Change country:

The New Lost Cause

One of my favorite things about covering political rallies is that they typically start with a recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance. For anyone above school age, occasions to recite the pledge with a large group of people are irregular, and the ritual serves as a good reminder of what politics is about at its best, no matter how divisive what follows might be.

The pledge at a rally for the Republican gubernatorial candidate Glenn Youngkin in Virginia on Wednesday night was different. At the beginning of the event, which Steve Bannon hosted and Donald Trump phoned into, an emcee called an attendee up onstage and announced, “She’s carrying an American flag that was carried at the peaceful rally with Donald J. Trump on January 6.” Attendees then said the pledge while facing the flag. (Youngkin didn’t attend, and later tepidly criticized the moment.)

This is a bizarre subversion. The pledge affirms allegiance to the republic, indivisible and offering justice to all. This flag was carried at a rally that became an attack on the Constitution itself: an attempt to overthrow the government, divide the country, and effect extrajudicial punishment. Elevating this banner to a revered relic captures the troubling transformation of the events of January 6 into a myth—a New Lost Cause. This mythology has many of the trappings of its neo-Confederate predecessor, which Trump also employed for political gain: a martyr cult, claims of anti-liberty political persecution, and veneration of artifacts.

Most of all, the New Lost Cause, like the old one, seeks to convert a shameful catastrophe into a celebration of the valor and honor of the culprits and portray those who attacked the country as the true patriots. But lost causes have a pernicious tendency to be less lost than we might hope. Just as neo-Confederate revisionism shaped racial violence and oppression after the war, Trump’s New Lost Cause poses a continuing peril to the hope of “one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.”

In the immediate aftermath of the failed January 6 insurrection, Trump flailed in his efforts to interpret the day’s events. He praised the participants even as the riot was ongoing, saying, “Go home; we love you.” He insisted (despite ample video footage) that what had happened was a peaceful protest—some demonstrators were pacific, while many others were not—though he has also falsely claimed that antifa and Black Lives Matter had instigated a riot. He praised the protesters for courageously fighting back against what he insists, again falsely, was a stolen election, but also criticized police for using excessive force.

Out of this murk, a unified mythology has begun to form. Trump hasn’t so much resolved the contradictions as transcended them. To him and his movement, January 6 was a righteous attempt by brave patriots to take back an election stolen from them. The day’s events produced a martyr—Ashli Babbitt, an Air Force veteran shot and killed by a Capitol Police officer as she tried to enter the Speaker’s Lobby of the House. The rioters who remain imprisoned, meanwhile, are “political prisoners.” Now objects carried that day have become sacred too.

[David A. Graham: Donald Trump’s lost cause]

During his term as president, and especially during its last summer, Trump—though a lifetime New York City resident—celebrated the Confederate battle flag, praised Robert E. Lee’s generalship, and defended statues honoring Confederates. These statues were not erected immediately after the war. Rather, they first required the creation of the “Lost Cause” mythology late in the 19th century. As the law professor Michael Paradis wrote in The Atlantic,

the Lost Cause recast the Confederacy’s humiliating defeat in a treasonous war for slavery as the embodiment of the Framers’ true vision for America. Supporters pushed the ideas that the Civil War was not actually about slavery; that Robert E. Lee was a brilliant general, gentleman, and patriot; and that the Ku Klux Klan had rescued the heritage of the old South, what came to be known as “the southern way of life.”

Many of the monuments themselves were put up at times of conflict over civil rights for Black Americans. They took on a quasi-religious cast. At Washington and Lee University, where Lee served as president after the war, the chapel features a recumbent statue of the general where a church would typically have an altar. The building where General Stonewall Jackson was taken and died after being wounded at Chancellorsville was preserved, first by a local railroad and then by the National Park Service, and until 2019, was known as the “Stonewall Jackson Shrine.”

After Congress decided in 1905 to send back flags captured during the Civil War to their home states, Virginia placed the ones it received in a Richmond museum that, as Atlas Obscura describes, “began as a shrine to the Confederate cause, filled with memorabilia sourced from Confederate sympathizers.” To Lost Cause adherents, these flags were hallowed because they had been carried by the boys in gray as they bravely fought against Yankee aggression.

