Bill Barr’s Stinging Attack on Bill Barr

In an administration that tends toward incoherence and lunacy, Bill Barr’s great strength is the ability to sound levelheaded. The attorney general is calm, cogent, and logical—and, in contrast to many of his Cabinet colleagues, clearly well studied and qualified for his role.

Barr’s sober demeanor allows him to make a lot of arguments that sound reasonable and persuasive when delivered, as he demonstrated in a speech to Hillsdale College on Wednesday. The problem comes when you start trying to reconcile what he says with the Justice Department’s actions. It’s almost as if there are two Bill Barrs, arguing with each other. If you take what Bill Barr says when he’s posing as a wise legal theorist seriously, you should be very worried about what Bill Barr is actually doing as attorney general.

For example, although there have been accusations that Trump has improperly intervened in the Justice Department, Wise Legal Theorist Bill Barr contends that nothing is amiss, because in a democracy, the people should have ultimate control over the legal system:

The most basic check on prosecutorial power is politics. It is counter-intuitive to say that, as we rightly strive to maintain an apolitical system of criminal justice. But political accountability—politics—is what ultimately ensures our system does its work fairly and with proper recognition of the many interests and values at stake. Government power completely divorced from politics is tyranny.

The Justice Department, he adds, “is an agency within the Executive Branch of a democratic republic—a form of government where the power of the state is ultimately reposed in the people acting through their elected president and elected representatives.” (Barr later adds, “Letting the most junior members set the agenda might be a good philosophy for a Montessori preschool, but it’s no way to run a federal agency.” Referring to your employees as preschoolers might be good red meat in a speech to a conservative audience, but it’s no way to run a federal agency.)

All reasonable stuff on its face. But Attorney General Bill Barr seems to disagree. After all, he assigned U.S. Attorney John Durham to conduct an extensive review of Obama administration officials involved in investigations into Russian interference in the 2016 election, including “unmaskings” related to Michael Flynn, whose prosecution for lying to FBI agents he is seeking to drop. Weren’t those just the actions of democratically accountable executive-branch officials exercising their lawful authority?

[Read: Why the Democrats can’t nail Bill Barr]

Wise Legal Theorist Barr argues that the officials of the Department of Justice are accountable, in part, because “the elected Congress can summon them to explain their decisions to the people’s representatives and to the public.” But under Attorney General Barr, the Justice Department has repeatedly stonewalled Congress. The attorney general himself long refused to testify to the House, and the Justice Department has supported Trump’s attempts to argue that allegations of misconduct against him can be pursued neither by the justice system nor via congressional investigation.

Wise Legal Theorist Bill Barr fulminates against:

taking vague statutory language and then applying it to a criminal target in a novel way that is, at a minimum, hardly the clear consequence of the statutory text.This is inherently unfair because criminal prosecutions are backward-looking. We charge people with crimes based on past conduct. If it was unknown or even unclear that the conduct was illegal when the person engaged in it, that raises real questions about whether it is fair to prosecute the person criminally for it.

The result of this, he says, is “prosecutors bringing ill-conceived charges against prominent political figures.”

Quite right. Has Attorney General Bill Barr heard this critique? He is the person who reportedly told prosecutors to consider charging violent protestors with sedition—that is, plotting to overthrow the United States government. That’s a rarely used charge, and is practically unheard-of in the case of mere violent protests. Now there is a movement that is seeking to provoke a civil war, the “boogaloo.” Federal prosecutors have charged several boogaloo adherents with violent acts over the summer, but Barr himself has been more focused on the left-wing “antifa,” a loose group that, whatever its dangers, does not have seem to have any intention of toppling the government.

