Change country:

What Germany’s Far Right Has Taught Us

When Germany heads to the polls this weekend, the far-right Alternative for Germany will again be on the ballot, once a fringe presence that has become the largest—and most loathed—opposition party in the Bundestag. It has stood at the center of scandal after scandal, yet unlike other far-right parties across Europe, its experience in mainstream politics hasn’t had a moderating effect on its outlook. The AfD of 2021 is more established, but also more radical.

With Angela Merkel set to step down after 16 years in office following this weekend’s election, all eyes are on who is poised to replace her. Whatever the outcome, however, the AfD is all but certain to be excluded from any future government. And if polling is any indication, the far-right party is expected to win only 11 percent of the vote, falling short of its historic showing in 2017.

Four years ago, many worried that the AfD would eventually win power, so it would be easy to write off the party as having failed. One could think that perhaps Germany has proved the limits of far-right populism.

The reality is not so simple: If any lesson is to be learned from Germany over the past four years, it’s that the populist right doesn’t need to be in power to be politically effective. From the sidelines, the AfD has managed to set the terms and tone of Germany’s political debate, all the while breaking taboos and challenging the limits of what constitutes acceptable political discourse in the country. No matter the result of the election, that much is unlikely to change.

Conventional wisdom suggests that once a far-right party enters the political mainstream, it begins to self-moderate in an effort to broaden its appeal. Such has been the case in France, where Marine Le Pen has tried to rebrand her far-right National Rally (formerly the National Front) into a more palatable choice—a process that has involved expelling the party’s founder and her father, Jean-Marie Le Pen, as well as turning away from much of his xenophobic and anti-Semitic rhetoric. (The party’s other policies, including its nativism and Islamophobia, remain intact.) The same has also proved true in Sweden, where the far-right Swedish Democrats have sought to distance themselves from their neo-Nazi roots.

The AfD, however, has only grown more extreme. Though it was founded in 2013 as an anti-euro party (its name was a pointed response to “There is no alternative,” one of Merkel’s signature statements), it swiftly pivoted during the 2015 migrant crisis, which saw Germany absorb hundreds of thousands of refugees from Syria and elsewhere. The party’s far-right politics gave it a path to the Bundestag, and its leaders seem confident that those politics can keep it there. In addition to doubling down on anti-immigration rhetoric in this election (“Cologne, Kassel or Konstanz can’t cope with more Kabul,” reads one AfD poster, in an apparent reference to Berlin’s decision to accept thousands of vulnerable Afghan refugees fleeing Taliban rule), the party has also sought to capitalize on more pressing issues, such as the coronavirus pandemic and the climate crisis, positioning itself as a political home for shutdown opponents and climate-change skeptics.

German voters haven’t embraced the AfD’s shift. The party suffered a blow this year in a regional election in East Germany, a defeat that was attributed in part to voters’ waning interest in immigration as a wedge issue, as well as to the internal battle between the AfD’s more moderate and extremist wings, the latter of which has attracted the attention of Germany’s domestic-intelligence agency, which is charged with monitoring extremist forces in the country. “They are under scrutiny—not officially yet under observation,” Kai Arzheimer, a political scientist and expert on right-wing extremism at Germany’s University of Mainz, told me. “But in the public’s mind, they are borderline extremists.” (The AfD leadership did not respond to requests for comment.)

Poll numbers and election results, clear though they are, can also be limited gauges of a movement’s impact. This is because, as several populist forces across Europe have demonstrated, the far right doesn’t have to win power to achieve its political goals. Such was the case in Britain with Nigel Farage, who despite never winning a seat in Parliament managed to elevate his pet issue, Britain leaving the European Union, to a matter of fierce national debate—one that ultimately culminated in Farage’s desired outcome: Brexit. Elsewhere in Europe, mainstream parties have adopted more hard-line rhetoric on immigration in a bid to undercut the growing populist and nationalist wave.

