Change country:

Social Media Is Attention Alcohol

Last year, researchers at Instagram published disturbing findings from an internal study on the app’s effect on young women. “Thirty-two percent of teen girls said that when they felt bad about their bodies, Instagram made them feel worse,” the authors wrote in a presentation obtained by The Wall Street Journal. “They often feel ‘addicted’ and know that what they’re seeing is bad for their mental health but feel unable to stop themselves.”

This was not a new revelation. For years, Facebook, which owns Instagram, has investigated the app’s effects on its users, and it kept getting the same result. “We make body image issues worse for one in three teen girls,” said one slide from a 2019 presentation. “Teens who struggle with mental health say Instagram makes it worse.”

The findings weren’t all negative. Although many teenagers reported that Instagram was compulsive but depressing, most teenagers who acknowledged this dark side said they still thought the app was enjoyable and useful.

[From September 2017 issue: Have smartphones destroyed a generation?]

So a fair summary of Instagram according to Instagram might go like this: Here is a fun product that millions of people seem to love; that is unwholesome in large doses; that makes a sizable minority feel more anxious, more depressed, and worse about their bodies; and that many people struggle to use in moderation.

What does that sound like to you? To me, it sounds like alcohol—a social lubricant that can be delightful but also depressing, a popular experience that blends short-term euphoria with long-term regret, a product that leads to painful and even addictive behavior among a significant minority. Like booze, social media seems to offer an intoxicating cocktail of dopamine, disorientation, and, for some, dependency. Call it “attention alcohol.”

I personally don’t spend much time on Instagram, but on reflection I love Twitter quite like the way I love wine and whiskey. Other analogies fall short; some people liken social media to junk food, but ultra-processed snacks have few redeemable health qualities compared with just about every natural alternative. I have a more complicated relationship with Twitter. It makes my life better and more interesting. It connects me with writers and thinkers whom I would never otherwise reach. But some days, my attention will get caught in the slipstream of gotchas, dunks, and nonsense controversies, and I’ll feel deeply regretful about the way I spent my time … only to open the app again, several minutes later, when the pinch of regret has relaxed and my thumb reaches, without thought, toward a familiar blue icon on my phone.

For the past decade, writers have been trying to jam Facebook into various analogical boxes. Facebook is like a global railroad; or, no, it’s like a town square; or, perhaps, it’s like a transnational government; or, rather, it’s an electric grid, or a newspaper, or cable TV.

Each of these gets at something real. Facebook’s ability to connect previously unconnected groups of people to information and commerce really does make it like a 21st-century railroad. The fact that hundreds of millions of people get their news from Facebook makes it very much like a global newspaper. But none of these metaphors completely captures the full berserk mosaic of Facebook or other social-media platforms. In particular, none of them touches on what social media does to the minds of the young people who use it the most.

[From the December 2019 issue: The dark psychology of social networks]

“People compare social media to nicotine,” Andrew Bosworth, a longtime Facebook executive, wrote in an extensive 2019 memo on the company’s internal network. “I find that wildly offensive, not to me but to addicts.” He went on:

I have seen family members struggle with alcoholism and classmates struggle with opioids. I know there is a battle for the terminology of addiction but I side firmly with the neuroscientists. Still, while Facebook may not be nicotine I think it is probably like sugar. Sugar is delicious and for most of us there is a special place for it in our lives. But like all things it benefits from moderation.

But in 2020, Facebook critics weren’t the ones comparing its offerings to addiction-forming chemicals. The company’s own users told its research team that its products were akin to a mildly addictive depressant.

If you disbelieve these self-reports, perhaps you’ll be persuaded by the prodigious amounts of outside research suggesting the same conclusion. In June, researchers from NYU, Stanford, and Microsoft published a paper with a title that made their position on the matter unambiguous: “Digital Addiction.” In closing, they reported that “self-control problems cause 31 percent of social media use.” Think about that: About one in three minutes spent on social media is time we neither hoped to use beforehand nor feel good about in retrospect.

Facebook acknowledges these problems. In a response to the Wall Street Journal exposé published on Tuesday, Karina Newton, the head of public policy at Instagram, stood by the company’s research. “Many find it helpful one day, and problematic the next,” she wrote. “Many said Instagram makes things better or has no effect, but some, particularly those who were already feeling down, said Instagram may make things worse.” But this self-knowledge hasn’t translated into sufficient reform.