Barr is also the person who has reportedly asked prosecutors to look into criminal charges against Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan for allowing protesters to establish a police-free zone in one section of the city over the summer, in what would almost certainly be a novel application of civil-rights laws. (Barr denies this.) And he’s the person who has rushed a decision to bring antitrust charges against Google over the objections of career lawyers. As Wise Legal Theorist Bill Barr would be quick to tell us, this is Attorney General Bill Barr’s prerogative, but it hardly exemplifies the careful, meticulous application of legal theories that he called for in the speech.

Wise Legal Theorist Bill Barr warns that bringing charges against prominent figures in this way creates a “criminalization of politics” in which the legal system is used to punish behavior that is merely “questionable,” and not illegal. This is an important point. There’s all sorts of behavior that is unsavory and perhaps even corrupt in a colloquial sense, but not illegal, and it’s a matter for the political system, not the criminal-justice system, to deal with.

[Sarah Chayes: Hunter Biden’s perfectly legal, socially acceptable corruption]

This seems almost like a rebuke to Attorney General Bill Barr, who blasted Democrats for using the (political) process of impeachment to go after Trump’s attempt to extort Ukraine into assisting his reelection effort, accusing them of taking the president conducting the business of his office, and misconstruing it as misconduct. Yet Barr was also eagerly accepting information from Trump’s lawyer Rudy Giuliani about the business dealings of Joe Biden’s son Hunter in Ukraine—dealings that indeed seem questionable, but about which there remains no proof of criminality.

If Barr is so worried about the criminalization of politics, he can find the chief culprit in the White House. His boss won office on a platform of locking up his opponent, complaining that no charges had ever been brought against her—and then repeatedly pressured Barr’s predecessor to investigate her and find some pretense, any pretense, to prosecute her.

Much of what Barr said in his Hillsdale speech makes a great deal of sense in the abstract. Of course it’s good for ultimate responsibility to rest not with career bureaucrats who are largely unaccountable to the public, but with political appointees accountable to the president, Congress, and finally voters. Of course it’s dangerous for people to be charged under novel legal theories, applied retroactively. Of course politics should not be criminalized. So why doesn’t he take his own advice?

“The Justice Department is not a praetorian guard that watches over society impervious to the ebbs and flows of politics,” Barr said in his Hillsdale speech. Instead, with Barr at the helm, the Justice Department is a praetorian guard that faithfully serves its president, highly attuned to the ebbs and flows of politics.

