I’ve read the plans to reopen the economy. They’re scary.

Medical personnel from Riverside University Health Systems administer a coronavirus test during drive-through testing. | Bob Riha Jr./Getty Images

There is no plan to return to normal.

Over the past few days, I’ve been reading the major plans for what comes after social distancing. You can read them, too. There’s one from the right-leaning American Enterprise Institute, the left-leaning Center for American Progress, Harvard University’s Safra Center for Ethics, and Nobel prize-winning economist Paul Romer.

I thought, perhaps naively, that reading them would be a comfort — at least then I’d be able to imagine the path back to normal. But it wasn’t. In different ways, all of these plans say the same thing: Even if you can imagine the herculean political, social, and economic changes necessary to manage our way through this crisis effectively, there is no normal for the foreseeable future. Until there’s a vaccine, we either need economically ruinous levels of social distancing, a digital surveillance state of shocking size and scope, or a mass testing apparatus of even more shocking size and intrusiveness.

The AEI, CAP, and Harvard plans aren’t identical, but they’re similar. All of them feature a period of national lockdown — in which extreme social distancing is deployed to “flatten the curve” and health and testing capacity is surged to “raise the line.” That’s phase one. Phase two triggers after a set period of time (45 days for CAP, three months for Harvard) or, in the AEI plan, after 14 days of falling cases and a series of health supply markers AEI.

 Christina Animashaun/Vox

All of them then imagine a phase two, which relaxes — but does not end — social distancing while implementing testing and surveillance on a mass scale. This is where you must begin imagining the almost unimaginable.

The CAP and Harvard plans both foresee a digital pandemic surveillance state in which virtually every American downloads an app to their phone that geotracks their movements, so if they come into contact with anyone who later is found to have Covid-19, they can be alerted, and a period of social quarantine can begin. Similarly, people would scan QR codes when boarding mass transit, or entering other high-risk public areas. And GPS tracking could be used to enforce quarantine on those who test positive with the disease, as is being done in Taiwan.

To state the obvious: The technological and political obstacles are massive. While similar efforts have borne fruit in Singapore and South Korea, we are a very different country, with a much more mistrustful, individualistic culture. Already, polling shows that 70 percent of Republicans, and 46 percent of Democrats, strongly oppose using cellphone data to enforce quarantine orders.

The CAP plan tries to answer these concerns, but in trying to imagine an answer, it shows the difficulty of the task. It’s worth quoting the CAP proposal at length:

The entity that hosts the data must be a trusted, nonprofit organization—not private technology companies or the federal government. The app could be developed for a purely public health nonprofit entity such as the Association of State and Territorial Health Officials (ASTHO)—an organization that represents state health officials—which would host the data. Congress or foundations could provide funding to develop and operate the technology. States licensing the app could provide ongoing operational funding to ASTHO, provided states receive federal funding for this purpose.

• Additional protections must include the following:

• The amount of data needed and shared must be minimized

• This system must be transparent

• Data must be collected, secured, and stored within the United States

• Data must be automatically deleted after every 45 days

• The sharing of data with the federal government, except for the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), must be prohibited

• The sharing of data with state and local government agencies that are not public health agencies must be prohibited

• The sharing of data with third parties and the sale of data must be prohibited

• Any data shared publicly must be anonymized

As a condition of receiving a COVID-19 test in the future, individuals may be required to download the app, which would include their test result. For others, the app would be voluntary, although the vast majority of people could be expected to download it to see if there are cases in their neighborhood or near their workplace.

I’m not here to say that this, or anything else, is impossible. But it is light-years beyond the kind of political leadership and public-private coordination we’ve seen thus far. Who is going to spearhead the effort? President Donald Trump? House Speaker Nancy Pelosi? Bill Gates? Who is trusted enough, in this country in this moment, to shape this? And even if they could pass it, can we build it, and do so quickly? Force adherence to it, and quickly? Are we really going to deny tests to anyone who refuses to download the surveillance app? And what about communities with less digital savvy?

The alternative to mass surveillance is mass testing. Romer’s proposal is to deploy testing on a scale no one else is contemplating — 22 million tests per day — so that the entire country is being tested every 14 days, and anyone who tests positive can be quickly quarantined. He shows, in a series of useful simulations, that even if the test has a high false-negative rate, the retesting is sufficient to keep the virus contained, and thus the country can return to normalcy rapidly. Of the various plans, this one seems likeliest to permit a true and rapid economic recovery.

 Sebastian Gollnow/Picture Alliance via Getty Images A doctor measures the temperature of a visitor in front of the entrance to the Katharinen Hospital in Germany.