Thinking of social media as attention alcohol can guide reform efforts. We have a kind of social infrastructure around alcohol, which we don’t have yet for social media. The need to limit consumption is evident in our marketing: Beer ads encourage people to drink responsibly. It’s in our institutions: Established organizations such as Alcoholics Anonymous are devoted to fighting addiction and abuse. It’s in our regulatory and economic policy: Alcohol is taxed at higher rates than other food and drink, and its interstate distribution has separate rules. There is also a legal age limit. (Instagram requires its users to be 13 years old, although, as it goes with buying alcohol, many users of the photo-sharing app are surely lying about their age.)

Perhaps most important, people have developed a common vocabulary around alcohol use: “Who’s driving tonight?”; “He needs to be cut off”; “She needs some water”; “I went too hard this weekend”; “I might need help.” These phrases are so familiar that it can take a second to recognize that they communicate actual knowledge about what alcohol is and what it does to our bodies. We’ve been consuming booze for several thousand years and have studied the compound’s specific chemical effects on the liver and bloodstream. Social media, by contrast, has been around for less than two decades, and we’re still trying to understand exactly what it’s doing, to whom, and by what mechanism.

We might be getting closer to an answer. A 124-page literature review compiled by Jonathan Haidt, an NYU professor, and Jean Twenge, a San Diego State University professor, finds that the negative effects of social media are highly concentrated among young people, and teen girls in particular. Development research tells us that teenagers are exquisitely sensitive to social influence, or to the opinions of other teens. One thing that social media might do is hijack this keen peer sensitivity and drive obsessive thinking about body image, status, and popularity. Instagram seems to create, for some teenage girls, a suffocating prestige economy that pays people in kudos for their appearance and presentation. The negative externality is dangerously high rates of anxiety.

How do we fix it? We should learn from alcohol, which is studied, labeled, taxed, and restricted. Similar strictures would discourage social-media abuse among teenagers. We should continue to study exactly how and for whom these apps are psychologically ruinous and respond directly to the consensus reached by that research. Governments should urge or require companies to build more in-app tools to discourage overuse. Instagram and other app makers should strongly consider raising their minimum age for getting an account and preventing young users from presenting fake birthdates. Finally, and most broadly, parents, teens, and the press should continue to build a common vocabulary and set of rules around the dangers of excess social media for its most vulnerable users.

Digital sabbaths are currently the subject of columns and confessionals. That’s a good start, but this stuff should be sewn into our everyday language: “No apps this weekend”; “I need to be cut off”; “I love you, but I think you need to take a break”; “Can you help me stay offline?” These reforms should begin with Facebook. But with social media, as with every other legal, compulsive product, the responsibility of moderation ends with the users.