Load more
Read full article on:
Joe Biden has finally disclosed who is raising him big money just days before Election Day
Photo by Bastiaan Slabbers/NurPhoto via Getty Images Biden has been sharply breaking from precedent in his Democratic Party. Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden finally disclosed the roster of his biggest fundraisers on Saturday, unveiling the names of the 820 people who have helped him build a big-money juggernaut. The list includes Biden surrogates like former South Bend, Indiana Mayor Pete Buttigieg and Rep. Adam Schiff (D-CA); Hollywood filmmakers like Lee Daniels and Jeffrey Katzenberg; Silicon Valley billionaires like Reid Hoffman and Ron Conway. The campaign did not specify how much these people raised for Biden efforts beyond that it was more than $100,000. The release on a Saturday evening came at the last possible moment: Election Day is on Tuesday, and more than 90 million people have already voted, having done so without clarity on who his largest fundraisers are or what influence they may have had on his candidacy. Biden’s last-minute disclosure was a sharp departure from precedent in the Democratic Party, whose presidential candidates have regularly disclosed their so-called “bundlers” in a nod to transparency. And that’s why campaign-finance reformers had grown concerned that Biden had not yet followed his predecessors Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton’s lead in releasing his bundlers for the general election. Biden’s campaign had declined to answer inquiries about their bundlers until last week, when it told The New York Times that it would release their names by the end of October (which ended Saturday.) Both Obama and Clinton released updates on the list of people helping them raise big money at consistent intervals; Biden’s only prior update came on a Friday evening just after Christmas in 2019 during the Democratic primary with about 230 names, before his bundling operation beefed up in earnest. “Congratulations on clearing an artificially low bar they set for themselves that defeats the entire purpose of transparency — allowing voters to know who is funding the campaigns asking for their support before casting their ballots,” said Tyson Brody, a Democratic operative who worked for Bernie Sanders and backs Biden, but is critical of the influence of large campaign contributors. It makes strategic sense that the Biden campaign would not to draw attention to the bundlers who have helped him turn a lagging fundraising operation into a surprising powerhouse. Biden has worked to position himself as the candidate with the interest of the working and middle classes in mind, giving himself the nickname “Middle-Class Joe,” and casting the general election “as a campaign between Scranton and Park Avenue.” And so, the Biden campaign has tried to draw focus to its small-dollar, online fundraising operation, rather than the celebrities, Silicon Valley billionaires, and Wall Street executives whose support undercuts some of the campaign’s messaging. That’s an especially important task for Biden given that many of these characters are prone to draw the scorn of the left, which is already skeptical of Biden and wants to see big campaign contributors play a smaller role in politics. And the Trump campaign hasn’t been in much of a place to argue for transparency. Trump hasn’t released any information about his own bundlers at all. So there’s been limited scrutiny. The upshot of that is that the 90 million people who have already cast ballots ended up voting with very limited information about the people who helped the campaigns raise the money that may have influenced those very votes. The debate over bundler disclosure reflects a key campaign question of the Trump era: Should Trump’s own tactics set the standard for his Democratic rivals? Or should Democrats — who claim to prioritize reducing the role of money in politics — aspire to a higher, or at least the pre-Trump, standard? Campaigns are only legally required to disclose bundlers who are registered lobbyists — everything else is voluntary. Trump and his most immediate GOP predecessor at the top of the ticket, Mitt Romney, declined to share any additional information. But prior to their campaigns, there had been a bipartisan tradition of at least offering some information in order to help voters understand who carried unofficial influence in their campaign; that was done by both John McCain and George W. Bush, who pioneered the modern bundling system and made being a bundler into something of a bragging right. Bundlers do the often painstaking work of