<em>Game of Thrones </em>Finally Decides Who Sits on the Iron Throne

Every week for the eighth and final season of Game of Thrones, three Atlantic staffers have been discussing new episodes of the HBO drama. Because no screeners were made available to critics in advance this year, we’ll be posting our thoughts on the series finale in installments.

David Sims: Let me start this review by listing a few of Brandon Stark’s qualifications to hold the Iron Throne (or whatever throne takes its place) of Westeros. One, as the eldest male Stark, he’s got the lordly bloodline to appease the country’s more tradition-obsessed members. Two, he’s got the temperament—ever since he assumed the mantle of the three-eyed raven, I haven’t seen him get remotely upset about anything, so no Mad King potential there. Three, he can see across the sea of time and has the power to mentally experience every memory anyone in Westeros has ever had, which is definitely a helpful skill set going forward. Honestly, someone should have thought to crown Bran earlier.

The sudden decision by Tyrion and company to name Bran as the new Lord of the Seven—sorry, Six—Kingdoms might have prompted a fair bit of whiplash for viewers. In all the warring between Daenerys, Jon, and Cersei, Bran was mostly overlooked as a contender, having become a living Wikipedia database and losing his personality in the process. The move to crown him was arrived at with the same kind of alarming speed that accompanied just about every big plot twist this season. The difference for me was that, by the time of the finale (titled “The Iron Throne”), I was less worried about plausibility and more just wondering how everything would end up. After a largely disappointing lead-up, I was at least satisfied by where the pieces fell.

To summarize: Daenerys the conqueror quickly indicates that she’s not done with warfare and promises to “liberate” people from tyranny all over the world. After a long chat with a depressed and imprisoned Tyrion, Jon realizes he’s not into that plan and stabs his Queen (and aunt and former lover) in front of the Iron Throne, which Drogon then impressively melts before taking his mother’s body to parts unknown. In the wake of that carnage, Westeros’s surviving leaders gather to sift through the mess and appoint Bran as king. “Bran the Broken” then names Tyrion as his hand, sends Jon to the Wall as punishment for killing Dany, and allows Sansa to run the North as an independent kingdom. Arya, eager to do something new, hops on a boat and sails west into uncharted waters.

After the misery of “The Bells,” it was a finale undeniably steeped in fan service, giving audience favorites like Brienne, Davos, Sam, and Bronn seats on the new small council and doing away with literally every bloodthirsty or unstable member of the cast. Seriously—anyone important in Westeros who ever spent a minute scheming about anything is dead, except for Tyrion, who professed himself thoroughly cowed by the whole war and promised to atone for his sins going forward. Jon even got to pet his direwolf Ghost, finally, before he journeyed with Tormund and the other Free Folk beyond the Wall to make a new life.

As a book reader who hopes that George R. R. Martin will one day finally deliver the ending he’s been working toward all these years, I was reassured. Daenerys’s flip to madness was utterly unearned by David Benioff and D.B. Weiss, but in the end, her dream was achieved, and the wheel was ostensibly broken, partly by the bloodshed she wrought in King’s Landing. Sick of the wars of succession that consumed the nation for years, the lords of Westeros will now pick rulers by committee, a system that sounds lovely in theory and that is incredibly fraught in reality. So much of Bran’s rule will probably be plagued with its own issues, but that would be a story for another series, not the Song of Ice and Fire (a title that was helpfully embossed on a large volume for Tyrion to read).

As a fan of the TV show, I felt battered into submission. This season has been the same story over and over again: a lot of tin-eared writing trying to justify some of the most drastic story developments imaginable, as quickly as possible. As usual, the actors did their best with what was on the page; Emilia Clarke and Peter Dinklage, long the two standouts of the show’s ensemble, wrestled mighty performances from unwieldy monologues, with Clarke trying to justify Daenerys’s belief in the burning of the city, and Tyrion finally investing his support in Bran, a living archive of Westeros’s history. Pause and think about the logic of it all for a second, and it’ll collapse under scrutiny. But time and time again in recent years, Benioff and Weiss have opted for grand cinematic gesture over granular worldbuilding, and Drogon burning the Throne to sludge was their last big mic drop. Lenika, Spencer, was that enough to win your fealty?

We will update this post with entries from Spencer Kornhaber and Lenika Cruz.

