask over it.

Wells: With an N95 with masking tape over the mouth and an orange sky, you’re painting a vivid picture. So just to sum up: what do we need to know about air quality and COVID-19?

Balmes: We think that there is an increased risk of COVID-19 with poor air quality, and that includes poor air quality due to wildfires smoke, and so people should try to reduce their exposure as much as possible. And the best thing to do is to stay indoors with the windows closed and portable air cleaners in any room that they want to spend a lot of time in.

Load more
Read full article on:
LeBron James 'pissed off' he didn't receive more first-place votes for NBA MVP
LeBron James, who finished second to Giannis Antetokounmpo, expressed some frustration over receiving just 16 of 101 first-place votes for NBA MVP.       
8 m
Dwight Howard, JaVale McGee get back to work in Lakers' Game 1 win
Lakers coach Frank Vogel knew centers JaVale McGee and Dwight Howard would be key factors against the Nuggets, and the big men were sharp in a Game 1 victory.
Most recent US elections have had an international event as the October Surprise. This one may be no different
The 2020 election may provide yet another 'October surprise' to rock the boat. Analysis by Nick Paton Walsh, CNN.
After a farmer suffered a heart attack, his neighbors banded together to harvest his crops
Around 60 farmers from North Dakota put their own harvesting on hold to cut 1,000 acres for a farmer who suffered a heart attack after his combine caught fire last week.
Nikola Jokic shares a passing trait with LeBron James
Denver's Nikola Jokic and the Lakers' LeBron James are alike in one crucial way — the ability to control a game with passing. L.A. won Game 1 by shutting down Jokic.
Can Mitch McConnell Be Stopped?
If Republicans give Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s seat to some Federalist Society fanatic, Democrats should pack the court.
What Ruth Bader Ginsburg Would Want America to Do Now
Throughout all of the late-breaking notorious fame, the Justice knew that she was just one link in the chain.
Senators appear to change stances on confirming successor to Ginsburg vs. Scalia, but argue 2020 is different
The 2016 presidential election happened as a seat on the Supreme Court was at stake following the death of a justice -- that will be the case yet again in 2020 after Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the face of the liberal bloc on the Supreme Court and a trailblazer for women's rights, died on Friday.
AOC says Ginsburg's death should 'radicalize' Dems: 'I need you to be ready'
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., mourned the loss of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg as "earth-shattering" and said the balance of democracy now hinged on who would succeed her on the Supreme Court.
Angels' Taylor Ward living up to his potential after some swing adjustments
Taylor Ward, who stalled at one point in the minor leagues because of his offensive production, has been hot for the Angels after redesigning his swing.
'Unforgivable': Rep. Doug Collins slammed for tweet about Ruth Bader Ginsburg's abortion stance after her death
Rep. Doug Collins was accused of "celebrating" Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg's death in his post.
Column: Ruth Bader Ginsburg's death should not eclipse Ruth Bader Ginsburg's life
The world changed, politics roared, America's mood shifted this way and that, and Ginsburg worked, steadily as she had always done, dismantling injustice wherever she could.
1 h
How to Watch 'On the Basis of Sex,' About the Legal Battle that Started Ruth Bader Ginsburg's Legacy
The 2018 film is a historic drama about a sex discrimination case that Ginsburg used to help shape the American legal landscape.
1 h
'A Towering Legacy:' AG Barr Honors Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg on Behalf of DOJ
AG William Barr shared his "deepest sympathy" on behalf of DOJ over the passing of U.S. Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg.
1 h
20 years of closed-door conversations with Ruth Bader Ginsburg
Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who died at age 87 on Friday, reached the heights of power at her own pace, always recalibrating the time she put to family and her pioneering career.
1 h
Ruth Bader Ginsburg, aka 'Notorious RBG,' was an unparalleled cultural icon
At 5’1” and barely 100 pounds, Ruth Bader Ginsburg earned her nickname “The Notorious RBG” by the sheer force of who she was as a judge: a feminist icon, a rebel, an indefatigable advocate for justice and yes – an unparalleled cultural icon.