Read full article on:
How life has changed for Christen Harper since Jared Goff’s trade from Rams
Jared Goff's model girlfriend Christen Harper is reminiscing about living in LA just days before the Lions quarterback will return to play his former Rams team.
5 m
Halle Berry once told director Bryan Singer to ‘kiss my black ass’
Alan Cumming claims in his upcoming book that Berry hurled the remark on the set of 2003's "X2" while staging an intervention for the now-disgraced director.
5 m
Dog the Bounty Hunter's Daughter Questions How Brian Laundrie's Parents Found Belongings
Some of Brian Laundrie's personal belongings were found in Florida's Myakkahatchee Creek Environmental Park.
6 m
Olivia Newton-John is ‘doing well’ amid stage 4 breast cancer battle
The "Grease" alum added that she's "feeling pretty good" as she manages her pain with medical marijuana, saying, cannabis is a huge part of her "healing."
7 m
Karrueche Tran dons sheer dress and pasties at Doja Cat’s birthday party
The actress went bold in a see-through green dress for Doja Cat's birthday party, which was also attended by Billie Eilish, Winnie Harlow and Teyana Taylor.
7 m
Oversight Board slams Facebook, says tech giant withheld info in Trump case
The board said that Facebook withheld or provided incomplete information about its so-called cross-check program, which shields millions of high-profile and VIP users.
8 m
State Department policies exclude U.S. citizens' family members
CBS News senior investigative correspondent Catherine Herridge joined "Red and Blue" to discuss the latest in Afghanistan, and U.S. policies surrounding Americans still in the country.
Video shows broad-daylight shootout near Bronx elementary school
The clip shows two groups of men at the corner of East 150th Street and Cedar Lane in Mott Haven, just around the corner from the Boys Prep Bronx Elementary School.
FLASHBACK: Media, liberals proven wrong on statue comments after NYC votes to remove Thomas Jefferson statue
The New York City Public Design Commission voted on Tuesday to remove a statue of Thomas Jefferson from the New York City Council's chambers at City Hall, despite earlier predictions from reporters and liberals that statues of the Founding Fathers weren't at risk of being removed.
Outraged North Carolina parent calls out 'racist' banner taunting football team's White privilege
Melissa Swanson, a single mother, voiced outrage after a local high school cheerleading squad held up a sign with the word "privilege" in White letters at a football game against the Catholic school. She said parents and school officials 'allowed' it to happen.
High School Student Injures Teacher in 'Aggressive' Classroom Attack—Officials
Fort Bend school district officials said the student ""engaged in aggressive behavior and injured a teacher."
The best sales to shop today: Adidas, Allswell, Le Creuset and more
Today, you'll find a deal on Le Creuset, discounted watches on Amazon and savings on kitchen essentials from Sur La Table. All that and more below.
Stephen Breyer Says Clarence Thomas Asking More Questions Is a 'Plus for Everybody'
The liberal justice again defended the Supreme Court against claims that it makes decisions based on political motivations.
Mortgage rates rise amid growing concerns about inflation
Home prices also rose more than 13 percent during the past year.
Ex-Minneapolis police officer sentenced to 57 months in the killing of a 911 caller
Mohamed Noor, who fatally shot an unarmed woman after she called 911 to report a possible rape behind her home, was sentenced on a lesser charge after his murder conviction was overturned.
Major California earthquake would knock out cell service, communications, study finds
A major earthquake in California is likely to knock out many communications services, including cellphones, for days or weeks, a USGS study finds.
Former Minneapolis police officer Mohamed Noor resentenced to 4 years and 9 months in prison for fatal 2017 shooting
The former Minneapolis police officer who fatally shot a woman while responding to her 911 call in 2017 was resentenced Thursday to 4 years and 9 months in prison on a second-degree manslaughter charge after Minnesota's highest court threw out his third-degree murder conviction last month.
Health problems tied to global warming are getting grimmer
The annual reports commissioned by the medical journal Lancet tracked 44 global health indicators connected to climate change, including heat deaths, infectious diseases and hunger.
Do not forget these courageous fighters in Russia
The Memorial organization is threatened as Alexei Navalny languishes in prison.
Sinema’s attack on Biden’s tax plan may be great news for the 1 percent
How Democrats may end up squandering a big opportunity for lasting change.
Local Matters: Virginia governor's race currently tied, poll says
A new Monmouth University poll shows the Virginia gubernatorial race is tied. Republican Glenn Youngkin has closed the gap with former governor Terry McAuliffe, a Democrat. Zach Montellaro, state politics reporter for Politico, joined CBSN's Lana Zak to discuss.
5 things to watch for CNN's Biden town hall in Baltimore
President Joe Biden on Thursday is expected to face questions about his legislative agenda and his handling of key issues during his first year in office when he participates in a CNN town hall in Baltimore.
TIME’s NFT Community Initiative, TIMEPieces, Announces its First-Ever Artist-in-Residence Program; Inaugural recipient is 12-Year Old Digital Artist and Creator of the “Long Neckie” Collection, Nyla Hayes
