Change country:

‘Self Care’ Isn’t the Fix for Late-Pandemic Malaise

If years could be assigned a dominant feeling (1929: despair; 2008: hope), 2021’s might be exhaustion. As the coronavirus pandemic rumbles through its 20th month, many of us feel like we are running a race we didn’t sign up for, and it’s getting longer every mile we run.

With this slog has come a renewed focus on mental health. During the pandemic, universities have poured money into psychological resources. Corporations have hired chief health officers and invested in wellness services. In 2020, the mindfulness app Headspace saw a 500 percent increase in corporate-subscription requests. Alongside these efforts, a worldwide conversation has grown around “self-care:” anything pursued for the sake of one’s own wellness, including practicing goat yoga, bingeing Ted Lasso, and old-fashioned napping. Self-care has been popular for decades, but during the pandemic it has gained new cachet. Google searches for the term more than doubled from March to April 2020. Countless organizations, including mine, implemented “COVID days”—time off meant for employees to center their own needs.

But self-care alone won’t fulfill people’s psychological needs as we rebound from the pandemic. After many months in relative isolation, we must reclaim connection and meaning. That comes not just from caring for ourselves but also from caring for one another.

Self-care is vital, but its efficacy is specific: It is especially good at softening intense stress and anxiety, for instance among nurses and therapists. Profound distress saturated people’s lives in the spring of 2020, and self-care might have protected against it. However, that distress was surprisingly short-lived: As a task force to which I belong reported, acute mental-health problems peaked early in the pandemic and then quickly subsided."

That doesn’t mean people are doing well. For many, the pandemic’s long tail has replaced intense distress with a duller struggle: languishing, or a loss of meaning amid the Groundhog Day that is pandemic living. Languishing has many sources, but right now I suspect isolation is its driving force. When people reflect on what matters to them most in life, social connections perennially top their list. Even as we emerge from social-distancing practices, it’s easy to miss those connections. People are still adapting to reentry and rebuilding atrophied social muscles. And though self-care soothes, it can be too individualistic to help with loneliness. “Me time” is great, truly, but human flourishing is typically out there with everyone else.

[Read: Late-stage pandemic is messing with your brain]

Languishing might subside on its own as socializing and travel become safe again. But another approach—one that has been shown in years of research to bolster people’s sense of self—is to show up for others. In one of many studies like it, people were randomly assigned to spend money on either themselves or someone else and then were asked how much they agreed with statements such as “My life has a clear sense of purpose.” Those who spent their money on others reported feeling greater meaning, self-worth, and connection. The effects in these studies were small; buying someone coffee probably won’t be your road-to-Damascus moment. But over time, the effects of many small actions can accrue.

This is even truer during trying times. Despite headlines that blare about looting and other crimes, disasters usually bring out the best in people, intensifying charitable donations, volunteering, and cooperation. Kindness has continued through the pandemic, and its benefits have too. In one recent study, hundreds of people were randomly assigned to buy personal protective equipment for themselves or as a gift for a stranger. Spending on others again boosted people’s sense of meaning and connection.

The punch line is simple: Giving boosts meaning in good times, and might be a salve against languishing in tough ones. Here’s the problem: Many people don’t seem to get this. Individuals wrongly predict that spending time, money, and energy on themselves will make them more fulfilled than spending those resources on others. When they act on these illusions, ironically they can deepen languishing and loneliness. Unfortunately, this kind of behavior can intensify when people most need human connection. For instance, individuals who feel lonely or depressed tend to turn inward, focusing less on others, which leaves them even more disconnected over time.

Some people might bristle at the suggestion that they need to devote more time to others. So many of us—parents of young children, children of immunocompromised parents, teachers, health-care workers—have been worn to a nub by helping. Other-care has caused our burnout; how could it possibly be a cure?

The surprising answer is that the very same act of helping can deplete or fulfill us, depending on how we think about it. Imagine helping someone move to a new apartment. To you, this could be an expression of appreciation to a close friend or an irritating obligation you were guilted into. These inner judgments can determine, in part, how doing this favor will affect you.

Researchers have identified psychological ingredients that make helping beneficial to helpers, including autonomy and empathy. In studies run by my own lab and others, researchers checked in with participants at the end of each day, asking whether they had helped someone else that day, how they experienced their act of kindness, and how they were feeling. People reported being more fulfilled on days they helped others, but only when they felt connected to why they were doing what they were doing, and to the person they were helping.