[From the June 2021 issue: Why Confederate lies live on]

The paradigmatic moment for the Lost Cause myth is Pickett’s Charge at the Battle of Gettysburg, a bloody, hour-long Confederate onslaught later called “the high water mark of the rebellion.” As my colleague Yoni Appelbaum wrote in 2012, the label was unearned. The charge was a disaster, as was immediately clear to Lee, who told the survivors it was his fault. Its fate did not change the outcome of the war or even necessarily the Battle of Gettysburg. Though the assault was initially apotheosized by a pro-Union artwork, it was soon adopted by Lost Cause proponents as a moment of valor. “For every Southern boy fourteen years old, not once but whenever he wants it, there is the instant when it’s still not yet two o’clock on that July afternoon in 1863,” William Faulkner wrote in 1948.

Like Pickett’s Charge, the January 6 insurrection was a disastrous error. It did nothing to prevent Congress from certifying Joe Biden’s election, and, in fact, several Republican members who had planned to object to the results decided against doing so after the riot. It got Trump impeached, a second time, and further tarnished his reputation, which hardly seemed possible.

Martyrdom is not necessarily nefarious, and some who die in battle do deserve veneration. Some heroes deserve veneration. Answering Stonewall Jackson, the Union had its own martyrs, such as Elmer Ellsworth. Ashli Babbitt’s death was awful. It was perhaps unnecessary for Lieutenant Michael Byrd to open fire, and it was certainly unnecessary for her to be in the Capitol that day, where she died in the name of lies that Trump and others had told her. As the journalist Zak Cheney-Rice writes, Trump’s aggrandizement of her death is rooted not in any genuine affection—he is largely incapable of caring about anyone but himself—but in opportunism.

The problem with these myths, the Lost Cause and the New Lost Cause, is that they emphasize the valor of the people involved while whitewashing what they were doing. The men who died in Pickett’s Charge might well have been brave, and they might well have been good fathers, brothers, and sons, but they died in service of a treasonous war to preserve the institution of slavery, and that is why their actions do not deserve celebration.

The January 6 insurrection was an attempt to subvert the Constitution and steal an election. Members of the crowd professed a desire to lynch the vice president and the speaker of the House, and they violently assaulted the seat of American government. They do not deserve celebration either.