[Read: Nigel Farage’s brilliant failure]

“It may look at some point like the far right is not doing very well,” Hans Kundnani, the director of the Europe program at the London-based think tank Chatham House, told me. “Centrists can say, ‘Isn’t it wonderful? We’ve seen off the populist wave.’ But what’s actually happened is that the center-right has completely taken over their agenda.”

Although Germany’s mainstream parties have maintained a cordon sanitaire around the AfD, they haven’t been immune to the trend that Kundnani described. Indeed, a number of politicians belonging to the Christian Social Union, the sister party of Merkel’s Christian Democrats, parroted AfD talking points about Islam and migration in a fruitless attempt to undercut the far right during state elections in 2018. Even now, some of the most right-wing members of Merkel’s party sound more like AfD supporters than they do Christian Democrats—the most prominent example being Hans-Georg Maassen, the party’s candidate for the East German state of Thuringia and the former head of the country’s domestic-intelligence agency, a position from which he was sacked over accusations of harboring far-right sympathies.

[Read: A far-right warning from Germany]

By claiming a share, however small, of Germany’s political real estate, the AfD has forced the country’s mainstream parties to broaden their tents and, in some cases, even normalize far-right positions. It has also forced them to consider more cumbersome coalitions that not long ago might have been unthinkable, complicating the math of forming a government in a country where a single party rarely wins an overall majority. “Its sheer existence makes two-way coalitions on the national level almost impossible,” Constanze Stelzenmüller, a Germany expert at the Brookings Institution, told me, noting that the country’s previous attempt at forming a governing coalition without the AfD took five months to negotiate. This time could be similar.

“We are looking at the possibility of protracted coalition negotiations and an inward-looking German capital at a time when I would argue German responsibility in Europe is urgently needed,” Stelzenmüller said. “That is one significant impact the AfD has, whether it is in the opposition or not.”