soliciting their networks for high-dollar campaign contributions: inviting their business associates to campaign events, making introductions to campaign staffers, and recruiting more bundlers to serve alongside them. Bundling can often end up be fiercely competitive, with campaigns closely tracking how much individuals have raised and bundlers sometimes finding themselves in competition for positions on leaderboards. The Biden campaign has six levels of membership for its finance committee: ranging from a “Protector” who helps the campaign raise $50,000 to a “Biden Victory Partner” who brings home $2.5 million, according to a campaign document seen by Recode. Mementos that Biden has sent that top level of bundler include a gold-and-blue pin. The Biden campaign sends out these buttons to the bundlers who have raised over $2.5 million for his bid.A reminder of how the Joe Biden big-money machine works.— Teddy Schleifer (@teddyschleifer) October 26, 2020 Despite his preference to talk about his low-dollar fundraising operation, Biden has built an impressive big-money machine.
9 m
Sean Connery Has Died. Friends, Fans, and the Other James Bonds Are Saluting Him on Social Media
“He will always be Indy’s dad to us,” wrote Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade producers Kathleen Kennedy and Frank Marshall.
9 m
U.S. airline launching trial program to test passengers for coronavirus pre-flight
United Airlines will soon begin a trial program, giving passengers a rapid COVID-19 test before certain flights to London. Airline officials are hoping to prove to regulators that the program can ensure safe flights during the pandemic and revive the air travel industry. Kris Van Cleave has more.
Tigers' A.J. Hinch on controversial managerial history: 'I understand how wrong it was'
The Detroit Tigers hired A.J. Hinch as their next manager on Friday but as the organization introduced him in the white and blue there were still questions that needed to be answered.
Saturday was October’s chilliest day; Sunday will be the year’s longest
We return to standard time Sunday, with a 25-hour day.
Shanghai could be the world's biggest IPO market this year. Holding the title will be tough
Shanghai is on track to steal the global IPO crown this year, bolstering a drive by Beijing to reduce its reliance on foreign financial markets and giving China a powerful one-two fundraising punch with regional powerhouse Hong Kong.
Revisiting President Trump’s border wall promise
In 2015, then-candidate Donald Trump campaigned on a promise to build a wall spanning the entire southern border with Mexico. Mireya Villarreal rode along with Border Patrol to see how those plans developed.
European nations imposing new lockdowns as coronavirus cases surge out of control
Several countries across Europe are imposing new national lockdowns as coronavirus infections rise once again. France was among the first to impose new restrictions as cases soared out of control. Imtiaz Tyab has more.
North Carolina voter rally ends with pepper spray, 8 arrests
GRAHAM, N.C. (AP) — A get-out-the-vote rally that ended with North Carolina police pepper spraying and arresting attendants was the result of participants blocking the roadway without authorization, authorities said Saturday. Graham police said they issued several warnings to the crowd at Alamance County’s courthouse to move from the roadway before releasing pepper spraying and...
Early voting numbers shatter previous records across the country
With just three days until Election Day, 90 million ballots have already been cast nationwide. That is already more than 65% of the total number of votes cast in 2016. Lilia Luciano has more.
Trump and Biden hold campaign events on final weekend before Election Day
President Trump and Joe Biden are holding multiple rallies on the final weekend before Election Day. Both candidates are making a push to lock up Pennsylvania, which could prove a key swing state. Ben Tracy reports.
U.S. experiencing worst week of coronavirus pandemic as infections peak nationwide
Coronavirus cases continue to trend upward throughout the U.S., months after the start of the pandemic. Hospitalizations and deaths are also climbing across the country as officials plead for people to take the virus more seriously. Michael George reports.
LeBron James reveals he was pondering leaving NBA bubble
The Milwaukee Bucks led a strike during the NBA playoffs after the police shooting of Jacob Blake in Wisconsin during the summer.
Stream It Or Skip It: ‘It: Chapter Two’ on HBO, in Which Pennywise the Clown Returns to Not Be as Scary as We’d Like