Read full article on:
Bryce Young puts on show in Alabama’s impressive win over No. 1 Georgia
Bryce Young threw for three touchdowns and ran for another as the fourth-ranked Crimson Tide rolled over No. 1 Georgia 41-24 in the Southeastern Conference championship game Saturday in Atlanta, a result that likely sends both powerhouse programs to the four-team College Football Playoff.
The world is becoming more dangerous under Joe Biden
We hope we’re not the only ones who’ve noticed, but the world has become a more dangerous place since Joe Biden became president. Why? Perhaps because hostile actors sense weakness — and opportunity.
SEC championship: No. 2 Alabama thumps No. 1 Georgia 41-24, eliminates any question about playoff qualification
The same team that needed a near-miracle just a week ago to come from behind against Auburn blew the doors off the nation's best defense.
CNN Fires Chris Cuomo After Investigation Into Help He Gave Brother Andrew Cuomo
The termination came mere days after the network had indefinitely suspended the star anchor.
Giants will need Mike Glennon to lead them to rare back-to-back wins
Here are the Giants, clanking along on a creaky win-lose-win-lose treadmill.
Texas football assistant coach Jeff Banks, girlfriend are being sued over alleged monkey bite
Texas assistant coach Jeff Banks and his girlfriend have been sued over an alleged monkey bite that happened on Halloween night.
Hidden iPhone tricks most people don‘t know
YouTuber Elly Awesome spills the beans about all the hidden features on the iPhone, along with helpful built-in short cuts that you may have missed.
911 Center Shooting Sees One Dispatcher Accidentally Kill Another While Trading Guns: Police
The two "grew up together and shared the hobby of casual gun trading," said a sheriff, adding they were "cousins and best friends."
AG’s new document dump leaves no doubt: SUNY boss James Malatras must go
SUNY trustees threw a life preserver to scandal-scarred Chancellor James Malatras on Friday, issuing a statement of support. Gov. Kathy Hochul needs to reverse their thinking.
Entitled Tiger Woods has taught media to ignore the tough questions
What do Tiger Woods and the late Bernie Madoff have in common?
American Athletic championship: Cincinnati rolls Houston to earn slot in playoff
The win brings the Bearcats to the doorstep of a historic trip to the College Football Playoff as the first team from the Group of Five to qualify.
Chris Cuomo saga: ABC producer who accused disgraced anchor of sexual harassment reacts to his firing from CNN
Shelley Ross came forward claiming the ousted CNN anchor squeezed her buttock in 2005 when they worked together at ABC News
A man jumped out of taxiing airplane at Phoenix's Sky Harbor International Airport
A 30-year-old man jumped out of an airplane as it was taxiing at Phoenix's Sky Harbor International Airport Saturday.
Seton Hall breezes to 46-point rout over Division II Nyack
No. 25 Seton Hall had a trio come off the bench and combine for 66 points, leading the Pirates to a 113-67 victory over Division II Nyack on Saturday.
Her dream to teach English in Japan ended with a lesson for the country
Wishma Rathnayake's death in immigration detention in Japan has fueled debate over the treatment of foreigners in the country and exposed the lack of transparency in a system where people can languish for years with no prospect of release.
Tom Thibodeau’s Knicks look ‘soft’ amid East tumble
Right now, the Knicks are soft, which is something you are not allowed to be in New York. 
1 h
Model Gisele Bundchen saves trapped sea turtle in new video: 'I felt relieved'
Gisele Bundchen emphasized the need to protect animals as she shared a video of herself saving a sea turtle trapped in a fishing net.
1 h
Florida Man Tased, Arrested for Jumping Court Railing During Wife's Sentencing for Child Abuse
"While I understand these proceedings can elicit an emotional response from loved ones, my bailiffs simply cannot allow an outburst of this kind," a sheriff said.
1 h
Smoke from wildfires prompts unhealthy air quality alert around L.A. County
The Los Angeles County Department of Public Health is telling people to be careful because of bad air quality conditions this weekend.
1 h
Crumbley parents charges 'absolutely warranted,' each could face 15 years, former US attorney says
A former Assistant United States Attorney told Fox News that the charges brought against James Crumbley's parents were 'absolutely warrented' and the couple could face 10-15 years in prison if convicted.
1 h
President Assad won the war but lost his country. A look at the ongoing conflict in Syria
1 h
‘We can't underscore how big of a deal’ Cuomo’s firing is: Joey Jones
Joey Jones and his fellow "Big Saturday Show" co-hosts reacted to the news of Chris Cuomo's dismissal from CNN on Saturday.
1 h
UFC on ESPN 31 video: Vince Morales becomes first to knock out Louis Smolka
Louis Smolka's streak of avoiding the knockout came to an end at UFC on ESPN 31 courtesy of Vince Morales.       Related StoriesUFC on ESPN 31 video: Vince Morales becomes first to knock out Louis Smolka - EnclosureUFC on ESPN 31: Official scorecards from Las VegasUFC on ESPN 31: Best photos from Las Vegas 
1 h
Prince William reveals 'cringing' moment with Taylor Swift, some of his favorite tunes and car rides with his mom and Harry
The Duke of Cambridge will take listeners on a walk down memory lane when he joins forces with Apple Fitness+ for a special festive episode of its "Time To Walk" audio series.
1 h