Read full article on:
Biden calls Macron, dispatches Kamala Harris to Paris to mend AUKUS rift
President Biden spoke with French President Emmanuel Macron on Friday in a bid to resolve a bitter diplomatic break and said he’s sending Vice President Kamala Harris to Paris to resolve any hard feelings. Macron recalled the French ambassador to Washington last month after Biden stunned America’s oldest ally by announcing a nuclear submarine pact...
7 m
Phoenix Suns owner Robert Sarver 'wholly shocked' by allegations of racism, sexism
The Suns released a statement in reaction to a tweet saying a story is coming out accusing Robert Sarver of "racism, sexism and sexual harassment."
‘Foundation’ Episode 6 Recap: Keeping Up the Pace
Lee Pace shirtless. That’s it. That’s the review.
Lil Nas X is set to make a surprise appearance with Diplo in Las Vegas
"He's going to hop on stage with Diplo and they're going to do something original," we're told. "He wanted to do it. Last-minute thing. [He's flying] out from Atlanta for it."
Duran Duran on ‘Future Past’ and partying with ‘Queen Elizabeth’ for 40th anniversary
Partying with everyone from Lady Gaga, Elton John and Daniel Craig to Kim Kardashian, Vladimir Putin and Queen Elizabeth II, Duran Duran holds the anniversary bash to end all anniversary bashes in celebration of 40 years in music. The festivities go down in the video for the band’s latest single, aptly titled “Anniversary.” But if...
The Supreme Court’s Texas Abortion Case Could Give States More Power Than Ever
The U.S. Supreme Court on Friday declined for the second time to immediately block Texas’ six-week abortion ban, but said it will hear two separate challenges to the law from the Biden Administration and Texas abortion providers on Nov. 1. The high court will not examine the question of whether the Texas law, known as…
Pain at the pump: California gas prices are sky high, with one town charging almost $8 a gallon
Prices are so high — and consumers are so perplexed — that a Google search of "Why are gas prices going up?" has spiked this month.
Brian Laundrie's Remains Sent to Forensic Anthropologist; Cause of Death Expected Next Week
The partial remains, including a portion of a human skull, found on Wednesday were identified as Brian Laundrie the next day using dental records.
Alec Baldwin's 'Rust' movie 911 call released
911 audio from the accidental shooting on the set of Alec Baldwin's "Rust" movie was obtained by Fox News on Friday.
Game On: Empathy-focused video game 'Rainbow Billy'
'Rainbow Billy: The Curse of the Leviathan' focuses on non-violent, empathy and listening-focused game play. Rick Damigella reports.
The Best Winter Outdoor Gear Deals to Shop Now
Photo: STEFANO CAVORETTO/iStock.With fall officially underway and winter just around the corner, you may be in the market for a cold weather outdoor gear refresh. Heavy coats, winter boots, and other outdoor essentials can be on the expensive side, but fortunately you don't have to pay full price to invest in a new piece. Scroll through below to check out some of our favorite deals and coupon codes from retailers like Macy's, Dick's Sporting Goods, and Nike. Macy's: to 60% Off Fall Sale. Dick's Sporting Goods: Up to 60% off Clearance Read more at The Daily Beast.
"CBS Evening News" headlines for Friday, October 22, 2021
Here's a look at the top stories making headlines on the "CBS Evening News with Norah O'Donnell."
A record amount of Americans are quitting their jobs due to pandemic burnout
Millions of Americans have quit their jobs due to pandemic burnout. Many have started their own companies.
Lev Parnas Not in Custody After Conviction, Says 'I've Never Hid From Nobody'
U.S. District Court Judge Paul Oetken declined a request from prosecutors to jail Parnas after he was convicted of campaign finance charges on Friday.
Letters to the Editor — Oct. 23, 2021
The Issue: WH Press Secretary Jen Psaki’s joking responses to questions about the disperal of migrants. The Post has it right in calling out White House Press Secretary Jen Psaki on her all-too-many sarcastic, trite responses to serious questions (“Laughing off US crises,” Oct. 20). Her actions ­border on childish. She also has a “poker...
Biden's looming European high-wire act
President Joe Biden heads to Europe next week for a series of high-stakes meetings and summits. Here's a primer on what to know:
Man With Tattooed Face Tried to Rape Woman Sleeping Next to Boyfriend, Police Say
The suspect claimed that the woman had made sexual advances towards him in a bathroom, but he "told her no" because he "had a curfew and needed to leave."
The week in 15 headlines
This week, Democratic leaders grappled internally with how to pass President Biden's agenda with a pared-down price tag. Meanwhile, all eyes are on Virginia as a new poll showed the governor's race in a dead-heat.
Joe Rogan calls CNN's Don Lemon a 'dumb motherf-----' for doubling down on 'horse dewormer' narrative
Podcast giant Joe Rogan held no punches towards CNN's Don Lemon after the anchor doubled down on his network's "horse dewormer" narrative.
Invasive species: How they spread, why they're a danger and how to prevent them
Spotted lantern flies, Burmese pythons and Zebra mussels are just some of the invasive species wreaking havoc on ecosystems in the U.S.