Load more
Read full article on:
Eight people are believed to be dead after two planes collided over Idaho's Coeur d'Alene Lake
Eight people are believed to be dead after two planes collided over Coeur d'Alene Lake in Idaho and then sank, Kootenai County Sheriff's Office Lt. Ryan Higgins said.
Protesters destroy Christopher Columbus statues over Fourth of July weekend
Protesters beheaded a Christopher Columbus statue in Connecticut, tossed another into Baltimore’s harbor and set fire to a “pioneer family” sculpture in Portland, Oregon, over the Fourth of July weekend as clashes over controversial monuments continued to rage across the country. “While we welcome peaceful protests and constructive dialogue on whether and how to put...
Broadway actor Nick Cordero dies at 41 after long battle with COVID-19
Broadway actor Nick Cordero died of coronavirus complications after spending more than 90 days in the intensive care unit. He was 41.
Nick Cordero, Nominated for Tony as Tap-Dancing Tough Guy, Dies at 41
The Broadway actor’s battle with the coronavirus was followed closely by many as his wife chronicled his experience on social media.
Breonna Taylor's lawyers link her shooting death to 'outrageous' search warrant, Louisville gentrification plan in new court filing
The complaint claims Breonna Taylor got wrapped up in a case that was less about a drug house and more about speeding up the city's development.
Steve Hilton: 5 things Trump should do to win reelection
President Trump should galvanize the country with positivity and optimism, Steve Hilton said Sunday, encouraging the Trump campaign to spread a message of hope as it works to reenergize his reelection bid.
L.A. County coronavirus cases hit a record one-day high over 4th of July weekend
The number of hospital patients with confirmed coronavirus infections jumped 41% in the last three weeks in Los Angeles County.
Rushmore was Trump at his best: Devine
He’s back! President Trump’s brilliant Mount Rushmore speech Friday laid out a winning campaign theme to restore national optimism. Of course, his media antagonists fell over themselves to find fault with it. He presented an antidote to the viciousness that has engulfed America, a declaration of love for this country, warts and all, a reaffirmation...
Remembering Nick Cordero: The Broadway star's life in photos
Broadway star Nick Cordero, a standout in "Rock of Ages" and "Bullets Over Broadway," has died of COVID-19 complications at 41. His life in pictures.
7 men arrested for making Nazi salutes, yelling racial slurs at black family
Seven white men were arrested for allegedly making Nazi salutes and yelling racial slurs at a black family celebrating Independence Day at an Oregon beach, police said Sunday. The seven, from Clark County, Washington, were part of a larger “highly intoxicated” group harassing the family on the Fourth of July in Lincoln City, police said....
Meet Alex Kline, Knicks’ 26-year-old scout with makings of front-office star
He was all sneakers, backpack and glasses, dwarfing his slight frame. He was impossible to miss at AAU events, a high school-aged kid who clearly wasn’t a player. A “cool, nerdy, little geeky guy” is the way close friend Frantz Massenat described him. But if you focused on Alex Kline, you could quickly tell he...
Rep. Steube fires back at Trump critics over July 4 address: 'They will criticize anything he does'
Rep. Greg Steube defended President Trump’s Fourth of July speech Sunday amid withering criticism from liberals who called his remarks divisive instead of unifying.
Aaron Glee has been charged with murders of Oluwatoyin Salau and Vicki Sims in Florida. He 'would have killed again,' experts say.
"Glee would have killed again if given the chance and most likely intended to acquire additional victims," said one renowned expert.
Bloody July 4th weekend rages on in NYC, with two men fatally shot minutes apart
The 4th of July weekend bloodshed in New York City continued Sunday night as at least six men were shot, two fatally, in a span of less than three hours, police said. Three of the four men wounded by gunshots were in grave condition, cops said Sunday night. The first murder, which police were notified...
Nick Cordero, Broadway actor, dies at 41 after battle with Covid-19
Nick Cordero, a Broadway actor who had admirers across the world rallying for his recovery, has died after a battle with Covid-19, according to his wife, Amanda Kloots.
Kevin Harvick wins second straight NASCAR Brickyard 400 at Indianapolis
Kevin Harvick held off Matt Kenseth in overtime at Indianapolis Motor Speedway to earn his fourth NASCAR Cup Series win of the season.       