Columbia murder suspect Vincent Pinkney tied to upstart Everybody Killa ‘open warfare’ gang
Alleged Columbia University killer Vincent Pinkney was allied with an upstart gang called EBK, short for Everybody Killa, according to sources.
1 h
Flying to the UK? A pre-departure COVID test will soon be required, regardless of vaccination status
Tuesday, all travelers 12 and older will need to take a pre-departure test before boarding a flight for the U.K., regardless of vaccination status.       
1 h
5 Amazing New Discoveries About Mars
The red planet's mysteries are being unraveled. Here are five of the biggest discoveries in recent times.
1 h
Norway Christmas party may have sparked largest omicron variant outbreak outside of South Africa
A recent Norwegian omicron outbreak at a Christmas party provides early anecdotal evidence on how the variants spreads between vaccinated people and the severity of its symptoms, according to a recent report.
2 h
Waukesha parade aftermath: Hundreds mourn victims Virginia 'Ginny' Sorenson and Jane Kulich
Hundreds paid their respects for two victims of the Waukesha Christmas parade tragedy on Saturday.
2 h
FDNY colleagues mourn probationary firefighter who died during training
Vincent Malveaux began to feel ill and lost consciousness during an academy training exercise at the FDNY Training Academy on Randall’s Island.
2 h
CNN's Brian Stelter on Chris Cuomo firing: He caused 'so many headaches' for CNN, staffers were 'very unhappy'
CNN fired its primetime anchor amid damning revelations about his involvement in his brother's scandals.
2 h
Irritable bowel syndrome may not be all in your head
Irritable bowel syndrome, otherwise known as IBS, may be the result of an abdominal infection that triggers an allergic response, according to the New England Journal of Medicine
2 h
Bowie State’s season ends with loss in NCAA quarterfinals at Valdosta State
The Bulldogs fall behind early and can't get out the hole against the Blazers.
2 h
Oregon Health Authority moves to implement 'permanent' indoor mask mandate
The Oregon Health Authority (OHA) assembled a Rules Advisory Committee (RAC) earlier this week to address a permanent indoor mask mandate in Oregon, which is only one of a few states that still retains one nearly two years into the pandemic.
2 h
Virginia Republicans savor Youngkin’s victory at retreat
2 h
Loudoun County Schools Try to Charge Parents $36K for Documents Connected to 'Sexual Assault' and 'Rape'
A parent filed a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request with the Loudoun County Public Schools and was asked to pay more than $36,000 for public records.
2 h
Acosta: Hard-right Supreme Court poised to turn back clock
CNN's Jim Acosta takes a look at the conservative breakdown of the US Supreme Court amidst debate about the nation's abortion and gun rights.
2 h
CNN Fires Chris Cuomo
CNN fired Cuomo Prime Time host Chris Cuomo after reviewing documents that showed Cuomo used his media sources to dig up information on his brother, former Governor Andrew Cuomo’s, sexual harassment accusers.
2 h
Man Crashes Truck Into Church Then Stabs Two People, Killing One: Police
The suspect was out on parole for six other offenses, noted a local police chief, describing a "never-ending source of suspects."
2 h
Kyoji Horiguchi 'really sorry' about brutal Bellator 272 knockout loss to Sergio Pettis
Kyoji Horiguchi understandably is disappointed coming out of Bellator 272 but will have another shot at gold in the bantamweight grand prix.       Related StoriesKyoji Horiguchi 'really sorry' about brutal Bellator 272 knockout loss to Sergio Pettis - EnclosureKai Kamaka's UFC release 'lit a fire' to get back to winning ways at Bellator 272Kai Kamaka's UFC release 'lit a fire' to get back to winning ways at Bellator 272 - Enclosure 
2 h
James and Jennifer Crumbley locked up in same jail as accused Michigan school shooter son Ethan
The parents of accused Michigan school gunman Ethan Crumbley are locked up in the same jail as their teenage son, authorities said.
2 h
Report: Brazen Crimes, High-Profile Murder Put L.A. at Policing Crossroads
The brazen shooting of an 81-year-old woman in her L.A. home and ongoing "smash and grab" crimes have put the city at a policing crossroads.
2 h
Mom shows what it’s like to have a night doula for your baby
American mom Brittany Bright shared a video about her night routine with her baby, which includes a night-time postpartum doula (night nanny). The video, posted to Twitter, shows Bright prepping bottles for her 2-month-old son, and then leaving the baby care to the doula from 8 p.m. to 6 a.m. Bright captioned the post: “There are...
2 h
Ben Roethlisberger expects this to be final season with Steelers
There are indications that this could be it for Ben Roethlisberger. 
2 h
Jets cut Matt Ammendola, add Alex Kessman in inevitable kicking change
The Jets made a change at kicker on Saturday, something that has felt inevitable for a few weeks. 
2 h
Warehouse fire source of lingering stench in California town
The lingering stench made residents sick and cost the county $5.4 million to remedy.
2 h
CNN terminates anchor Chris Cuomo after aiding brother Andrew amid sexual harassment allegations
The cable news network tweeted about Chris Cuomo's termination Saturday saying his firing is  "effective immediately."       
2 h
Kentucky Rep. Thomas Massie tweets pro-gun photo days after Michigan school shooting
The Kentucky representative's post received nearly 9,000 retweets and about 13,000 comments as of about 3:30 p.m. Saturday.       
2 h