Search warrant issued for Alec Baldwin film set after fatal shooting
When Will ‘Locke & Key’ Season 3 Premiere?
Booking my trip back to Matheson right now.
Kamala Harris still has no plans to visit border as feds confirm 1.7M illegals arrested
The feds reported CBP has detained 1,734,686 illegal immigrants attempting to enter the US via the southwest border in fiscal year 2021, but the veep said she does not have plans to head to the border.
'Rust' crew walked off set to protest working conditions hours before cinematographer death: Reports
Crew members reportedly walked off the set of the film "Rust" in protest of working conditions hours before the fatal Alec Baldwin prop gun incident.
Pfizer: COVID vaccine highly effective for kids
Pfizer says kid-size doses of its COVID-19 vaccine are safe and effective at preventing symptomatic infections. If regulators sign off, the shots could begin in early November, with the first children in line fully protected by Christmas. (Oct. 22)
Don't Wait, Get Your Personalized Refinance Rates Now
Need to minimize debt? Transfer to a 0% intro APR card today
Don't Ignore These Valuable Cash Sign Up Bonuses
Spend $500, get $200 Fast With This Top Card
High school girls' tennis: City playoff pairings
High school girls' tennis: City playoff pairings
Tony Ferguson accuses 'fragile' McGregor of PED use; Conor replies to 'sad bastard' – with a death threat
Tony Ferguson and Conor McGregor got personal in a Twitter exchange around a potential fight.       Related StoriesConor McGregor issues warning ahead of UFC return: 'These clowns are f*cked when I get back'UFC Fight Night 196 video: Marvin Vettori flips off, cusses out Paulo Costa in heated faceoffUFC Fight Night 196 predictions: Marvin Vettori or Paulo Costa in 205-pound main event?
Deafening silence on migrant kids and other commentary
Media watch: Deafening Silence on Migrant Kids A report by The Post and confirmed by NBC News that flights originating in Texas are bringing thousands of migrant children to New York suburbs is clearly “newsworthy” — as it further demonstrates “the Biden administration’s failure to secure the border, thereby worsening a humanitarian and national security...
Texas Police Officer Fired After Fatal Shooting of Man Following Low-Speed Chase
"They are handing down judgements without giving time for a complete investigation," said the Arlington Police Association.
Martellus Bennett: Patriots lost game due to Jimmy Garoppolo ‘being a bitch’
Jimmy Garoppolo didn't leave the best impression on Martellus Bennett.
Facebook Employees Warned About Election Misinformation, to Little Effect
Company documents show that the social network’s employees repeatedly raised red flags about the spread of misinformation and conspiracies before and after the contested November vote.
Could 'Dune' stars and besties Timothée Chalamet and Zendaya be any more charming?
Promoting their new movie, 'Dune' actors Zendaya and Timothée Chalamet are leaving interviewers and fans in awe of their obvious affection for each other.
Haiti Gets New National Police Head as Hundreds Protest Following Missionary Kidnappings
"We would like for public peace to be restored, that we return to normal life and that we regain our way to democracy," Prime Minister Ariel Henry said.
Justice Sonia Sotomayor criticizes colleagues for allowing Texas abortion ban to remain in effect
Justice Sonia Sotomayor sent a strong reminder Friday that she is not a justice looking to carve out compromises with a conservative majority.
YouTube deletes rapper's 'Let's Go Brandon' song claiming 'medical misinformation'
Rapper Bryson Gray announced on Twitter Thursday that his music video poking fun at President Joe Biden was removed from YouTube due to “medical misinformation.”
Psaki says Biden approval ratings low because people 'tired of fighting' the pandemic he vowed to shut down
White House press secretary Jen Psaki said President Biden's approval ratings are so low because people are "tired of fighting" the coronavirus pandemic, which Biden promised to “shut down” during the 2020 campaign.
Peter Scolari, ‘Newhart’ and ‘Girls’ Actor, Is Dead at 66
His first big break came as Tom Hanks’s co-star on the TV comedy “Bosom Buddies” in the early 1980s, He also worked on the stage, occasionally on Broadway.
Peter Scolari, of 'Newhart,' 'Bosom Buddies' and 'Girls,' dies at 66
Scolari, a versatile character actor whose television roles included recurring parts on Evil and Girls, has died after fighting cancer for two years.
Walmart recalls essential oil-infused spray after 'rare and dangerous' bacteria found
Officials are looking into four confirmed cases of the dangerous bacteria discovered in the sprays. Two deaths associated with the bacteria are being investigated.
People wonder if they should keep calm and carry on in the face of delta plus variant
A new coronavirus variant — known as delta plus — has cropped up in the U.K. There's concern it could be more dangerous than the highly contagious delta variant. What does the science actually show?
Whoops! Ohio messes up new license plate
The Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles issued a correction to a new license plate design featuring the Wright brothers' plane.