A really long Stephen King book becomes a really long movie.
UFC on ESPN+ 39 results: Bryce Mitchell's takedowns make difference against Andre Fili
Bryce Mitchell said he wasn't going to lose in his new camo shorts, and that proved true in his fight with Andre Fili at UFC on ESPN+ 39.        Related StoriesUFC on ESPN+ 39 results: Bryce Mitchell's takedowns make difference against Andre Fili - EnclosureUFC on ESPN+ 39 results: Greg Hardy drops, stops Maurice Green for TKO - EnclosureUFC on ESPN+ 39 results: Greg Hardy drops, stops Maurice Green for TKO
Knicks’ 1990s glory days captured in two compelling books
Knicks fans will get to reminisce like it’s 1999. During this gloomy Knicks century of basketball, two books are emerging about the 1990s Knicks to brighten the day. The first, written by lawyer-turned-author Paul Knepper, is on sale now: “The Knicks of the Nineties: Ewing, Oakley, Starks and the Brawlers That Almost Won It All.”...
Jack Nicklaus questions COVID death toll, took hydroxychloroquine to combat his own virus symptoms
Jack Nicklaus, fresh off of his supportive tweet of President Trump, questioned whether the coronavirus death toll was correct in an interview published Friday.
Biden focuses on slamming Trump coronavirus plan, but faces questions over his plan's specifics
Democratic candidate Joe Biden has taken some heat on social media for attacking President Trump's coronavirus plan, while leaving some with questions about what his own plan entails.
Giants' Logan Ryan compares Tom Brady to the 'final boss in Mario'
Logan Ryan gave Tom Brady a lasting memory of his time with the New England Patriots – a Pick Six to solidify a Tennessee Titans victory in the AFC playoffs.
"CBS Weekend News" headlines for Saturday, October 31, 2020
Here's a look at the top stories making headlines on the "CBS Weekend News” anchored by Major Garrett.
Trump gains ground over Biden in Iowa, poll finds. Ernst leads in a tight Senate race
President Trump has recovered ground in Iowa, leading Joe Biden by 7 points, according to a new poll, and Iowa Sen. Joni Ernst leads Theresa Greenfield.
Ex-NFL star scores TKO win in latest UFC bout
Controversial ex-NFL star Greg Hardy continues to find success in MMA, finishing Maurice Greene in the second round of their UFC on ESPN+ 39 bout.
Iowa farmers split between voting for Trump, Biden
Watch Obama Casually Nail a 3-Pointer in Michigan Campaign Stop
The former president mocked Trump's obsession with crowd sizes and wondered if it was because no one went "to his birthday party when he was a kid."
Twitter reacts to Greg Hardy's finish of Maurice Greene at UFC on ESPN+ 39
See the top Twitter reactions to Greg Hardy's win over Maurice Greene at UFC on ESPN+ 39.       Related StoriesFight Game on the 'Gram: Anderson Silva's best posts before UFC on ESPN+ 39Fight Game on the 'Gram: Uriah Hall's best posts before UFC on ESPN+ 39UFC on ESPN+ 39 play-by-play and live results (4 p.m. ET) 
1 h
Biden campaign cancels Texas event after Trump supporters surround bus on interstate
A campaign bus for Joe Biden traveling Friday from San Antonio to Austin, Texas, was surrounded by multiple vehicles with Trump signs that attempted to slow down the bus and run it off the road, a Biden campaign official tells CNN.
1 h
Single Father Adopts Five Siblings on Ohio County's Adoption Day
Five siblings will now have a forever home thanks to one single Ohio father who adopted them on Adoption Day in Hamilton County Friday morning.
1 h
Poll: Donald Trump leads Joe Biden by 7 points among Iowa voters
President Donald Trump now leads by 7 percentage points in Iowa over former Vice President Joe Biden, 48% to 41%. In September, they were tied.        
1 h
Clemson's Trevor Lawrence to miss Notre Dame game after positive coronavirus test
Trevor Lawrence will not play next week when No. 1 Clemson takes on Notre Dame next week.
1 h
UFC on ESPN+ 39 results: Greg Hardy drops, stops Maurice Green for TKO
Former NFL standout Greg Hardy continued to show improvements in his MMA game when he beat Maurice Greene at UFC on ESPN+ 39.        Related StoriesUFC on ESPN+ 39 results: Greg Hardy drops, stops Maurice Green for TKO - EnclosureTwitter reacts to Greg Hardy's finish of Maurice Greene at UFC on ESPN+ 39UFC on ESPN+ 39 video: Kevin Holland becomes first to go 4-0 in 2020, trash talks Israel Adesanya 
1 h
Interim coach Dominic Kinnear hopes to keep the Galaxy from a last-place finish
Interim coach Dominic Kinnear is popular with players and has a wealth of experience, but keeping the Galaxy from a last-place finish won't be easy.
1 h
78-year-old man clubbed by grill brush in shocking NYC attack