1 h
Frederick Douglass Statue Torn Down and Vandalized in Rochester, N.Y.
In Rochester on July 5, 1852, Douglass gave the speech “What to the Slave is the Fourth of July,” in which he called the celebration of liberty a sham in a nation that enslaves and oppresses its Black citizens
1 h
Nick Cordero, Broadway actor, dies at 41 after battle with Covid-19
Nick Cordero, a Broadway actor who had admirers across the world rallying for his recovery, has died after a battle with Covid-19, according to his wife, Amanda Kloots.
1 h
'A Nightmare': Georgia Tech Faculty Push Back Against In-Person Reopening Plans
The University System of Georgia is holding in-person classes this fall, with no masks required. It's an anomaly among top public universities — and it will put people at risk, professors say.
1 h
Broadway star Nick Cordero dies at 41 after long battle with COVID-19
Broadway star Nick Cordero has died at 41 after a long battle with COVID-19.
1 h
These senior Indian couples found love again. Not everyone is happy about it
The social stigma around senior couples living together out of wedlock is perpetuated by adult children who fear their parents will be ostracized by their communities.
1 h
These senior Indian couples found love again. Not everyone is happy about it
Evening is Asawari Kulkarni's favorite time of the day. She spends it sipping green tea with her new partner Anil Yardi.
1 h
Tokyo’s First Female Governor Wins Re-Election by Landslide in Vote Clouded by Coronavirus
Yuriko Koike said shortly after declaring victory that “the most urgent problem now is dealing with the virus”
1 h
Nick Cordero dead at 41 after coronavirus battle, wife Amanda Kloots announces
Tony Award-nominated actor Nick Cordero, 41, has died after suffering complications from the coronavirus, according to reports.
1 h
NHL, NHLPA agree on protocols to resume season in big step
Deputy Commissioner Bill Daly told The Associated Press on Sunday that the NHL and NHL Players’ Association have agreed on protocols to resume the season. Daly said the sides are still negotiating an extension of the collective bargaining agreement. A CBA extension is crucial to the process, and the league’s board of governors and players’...
1 h
Nick Cordero, Broadway actor who battled COVID-19, dies at 41
Cordero's leg was amputated after he was sedated in the ICU for 18 days.
1 h
Human remains identified as missing Fort Hood soldier
Human remains found in a shallow Texas grave were positively identified as Army Spc. Vanessa Guillen on Sunday, according to Guillen family attorney Natalie Khawam.
2 h
Broadway star Nick Cordero dies after battle with COVID-19
Tony nominated actor Nick Cordero spent more than a month fighting the virus.       
2 h
Nick Cordero, Broadway star of ‘Waitress’ and ‘A Bronx Tale,’ dead at 41
The Broadway and music communities celebrated a man that many have worked with.
2 h
Side dish becomes side app: gig economy providing needed income for chefs
There’s a gig economy for everything these days, including gourmet cooking. Plenty of new apps are cropping up to help chefs earn extra income during the coronavirus pandemic by cooking or teaching about cooking — and they’re attracting some big name talent. On Monday, Franklin Becker, co-founder of restaurant chain The Little Beet, will launch...
2 h
Broadway star Nick Cordero dies at 41 after coronavirus struggle highlighted by wife Amanda Kloots
Broadway actor Nick Cordero, who earned a Tony Award nomination in 2014, has died at age 41 after a high-profile battle with coronavirus.        
2 h
Human remains identified as missing Fort Hood soldier Vanessa Guillen
Human remains found in a shallow Texas grave last week have been identified as missing Fort Hood soldier Vanessa Guillen, a lawyer for her family said Sunday. The family was informed of the identification by Army officials on Sunday, while in the company of their priest, attorney Natalie Khawam told The Associated Press. Guillen, 20,...
2 h
How the ballet world is adjusting to the coronavirus pandemic
Ballet training begins at the barre, but in the age of the coronavirus pandemic, a kitchen counter and the back of a couch have become substitutes for even America's most elite ballerinas. CBS News political unit associate Sarah Ewall-Wice joins CBSN to discuss how the ballet world has been adjusting.
2 h
Atlanta mayor says Wendy's occupied by protesters will be cleared after shootings; 8-year-old girl killed
After a night of a dozen shootings, including one in which an 8-year-old girl was killed, Atlanta Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms on Sunday said protesters may no longer occupy the Wendy’s where a police officer fatally shot Rayshard Brooks last month.