1 h
Ginsburg made the law fairer for every woman
Even before joining the Supreme Court, she convinced an all-male Supreme Court that laws' enforcing sex stereotypes violated the Constitution--and demonstrated how those laws harmed men as well as women, writes Mary Ziegler. Ginsburg helped make sense of how discrimination against pregnant workers could be pernicious.
1 h
Dodgers rout Rockies to clinch home-field advantage in wild card
Dodgers hit their season high for runs and lower their NL West-clinching magic number to four in a 15-6 victory over the Colorado Rockies.
1 h
Ruth Bader Ginsburg's life and work propelled women's equality front and center
Ginsburg's successes we take for granted now. But she was the one who brought to the Supreme Court the perspective of women's rights.       
1 h
Ted Cruz urges Senate to fill Ruth Bader Ginsburg's seat, warning of 'constitutional crisis' on Election Day
Sen. Ted Cruz on Friday urged his fellow lawmakers to nominate and confirm a Supreme Court justice before the Nov. 3 presidential election following the death of Ruth Bader Ginsburg, warning of a looming "constitutional crisis" if the seat remains vacant.
1 h
How to Watch 'RBG,' the Ruth Bader Ginsburg Documentary
The life and career of Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who died Friday, is explored in the Oscar-nominated documentary "RBG."
1 h
Some in GOP See a Political Opening for Trump in the Death of Ruth Bader Ginsburg
Hours after the death of the powerful liberal Justice, Republican Senators and donors endorsed replacing her before the next inauguration.
2 h
Editorial: Ruth Bader Ginsburg, a Supreme Court icon, is dead. The Senate should wait to replace her.
The Senate should be consistent and decline to act on Trump's nominee
2 h
Memorials spring up outside Supreme Court after Ruth Bader Ginsburg's death
She was an icon for women. Ruth Bader Ginsburg is honored outside the Supreme Court.        
2 h
Q&A: What happens now with the Supreme Court?
President Trump and Senate GOP leaders plan to push to replace Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg before the election. Can they? Can Democrats stop them?
2 h
COVID Could Be Transmissible From Animals to Humans and Vice Versa
Among the group studied by Dutch researchers, 67 percent of workers at mink farms developed the coronavirus.
2 h
Biden says 2020 winner should pick RBG successor
Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden says the winner of the November election should pick a successor to the late Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. (Sept. 18)       
2 h
Steven Matz didn’t give Mets a chance in ugly loss as playoff hopes fade
The Mets withstood two consecutive abridged starts by their rotation, coming back each time behind a resilient bullpen and a productive lineup, to post two desperation wins they needed to barely remain alive in the National League playoff hunt. Steven Matz, however, made sure there would not be a third. Matz’s first start in more...
2 h
McConnell vows Trump’s Supreme Court nominee will get a Senate vote
The Senate leader, who blocked former president Barack Obama’s nominee for much of 2016, is pressing ahead within weeks of the Nov. 3 election.
2 h
Trump learns of Ruth Bader Ginsburg's death from reporters
President Trump learned about Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg's death from reporters following a campaign rally in Bemidji, Minnesota. Mr. Trump said Ginsburg was "an amazing woman who led an amazing life." Watch his remarks.
2 h
Watch Live: Mourners Gather Outside SCOTUS Following Justice Ginsburg's Death
Mourners have gathered outside of the Supreme Court in the nation's capital Friday night following the news of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg's death.
2 h
Blue Checks Vow Violence If McConnell Tries to Replace Ruth Bader Ginsburg: 'Burn the Entire F**king Thing Down'
Blue check leftists on Twitter vowed violence in America if Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell attempts to replace Ginsburg.