The NYPD is still trying to solve a bizarre and random clubbing attack — involving the kind of long brush used to clean barbecues — that sent a 78-year-old man to the sidewalk in Manhattan on Monday. The victim was walking in front of 393 West 49th St., not far from his Hell’s Kitchen residence,...
1 h
Philippines rocked by massive typhoon
It was blowing westward toward densely populated regions and rain-soaked provinces still recovering from a typhoon that hit a week ago and left at least 22 dead.
1 h
Obama urges voters to turn out to support Biden
Joe Biden received a little extra help Saturday from former US President Barack Obama and R&B icon Stevie Wonder when he tried to get Michigan voters to sign, seal and deliver their ballots. (Oct. 31)       
1 h
Steelers bringing gritty style of past into battle vs. rival Ravens
The Steelers belong to Pittsburgh every bit as much as the old mills and smokestacks, which polluted the air and left buildings and clothes covered in soot, once did. From the days of stogie-chomping Art “The Chief” Rooney and the Steel Curtain dynasty, to Terrible Towels waving at Three Rivers Stadium and Heinz Field, to...
1 h
Amazon is celebrating Alexa's birthday with a huge sale on Alexa devices
These Alexa devices are massively discounted right now as part of Amazon's Alexa birthday celebration—get the details.       
1 h
Third grand juror in Breonna Taylor case wants to speak out
A third grand juror in the Breonna Taylor case plants to speak out about the controversial deliberations that cleared three Louisville cops of any criminal liability in the 26-year-old emergency room tech’s death, according to reports. The announcement comes just three days after two other jurors spoke out for the first time on “CBS This...
1 h
Coastal Carolina's Grayson McCall pushed in facemask during blowout win vs. Georgia State
Coastal Carolina quarterback Grayson McCall was pushed in the facemask by a Georgia State player in the Chanticleers’ blowout of the Panthers on Saturday afternoon.
1 h
The map is wide, Democrats tense and Republicans hopeful in the last days of campaign 2020
Biden and Trump close in on the final days of voting with deeply contrasting styles and messages.
1 h
Rep. Mike Garcia: 'If You Want to Fix the Nation, You've Got to Start with California'
Garcia blasted Democrats' failing policies in California and said he sees more opportunities for red seats in his very blue state.
1 h
Iowa Trump Supporters Hold Trump Tractor Parade
Supporters of President Donald Trump in Atlantic, Iowa, held a Trump tractor parade Friday to show support for the president's re-election.
1 h
Michigan State takes down No. 13 Michigan in Ann Arbor, 27-24
Michigan State delivered a shocking upset to No. 13 Michigan on Saturday, 27-24.
2 h
Mansour: Joe Biden’s Energy Policies Could Wipe Out Millions of Auto Jobs
Rebecca Mansour joined Dan Proft to explain how Joe Biden's proposed energy policies could destroy millions of jobs in the automobile sector.
2 h
Rutgers nearly pulled off one of the craziest touchdowns in college football history
Rutgers pulled off a wild eight-lateral touchdown vs. Indiana that was unfortunately called back for an illegal forward pass.       
2 h
UFC on ESPN+ 39 video: Kevin Holland becomes first to go 4-0 in 2020, trash talks Israel Adesanya
Kevin Holland's activity this year paid off in the form of a notable feat at UFC on ESPN+ 39.        Related StoriesUFC on ESPN+ 39 video: Kevin Holland becomes first to go 4-0 in 2020, trash talks Israel Adesanya - EnclosureUFC on ESPN+ 39 video: Alexander Hernandez becomes first to stop Chris Gruetzemacher with strikesUFC on ESPN+ 39 video: Alexander Hernandez becomes first to stop Chris Gruetzemacher with strikes - Enclosure 
2 h
Solving NYC’s dire economic crisis demands far better leadership than it has now
With the COVID-19 crisis entering its ninth month, the city’s economy and municipal finances face an existential threat, and Gotham’s need for real leadership grows ever more dire. As The New York Times reported last week, the city is now grappling with “a bigger challenge in recovering from the pandemic than almost any other major...
2 h
Trump praises Mike Piazza as Hall of Fame catcher is spotted at Pennsylvania rally
Baseball Hall of Famer Mike Piazza received a shout out from President Trump during a rally in Pennsylvania on Saturday.
2 h
Stevie Wonder Demands Reparations During Biden Rally in Detroit: 'I Know Joe Biden Will Do It'
Pop icon Stevie Wonder, whose estimated net worth exceeds $100 million, called for reparations for black Americans while performing at a Joe Biden rally in Detroit on Saturday.
2 h