For these reasons, I think we need a complement to self-care days: “other-care” days, earmarked to zero in on positive effects we can have on someone else. Schools and companies can clear time for people not to soothe themselves but to be helpers instead. Among corporations, organized kindness was popular early in the pandemic, for instance when Anheuser-Busch brewed hand sanitizer and Gap pivoted to manufacturing clothing for health-care workers.

[Read: Why are people nostalgic for early-pandemic life?]

Other-care days would build on this spirit, but in different ways. They would shift from grand collective gestures to personal habits of helping, and give individuals leeway to help whomever and however they like, turning kindness into an act of self-expression. This could be integrated with the kinds of care many of us do already, such as parenting. On other-care days, instead of trudging between video meetings and preschool tantrums, a parent could take her kids to volunteer or visit an elderly neighbor. By making space for intention and compassion, other-care days could transform our everyday helping and recuperate its meaning.

Ultimately, the line between self-care and other-care is blurrier than we might realize. People are psychologically intertwined, such that helping others is a kindness to ourselves and watching over ourselves supports others. This idea was embedded in early conversations about self-care. Following its more mundane roots in medicine—when self-care more or less meant heeding doctors’ orders—activists took this idea in a revolutionary direction. In the 1960s, the Black Panther Party launched Survival Programs, mutual-aid efforts designed to encourage preventive medicine, nutrition, and exercise in response to the lack of high-quality health-care access many Black Americans face.

Activists such as Angela Davis and Ericka Huggins broadened this approach to include practices such as mindfulness and yoga, more along the lines of what we now understand as self-care. But their version was still firmly grounded in community. As they saw it, self-care among Black people—especially Black women—was a radical act, denying the oppression that would reduce them. It was also a way to continue pushing against that oppression and toward justice. “Anyone who is interested in making change in the world,” Davis once said, also “has to learn to take care of herself.”

As with so many revolutionary ideas, the narrative around self-care has now been wrapped in marketing; the industry has soared past $10 billion a year in the United States alone. The millions of people who Googled self-care as the pandemic began likely didn’t find information on its community-based roots. They found instead an atomized, hyperpersonal world of tips, products, and services—calming, sometimes expensive tools for being alone in nicer ways—that can help sometimes, and that might strand us at other times.

By integrating other-care into our plans, we can go back to self-care’s broader, more connected origins and rebuild meaning at a time when so many of us desperately need it.