Today, TIMEPieces, a recently launched web3 community initiative from TIME, announced that 12-year old NFT digital artist Nyla Hayes would serve as its first-ever “Artist-in-Residence.” Nyla Hayes is the creator of the Long Neckie Collection, which features diverse women with elongated necks inspired by her favorite dinosaur, the Brontosaurus. She is the founder of NFT…
Port of Long Beach executive director talks supply chain efforts
President Joe Biden announced plan to address supply chain bottlenecks by expanding round-the-clock operations at key West Coast ports. Executive Director of the Port of Long Beach Mario Cordero joins Lana Zak on CBSN to discuss how the move could help ease the major backlog.
Chicago officer accidentally fires his handgun, wounding two other officers
An officer accidentally fired his handgun during a struggle while police were making arrests in suburban Chicago, wounding two other officers, authorities said.
Surgeon General Murthy: Vaccinated Children Will Still Need to Wear Masks in School
Thursday on CNN's "New Day," U.S. Surgeon General Vivek Murthy sounded off on masks for children as the White House prepares for the Pfizer coronavirus vaccine to be approved for children ages 5 to 11 in the coming weeks.
NBC's 'Premier League Mornings Live' will be live at Coliseum this weekend
Soccer fans can attend a live show of NBC's "Premier League Mornings Live" at the Coliseum on Saturday and Sunday mornings.
The Joe Manchin party-switch question
Regardless of how real the possibility is, it reinforces Manchin's leverage in his relationship with his party — whether Democrats want to acknowledge that or not.
Nevada Gov. candidate shoots ‘CRT,’ ‘vaccine mandate’ beer bottles in campaign video
Michele Fiore has released a campaign video of her shooting down beer bottles with “critical race theory” and “vaccine mandates” scrawled across them.
A break-up, an idol and work-life balance. How Mia Hansen-Løve found 'Bergman Island'
Critically hailed French filmmaker Mia Hansen-Løve makes her English-language debut with 'Bergman Island,' featuring Vicky Krieps and Mia Wasikowska.
What Time Will ‘Canada’s Drag Race’ Season 2 Episode 2 Premiere?
Bring it to the runway, Canada.
Are you using the right credit card when ordering food for delivery?
With everything from cash back to monthly dining credits, these are the best credit cards to use when ordering food for delivery from your favorite restaurants to the comfort of your own home.
Carrie Lukas: I'm a Virginia mom and I don't trust my local public school
When I moved to Virginia, public school quality was top of mind. I wanted schools that would give my kids a quality education, a supportive environment, and a positive community. As a busy, working parent, I needed schools I could trust.
Virginia QB Brennan Armstrong is putting up video game numbers this season
Read more
Adorable Video of Baby Dancing Along to Dad's Piano Playing Viewed 5M Times
Gus the baby's enthusiastic reaction prompted one fan to declare it was the "best thing I've ever seen."
Extreme atmospheric rivers to bombard California with beneficial precipitation
Multiple rounds of rain and snow will bring drought relief but also the risk of mudslides and debris flows
Unvaccinated Oregon workers who had covid-19 argued they don’t need a vaccine. A judge denied their request.
The judge wrote, “Whatever hardships Plaintiffs face in choosing between accepting vaccination or leaving their employment are substantially outweighed by the interests and needs of the State of Oregon and her people.”
Moscow is going back into lockdown as Covid-19 deaths multiply in Russia
Moscow will impose a 10-day lockdown from next week in an effort to curb soaring Covid-19 cases, the city's mayor has said, as Russia endures its worst-ever phase of the pandemic.
California Town Charging Nearly $8 a Gallon For Gas as Prices Hit 7-Year-High Across U.S.
The town of Gorda is seeing sky-high gas prices as the cost of gasoline is surging around the U.S., with the national average at around $3.30 per gallon
Outrage As Teacher Mocks Native American Dance Wearing Feather Headdress: 'Disrespectful'
A Native American high school student filmed his teacher appearing to mock his culture, explaining he felt "that violence was being committed against him."
Fisher-Price toy telephone gets upgrade and can now make and receive real calls
Fisher-Price announced its classic Chatter toy phone has been updated to make and accept real phone calls.
James Gandolfini had a 'tantrum' over raunchy 'Sopranos' scene
James Gandolfini wasn’t jerking around on the set of “The Sopranos.”
Two teen passengers killed, driver hurt in Long Island crash, cops say
Two unidentified passengers inside the BMW -- a 19-year-old male and 17-year-old female -- suffered severe trauma and were pronounced dead on scene.
Donald Trump's Businesses Facing Multiple Criminal Investigations
A probe into the ex-president's golf club at Westchester County, 30 miles north of New York City, is the latest incident.
Shocked NYC fishermen are catching ‘monster’ 600-pound tunas
In an unprecedented phenomenon, trophy Atlantic bluefin tuna have been swimming inshore, off NYC, prompting hundreds of anglers to venture out for a shot at blue gold.
Red Sox fans chant ‘F–k Joe Biden’ after loss to Astros
Red Sox fans turned their ire toward Joe Biden after Wednesday's loss to the Astros.
Eddie George disappointed in Tennessee State home crowds: We're playing 'in front of nobody'
Football coach Eddie George is disappointed in Tennessee State's average home attendance, the worst in the OVC, ranking 122nd out of 129 FCS teams.
Myles Garrett held players-only meeting to help Browns defense get back on track
Myles Garrett sent a message to his Browns teammates this week. "We'll see Thursday if everybody received it," Malik Jackson said.