2 h
Nets’ Garrett Temple sees NBA restart as powerful social justice tool
Don’t get Garrett Temple mistaken: He wasn’t disappointed or even surprised that Nets teammate and fellow union leader Kyrie Irving expressed doubts about the NBA restart. But after seeing the killing of George Floyd finally wake America up to racial injustice — and seeing white allyship grow for Black Lives Matter — Temple said on...
2 h
At Least 70 Shot, 14 Dead by Sunday Night over July 4th Weekend in Chicago
Over 70 people have been shot, at least 14 of them fatally, by Sunday night over the Fourth of July weekend in Mayor Lori Lightfoot's (D) Chicago.
2 h
Terry Francona supports Indians name change: ‘Time to move forward’
CLEVELAND — Cleveland manager Terry Francona won’t sidestep the hot-button topic any longer. He believes the Indians need to change their contentious nickname. “I think it’s time to move forward,” Francona said Sunday. Francona’s comments came two days after the Indians, amid a nationwide movement to erase racially insensitive symbols, released a statement saying the...
2 h
NYC grocers struggle to hire while workers bank on unemployment claims
New York City supermarkets are getting inundated with unemployment claims — while most of them are looking to hire workers during the coronavirus lockdown, not fire them. Morton Williams, which operates 16 stores in the New York metro area, was slammed with 400 claims at the height of the pandemic in March and April —...
2 h
Jeffrey Epstein accuser calls Ghislaine Maxwell arrest 'one of the best days of my life'; sob claim disputed
A Jeffrey Epstein accuser called the arrest of Ghislaine Maxwell “one of the best days of my life,” and said the disgraced financier's ex-girlfriend sobbed loudly in court -- a claim disputed by reporters.
2 h
Jed Lowrie keeps injury a mystery after ‘full-go’ Mets workout
Luis Rojas described Jed Lowrie as “full-go” for Sunday afternoon’s workout and simulated game. The Mets probably hope there is another level he can get to after Lowrie, sporting what he called his “functional” brace, gingerly ran the bases and seemed to be favoring his injured left side that still remains a mystery. But at...
2 h
Milwaukee Bucks close their practice facility after receiving results of Friday's coronavirus tests
The Milwaukee Bucks shut down their practice facility Sunday after receiving the results of Friday's coronavirus testing.        
2 h
Pandemic takes toll on seasonal workers, small businesses
Large outdoor events across the country have been canceled because of the coronavirus pandemic. Those hardest hit by these cancellations include small businesses and seasonal workers. CBS News campaign reporters Musadiq Bidar and Nicole Sganga joined CBSN to discuss the economic impact for businesses, workers and states.
2 h
Trump to hold next rally outdoors in Portsmouth, New Hampshire
In a survey of New Hampshire voters released last month, the president trails Joe Biden.
2 h
Record-high background checks indicates public fear over 'defund police' movement, gun-rights activist says
Firearm-related background checks reached 3.9 million in June, the most since the tracking system was created more than two decades ago, because "people are being hit with a hard dose of reality" amid calls to "defund" the police,​​​​​​​ gun-rights activist Colion Noir said Sunday.
2 h
Snoop Dogg Declares Black Conservatives 'The Coon Bunch,' Targeting Herman Cain, Candace Owens
The rapper Snoop Dogg has smeared several prominent black conservatives "The Coon Bunch," including Herman Cain, Candace Owens, Paris Dennard, and the Angela Stanton. 
2 h
As private sector bleeds, NYC government has barely even begun belt tightening
Crisis, what crisis? You don’t have to look at the numbers behind the city’s new, $92 billion budget to see that neither the mayor nor the City Council takes the COVID-19 calamity seriously: Just to look at the number of workers the city plans to keep on board over the next year. By next June,...
3 h
6-year-old boy killed in San Francisco shooting
A 6-year-old boy was reportedly killed and another person was wounded in a shooting in San Francisco Saturday night. The fatal shooting occurred in the city’s Bayview neighborhood at about 10:45 p.m., the San Francisco Chronicle reported. It’s unclear where the child was shot. He died at a nearby hospital, the newspaper said. The other...
3 h
Heat wave forecast to bake most of U.S.
Roughly 84% of the continental U.S. population will see highs above 90 degrees at least one day this week, and for most, it will be multiple days.
3 h