Read full article on:
Germany's unvaccinated could soon face even tougher Covid restrictions
Mets’ Starling Marte always wanted to play with Robinson Cano
Sure, there were 78 million reasons for Starling Marte to choose the Mets, but the prospect of playing with Robinson Cano also attracted him to New York.
Boogie Ellis, Isaiah Mobley lead No. 20 USC to win over Utah in Pac-12 opener
Isaiah Mobley scored 21 points, Boogie Ellis added 19, and No. 20 USC opened Pac-12 play by rolling to a 93-73 victory over Utah.
19-year-old man fatally shot outside Brooklyn public housing complex
The victim, identified as Jaden Cruz, was shot in the chest in front of a building at NYCHA's Marlboro Houses in Gravesend, according to the NYPD.
Spacewalk approved after debris scare prompted delay
After assessing possibly threatening space debris, NASA cleared two astronauts to press ahead with a spacewalk.
Paul George-less Clippers have trouble finding rhythm in loss to Kings
Clippers star Paul George sat out as the team could not slow down the Sacramento Kings in the 124-115 loss on Wednesday at Staples Center.
Igor Shesterkin has another big night in win over Flyers
With his usual flair and intensity, goalie Igor Shesterkin made seven saves to fend off a five-minute Flyers power play early in the second period to preserve the Rangers’ lead on the way to their 4-1 win over Philadelphia on Wednesday night.
Laos-China railway to launch as debt to Beijing mounts
Laos is opening a US$5.9 billion Chinese-built railway that links China's own poor southwest to foreign markets but piles on potentially risky debt
Students call on SUNY Chancellor to resign
The New York College Democratic and Republican clubs called for SUNY Chancellor James Malatras to resign for smearing Lindsey Boylan, the first woman to publicly accuse ex-Gov. Andrew Cuomo of harassment.
Waukesha Christmas parade suspect: I'm being treated like a 'monster'
In an interview with FOX News, Waukesha Christmas parade suspect Darrell Brooks Jr., says he is being treated like a "monster."       
1 h
The UN Secretary General said widespread travel bans imposed on southern African countries over fears of the Omicron variant were 'unacceptable'
1 h
Boris Johnson faces grilling over alleged 'boozy' Christmas parties last year
British Prime Minister Boris Johnson faced a grilling during the Prime Minister's Questions (PMQs) in the UK Parliament after a British newspaper reported claims that he and aides held Christmas parties last year at 10 Downing Street, despite the Covid-19 restrictions at the time. CNN's Bianca Nobilo reports.
1 h
Mother, boyfriend charged in 3-yo's beating death
1 h
Stephen Colbert and Jimmy Kimmel Go Off on Trump for Debating Biden With COVID
CBS/ABCAs Stephen Colbert has explained to his Late Show audience before, he has spent almost all of 2021 trying his best not to talk about former President Donald Trump. “But no matter how hard you try to avoid him,” he said on Wednesday night, “his name keeps coming up.”The latest story Colbert couldn’t ignore comes from The Chief’s Chief, the new book by former White House Chief of Staff Mark Meadows, who reveals that Trump actually tested positive for COVID-19 three days before his September 2020 debate with Joe Biden, and not after as he had previously claimed. “Who could have known that he might have been positive at the debate that Tuesday?” Colbert asked before cutting to a clip of him suggesting just that in a clip that aired on The Late Show after Trump was hospitalized a few days after the in-person event. “You can’t go wrong when you bet on the former president lying,” he added.Read more at The Daily Beast.
2 h
Ingraham: Supreme Court could 'finally put Roe to rest', rips 'twisted logic' of Sotomayor
In her "Ingraham Angle" commentary, host Laura Ingraham said there is a decent potential for the conservative-majority U.S. Supreme Court to finally "put Roe to rest" and reserve the legality of abortion to the states.
2 h
Peng Shuai's Case Is a Turning Point for China
Ms. Peng’s celebrity certainly has driven interest in her case. But her allegations also are groundbreaking.
2 h
How Éric Zemmour Became the New Face of France’s Far Right
It doesn’t take much to see the roots of his ideology. The irony is that this time, its proponent is Jewish.
2 h
What to watch on Thursday: ‘Annie Live!’ premieres on NBC
Thursday, December 2, 2021 | The season finale of “The Great Christmas Light Fight” on ABC
2 h
Why was Drake at a seemingly random Thunder-Rockets game in Oklahoma City?
Drake surprised players and fans when he sat courtside in Oklahoma City for the second half of Wednesday's Thunder-Rockets game.       
2 h
Dad Charged With Felony Neglect For Death of 2-Year-Old Girl Found in River's Debris Field
Jeremy Sweet was also charged with unlawful possession of a syringe and being a habitual offender, Bartholomew County Sheriff Matthew Myers said.
2 h
U.S. defense chief slams China’s drive for hypersonic weapons
Lloyd Austin said the U.S. is concerned about China’s military capability.
2 h
Disney Elects Susan Arnold as Its First Woman Chair in 98-Year History
The upcoming chair has been a member of Disney's board for 14 years.
2 h
In Surprising Move, Canada Rules Boeing Out of Finalists to Build New Fighter Planes