But it is hard to imagine a testing effort of this scale, either. So far, America is struggling to get into the millions of tests per week. This requires the US to do tens of millions per day. Most experts I’ve spoken to doubt that’s realistic anytime soon, though some believe it’s possible, eventually. So far, we’ve added testing capacity largely by repurposing existing labs and platforms. To add more, we need to build more labs, more machines, more tests. And there are already shortages of reagents, swabs, and health workers.

But even if those constraints could be overcome, how are these 22 million daily tests going to be administered? By whom? How do we enforce compliance? If you refuse to get tested, are you fined? Jailed? Cut off from government benefits? Would the Supreme Court consider a proposal like this constitutional?

The AEI proposal is the closest thing to a middle path between these plans. It’s more testing, but nothing approaching Romer’s hopes. It’s more contact tracing, but it doesn’t envision an IT-driven panopticon. But precisely for that reason, what it’s really describing is a yo-yo between extreme lockdown and lighter forms of social distanncing, continuing on until a vaccine is reached.

This, too, requires some imagination. Will governors who’ve finally, at great effort, reopened parts of their economies really keep throwing them back into lockdown every time ICUs begin to fill? Will President Donald Trump have the stomach to push the country back into quarantine after he’s lifted social distancing guidelines? What if unemployment is 17 percent, and his approval rating is at 38 percent?

And even if the political hurdles could be cleared, it’s obvious, reading the AEI proposal, that there’ll be no “V-shaped recovery” of the economy. Scott Gottlieb, the former FDA commissioner who helped craft the plan, says he thinks something like 80 percent of the economy will return — that may sound like a lot, but it’s an economic collapse of Great Depression proportions.

I don’t want anyone to mistake this as an argument for surrendering to the disease. As unlikely as these futures may be, I think the do-nothing argument is even less plausible: It imagines that we simply let a highly lethal virus kill perhaps millions of Americans, hospitalize tens of millions more, and crush the health system, while the rest of us go about our daily economic and social business. That is, in my view, far less likely than the construction of a huge digital surveillance state. I care about my privacy, but not nearly so much as I care about my mother.

My point isn’t to criticize these plans when I have nothing better to offer. Indeed, my point isn’t to criticize them at all. It’s simply to note that these aren’t plans for returning to anything even approaching normal. They either envision life under a surveillance and testing state of dystopian (but perhaps necessary!) proportions, or they envision a long period of economic and public health pain, as we wrestle the disease down only to see it roar back, as is currently happening in Singapore.

What’s even scarier to consider is that the debate between these plans is far beyond the political debate we’re actually having. As of now, the White House has neither chosen nor begun executing on a plan of its own. That’s a terrible abdication of leadership, but reading through the various proposals, you can see why it’s happened. Imagine you’re the president of the United States in an election year. Which of these futures, with all its costs and risks and pain, would you want to try and sell to the American people?

One final takeaway from all this: If there is literally anything more we can possibly do to accelerate the development of vaccines or therapeutics, we should do it.

Support Vox’s explanatory journalism

Every day at Vox, we aim to answer your most important questions and provide you, and our audience around the world, with information that has the power to save lives. Our mission has never been more vital than it is in this moment: to empower you through understanding. Vox’s work is reaching more people than ever, but our distinctive brand of explanatory journalism takes resources — particularly during a pandemic and an economic downturn. Your financial contribution will not constitute a donation, but it will enable our staff to continue to offer free articles, videos, and podcasts at the quality and volume that this moment requires. Please consider making a contribution to Vox today.