2 h
How the late Ruth Bader Ginsburg became a pop culture icon
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who died Friday at 87, became a pop culture icon — thanks, in part, to her fiery dissents on the bench. Her impassioned disagreement of the court’s decision in 2013 Shelby County v. Holder decision sparked the “Notorious R.B.G.” Tumblr page and meme — comparing Ginsburg to rapper Biggie Smalls aka...
2 h
Attention Mitch McConnell: Filling RBG's seat now could break American democracy
While a law student at the University of Kentucky, the institution where I teach, Senator Mitch McConnell surely learned about the importance of justice and democracy. In the wake of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg's passing on Friday evening, there is one action that McConnell can take that may very well save our democracy: announce that the Senate will not consider a Supreme Court nomination until after Inauguration Day 2021.
2 h
SCOTUS After Ruth Bader Ginsberg
Emily Bazelon on the Justice’s legacy, the looming Senate fight, and what could happen with a conservative court.
2 h
'It's going to be intense,' Bash on what's next after RBG's death
CNN's Dana Bash explains what the death of Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg could mean for the future of the Supreme Court.
2 h
Anatomy of a faux scandal: Right-wing media uses misleading local story to suggest coronavirus cover-up
A version of this story is also appearing in the Reliable Sources newsletter. Click here to sign up for free. If you don't get your news from right-wing media, it is likely that you haven't heard about this story. But for those who do rely on outlets such as Fox News or Breitbart for information, a scandal of towering proportions has been brewing in Nashville, Tennessee.
2 h
Gov. Cuomo to target bars frequented by college students
ALBANY — Beer pong alert: Gov. Andrew Cuomo is directing his recently heavy-handed State Liquor Authority to beef up inspections at watering holes frequented by college kids. “With the return of college students for the fall semester, Governor Cuomo has directed the State Liquor Authority to increase efforts to ensure bars and restaurants in areas...
2 h
Trump lauds Ginsburg but is eager to nominate her replacement, source says
President Donald Trump hailed Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg as a "brilliant mind" in a statement Friday evening, praising her for demonstrating "that one can disagree without being disagreeable toward one's colleagues of different points of view."
2 h
Ruth Bader Ginsburg death makes Supreme Court major 2020 campaign issue
The death of Ruth Bader Ginsburg put the Supreme Court at the epicenter of the 2020 presidential election, setting up a furious battle over who should fill the vacancy.
2 h
Sean Hannity reacts to Ruth Bader Ginsburg death, praises her 'incredible, inspiring courage'
Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who died Friday night at the age of 87, showed "incredible, inspiring courage" in the fight against her final illness, Sean Hannity told his viewers Friday night.
2 h
'The voters should pick': Joe Biden says nomination to replace Ginsburg should be made after the November election
'The voters should pick the president and the president should pick the justice for the Senate to consider,' Biden said.        
2 h
Hundreds pay tribute to Ruth Bader Ginsburg outside Supreme Court
Well-wishers left flowers and signs and broke into songs.
2 h
GOP Rep. Offers Condolences to '30 Million Innocent Babies' Who Died From Ruth Bader Ginsburg's Defense of Abortion
"RIP to the more than 30 million innocent babies that have been murdered during the decades that Ruth Bader Ginsburg defended pro-abortion laws," Congressman Doug Collins tweeted.
2 h
Tell us: Why was Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg important to you ?
Ruth Bader Ginsberg gained fame for her feminist ideals and her civil rights record. Share your feelings about her, and we may publish your thoughts.
2 h
CBS Evening News, September 18, 2020
President Trump says there will be enough vaccine available by April ; How a fish chair tattoo inspired a Facebook group's 300-mile journey
2 h
Crowds gather at Supreme Court to remember Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg
Tributes to Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg flowed outside the court after news of her death.
2 h
Street life slowly returns to Mexico, even as the coronavirus toll climbs
The official death toll in Mexico quietly surpassed 70,000 this month, a figure topped only in the United States, Brazil and India.
2 h