The finalists, Lockheed Martin's F-35 stealth fighter and Saab's Gripen, surprised many as American aerospace giant Boeing's Super Hornet was left out.
2 h
Alabama shooting leaves retired deputy and suspect dead: reports
A shooting in Alabama on Wednesday resulted in the deaths of a retired sheriff’s deputy who was working as a process server, and of the suspect, according to reports.
2 h
Amari Bailey returns for Sierra Canyon, scores 23 points during win over West Ranch
UCLA-bound Amari Bailey gives Sierra Canyon a boost during a 100-72 win over West Ranch on Wednesday.
2 h
Giants’ Logan Ryan details how he spent his stint on COVID-19 list
The time on the COVID-19 list was excruciating wait for Logan Ryan, who watched from his New Jersey home as the Giants lost to the Buccaneers in Tampa and, six days later, came home and beat the Eagles.
2 h
Facing Olympic boycott calls, China presses U.S. companies to speak up in its defense
The campaign comes as the Women’s Tennis Association suspended tournaments in the country over the treatment of player Peng Shuai.
2 h
Major League Baseball lockout begins as players and owners fail to reach a new bargaining agreement
The collective bargaining agreement between Major League Baseball and the players' union expired at 11:59 p.m. ET on Wednesday, leading to the first official work stoppage in professional baseball since the 1994-95 seasons.
2 h
Former Planned Parenthood director drags Supreme Court liberals for ‘idiotic’ comments during abortion hearing
Former Planned Parenthood director Abby Johnson joins 'Tucker Carlson Tonight' to discuss the Supreme Court's hearing regarding Dobbs v. Jackson Women's health abortion case
2 h
Restaurant going against grain, requests vaccine
2 h
The nation's top doctor and other experts joined CNN for a town hall the day the first US case of the Omicron variant was identified in California
2 h
Arrest made in mysterious killing of 14-year-old boy in Florida
Florida police on Wednesday made an arrest in the killing of a 14-year-old boy who was found dead after going for a bike ride last month, a report said.
2 h
Fiji reopens to tourism
Fiji reopened its border to international travelers for the first time in nearly two years on Wednesday, December 1 as the Pacific Island country seeks to revive its dominant tourism industry.
2 h
Hannity: Biden administration takes responsibility for nothing
Fox News host Sean Hannity revealed the full extent of the Biden administration's failures in his opening monologue Wednesday night.
2 h
Gabby Petito’s family converts social accounts into missing persons pages
Gabby Petito's stepdad, Jim Schmidt, announced an updated Facebook page dedicated to finding missing people called "Gabby - Find The Missing."
2 h
FCC's 'Equal Time' Rules Prompt Stations to Take The 'Dr. Oz Show' Off The Air
TV stations that air in and around Pennsylvania announced Wednesday they would stop airing Dr. Oz's show in an effort to avoid violating the campaign rule.
2 h
MLB lockout is on after collective bargaining agreement expires, owners agree to freeze out players
MLB and union officials met multiple times this week, but as expected, little progress was made, and owners voted to lock out players.      
2 h
'That's not what's happening:' Biden tries to rebut news coverage about empty store shelves
A version of this article first appeared in the "Reliable Sources" newsletter.
2 h
MLB lockout official as CBA expiration brings baseball to halt
As midnight hit Thursday morning, a Major League Baseball owners’ lockout of the players became a reality.
2 h
This Platform Stripped 'Jeopardy!' Champ Matt Amodio of His Checkmark: What Is Twitter?
"I never thought trying to fight cancer would be what gets me canceled," Amodio tweeted.
3 h
Tucker Carlson: Tyranny is coming unless someone stops Democrats' COVID power grab
Tucker Carlson analyzes Democrats' and the media's reaction to the new omicron COVID variant.
3 h
Colorado Panel Says Erratic Behavior Not a Reason to Use Ketamine as Restraint
The panel was announced last year, saying it would review the state's ketamine waiver, which allows workers to use the drug outsides of hospitals.
3 h
Tyger Campbell provides boost to lead No. 5 UCLA over Colorado in Pac-12 opener
Tyger Campbell scored 21 points as No. 5 UCLA defeated Colorado 73-61 in their Pac-12 opener on Wednesday at Pauley Pavilion.
3 h
The demonization of Dr. Fauci is just one sign of this insanity
3 h
Ed McClanahan, Kentucky author and 'Merry Prankster,' dies at 89: 'A pillar in the community'
Ed McClanahan, a Kentucky author and teacher died Saturday at his home in Lexington, according to his wife. He was 89.       
3 h
‘Playoffs’ start now as struggling Islanders return to face Sharks
The Islanders will be back on the ice Thursday night against the Sharks, carrying a sense of urgency with them.
3 h
MLB on verge of first work stoppage in 26 years as CBA expires without new agreement
The collective bargaining agreement between MLB and the MLB Players Assn. expired without a new agreement in place, setting the stage for a lockout.
3 h
MLB work stoppage looms after CBA expires with owners and players still at odds
As drastic as a lockout may feel, the expectation in the industry is that it will not affect the start of spring training or the 2022 season.
3 h