Load more
Read full article on:
New Zealand set to ease coronavirus restrictions after 11 days with no new cases
New Zealand's government could ease coronavirus restrictions as early as next week, Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern announced Tuesday.
9 m
Deroy Murdock says George Floyd's story becoming 'second fiddle' to looting and rioting
Deroy Murdock appeared on “America’s Newsroom” after writing an op-ed that addressed the chaos during protests over George Floyd’s death in NYC.
Cuomo says looters and protesters are separate groups: "We can't blur the lines"
"COVID-19 is one issue, the outrage over Mr. Floyd is another issue, looters are another issue," he said.
Philadelphia gun range owner fatally shoots suspected burglar
A Philadelphia gun range owner fatally shot a suspected burglar inside his business early Tuesday, police said. The 67-year-old owner told cops he spent the night at Firing Line Inc. on South Front Street after a recent attempted burglary at his business, CBS Philadelphia reports. “He was inside of his gun shop overnight because someone...
State Secretary Mike Pompeo to Visit China's Tiananmen Square Survivors Amid Growing U.S. Protests
Secretary of State Mike Pompeo was set to visit survivors of China's 1989 crackdown on Tiananmen Square protests as the death toll in demonstrations across the United States continued to rise.
Facebook employees protest Zuckerberg's inaction
The protests come after Mark Zuckerberg opted not to take action against President Trump's inflammatory posts about protests.
Indonesia Cancels Hajj Pilgrimage, Citing Risks Of Travel During Pandemic
"Our religion teaches us that saving lives is an obligation. That is the consideration in this policy," Minister of Religious Affairs Fachrul Razi says.
Jets capable of late splash with Trumaine Johnson’s $11 million off the books
The Jets gained $11 million in salary cap space Tuesday as a chunk of Trumaine Johnson’s contract came off the books. The Jets designated Johnson as a post-June 1 cut when they released him in March. That allows them to spread the dead money from his contract over two years. He carries a $4 million...
Karol G apologizes for using her dog to promote Black Lives Matter
"I recognize that the way I expressed myself was not right."
Southwest flight attendant has emotional conversation about race with passenger revealed as American Airlines CEO
You never know who you'll meet on a plane.
Video shows looters ransacking storefronts in Philadelphia
The footage, shot Saturday by a man on a bike, shows City Center in chaos, with shattered windows and shuttered stores covered in graffiti -- as large crowds fill the streets and looters raid the businesses in broad daylight.
A controversial Confederate statue with its back to the north was removed in historic Old Town Alexandria
Crews in historic Old Town Alexandria quickly removed a bronze statue of a Confederate soldier named "Appomattox" Tuesday morning.
Column: History lesson? After Hoover's military attacked peaceful protesters, he lost reelection
Hoover also ordered an attack on peaceful protesters -- and lost the presidency.
Cristobal becomes the earliest third Atlantic named storm on record
The 2020 hurricane season is only two days old and is already an active one. Cristobal is now the third named storm of the season. It's the earliest a third named storm has ever formed.
Surgeon General warns of coronavirus outbreaks from Floyd protests
US Surgeon General Dr. Jerome Adams said to expect new outbreaks of the coronavirus resulting from the nationwide protests over the death of George Floyd that have seen thousands of people gather in close proximity.
New York Governor Cuomo says police failed to do their job during protests
New York Governor Andrew Cuomo said on Tuesday that New York City's police failed in their duty to protect the public from looting and other criminal activity during protests the previous night, and that the city's mayor had refused help from the National Guard.
Pedro Martinez: ‘Dirty’ side of baseball can’t be the problem now
Pedro Martinez isn’t siding with the owners. He isn’t siding with the players. Instead, the Hall of Fame hurler is on the side of who he believes matters the most – the fans – in the midst of the dispute into starting the season amidst the novel coronavirus pandemic. “I hope that they take in...
Trump tweets 'no problems' after peaceful protesters tear-gassed for photo op
President Donald Trump Tuesday praised "overwhelming force" and "domination" after peaceful protest broken up for his photo op.
Pelosi cites Ecclesiastes in response to Trump, says it is a time for healing
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi on Tuesday cited religious text in response to President Donald Trump's photo opportunity with a Bible outside of St. John's Church in Washington, DC, which came after law enforcement forcibly cleared peaceful protesters away from the White House using tear gas and riot shields.
Biden Says Trump Is 'Consumed by Blinding Ego' When It Comes to Obama, Calls for Severe Punishments for 'Bad Cops'
The former vice president called for Americans to take a "hard look at the culture that allows for the senseless tragedies that keep happening."
Romanian shoemaker creates size 75 shoes for social distancing
Social distancing, but make it fashionable.
A Vet Visit Video Shows a Nervous Cat's Love for Its Human
Not all pets love the vet, and Reddit has some great soothing tips.
COVID-19 has made food insecurity worse in Puerto Rico
COVID-19 has made food insecurity worse in Puerto Rico; a local food bank doubles the amount of food given out.
Mitch McConnell denounces officers in George Floyd case, calls for justice
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell has weighed in on the murder of George Floyd, voicing appreciation for the outrage caused by his death, while denouncing the violent protesters who disrupt peaceful demonstrations. Speaking on the Senate floor Monday, McConnell (R-Ky.) described “an hour of great pain and unrest in our country.” “Americans from coast to...
Terrence Floyd says looting won't "bring my brother back"
It seems Monday night, protesters in Minneapolis took Terrence Floyd's words to heart.
Trump's Grotesque Violation of the First Amendment
The contrast is striking: On May 28, Donald Trump demanded the First Amendment right of free speech for himself on privately owned social media, and then, four days later, declared war on the people, gathered on public property, as they sought, in the words of the amendment itself, “to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”The right of assembly is an important First Amendment right, one treasured by the founding generation and the First Congress, which wrote the amendment, and one re-won two centuries later at great pain by the labor, civil-rights, and anti-war movements. The show of force that swept peaceful protesters from Lafayette Park in Washington, D.C., last night was an assault—and perhaps only one of a series of assaults—on that right.[Quinta Jurecic and Benjamin Wittes: The law-enforcement abuses that don’t bother Trump]During the 18th century, the British crown looked with disfavor on what was then called “the people out of doors”—ordinary people assembled to discuss their grievances, or to ask their rulers to address them. If 12 or more subjects of the king assembled, any royal jack-in-office could “read them the riot act”: Our sovereign lord the King chargeth and commandeth all persons, being assembled, immediately to disperse themselves, and peaceably to depart to their habitations, or to their lawful business, upon the pains contained in the act made in the first year of King George, for preventing tumults and riotous assemblies. God save the King. If the crowd did not disperse within an hour, the authorities could disperse them by force. Officials were granted immunity if any of the “rioters” were “killed, maimed or hurt.”And those arrested could be hanged.When the new American government was formed, the Second Congress enacted the Militia Act, a more limited law governing “unlawful assembly.” Federal authorities could use force to break up assemblies only if they amounted to “insurrections”—and the act had to be invoked by the president himself, not by his appointees.The right of assembly had a rough go for the first century and a half of the Constitution. By the end of the 19th century, no less an authority than Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. (the son of a founder of this magazine, and then a state judge) briskly dismissed the idea of expressive rights on public property. Public property belonged to the government, Holmes said, not to the people at all. “For the legislature absolutely or conditionally to forbid public speaking in a highway or public park is no more an infringement of the rights of a member of the public than for the owner of a private home to forbid it in his house.” The U.S. Supreme Court tersely affirmed Holmes’s opinion. “Peaceful assembly” be damned. The people were not to come “out of doors” without the permission of their rulers.[Nora Benavidez: First Amendment rights—if you agree with the President]Only half a century later, in a case about the rights of labor organizers, did Justice Owen Roberts, writing for a plurality, cleanse the law of Holmes’s view of government as the owner and citizens as guests. Roberts wrote: Wherever the title of streets and parks may rest, they have immemorially been held in trust for the use of the public and, time out of mind, have been used for purposes of assembly, communicating thoughts between citizens, and discussing public questions. Such use of the streets and public places has, from ancient times, been a part of the privileges, immunities, rights, and liberties of citizens. The privilege of a citizen of the United States to use the streets and parks for communication of views on national questions may be regulated in the interest of all . . . but it must not, in the guise of regulation, be abridged or denied. The people own the streets—not the police, not the military, and not Donald Trump. And regulation of their use of the streets must be conducted with the greatest care, recognizing that occasional inconvenience caused by demonstrations is the price America pays for free government. The fact that some demonstrations are violent cannot be used to strip all Americans of their right to assemble.That right has been under assault since the day Trump took office. As outlined in a new report by PEN America, red-state legislatures have been indefatigable in debating and passing laws designed to penalize protesters for disfavored causes. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals last year approved a grotesque opinion holding that anyone who organizes a protest can be sued—and thus possibly bankrupted—if someone else present commits an illegal act.[James Fallows: Is this the worst year in modern American history?]Trump has never cared much for these foundational American ideals. Years ago, as a private citizen, he spoke with great admiration of China’s leaders for their 1989 massacre of peaceful protesters in Tiananmen Square: “They were vicious, they were horrible, but they put it down with strength,” Trump told Playboy in 1990. “That shows you the power of strength.”Trump may fancy that June 1 will be known as his Tiananmen moment, his show of strength. But the American tradition is quite different from the Chinese. The dispersal of the peaceful protesters in Lafayette Square was a monstrous violation of America’s venerable right of assembly, and so are the occasions across the country when police departments respond to peaceful marches with flash-bang grenades, rubber bullets, and tear gas. Some people in the streets have responded with violence—and that is a violation of the law. But when police treat demonstrators as illegitimate intruders in the people’s streets, when they respond to peaceable assembly with weapons of war, they too break the law—America’s fundamental law, the Constitution.
Rep. Doug Collins: Why aren't Democrats, media calling out rioters?
Former House Judiciary Committee Chairman Rep. Doug Collins, R-Ga., questioned Tuesday why Democratic leaders weren't calling out those rioting, looting, and shooting police officers amid the George Floyd protests.
Celebrities Dig Deep During George Floyd Protests, Donating Millions to Racial Justice Causes
Chrissy Teigen, Seth Rogen, Janelle Monae, The Weeknd, Cynthia Nixon, Halsey, Colin Kaepernick and more have donated to various organizations.
Former FBI lawyer Lisa Page rips 'monstrous' Trump: I sent a 'few mean texts,' he 'assaulted' protesters
Former FBI agent Lisa Page suggested on Tuesday that the president participated in a "coup" by allegedly assaulting peaceful protesters for a "photo op" at the church burned down across from the White House.
The Inconceivable Strangeness of Trump’s Bible Photo Op
Still photography doesn't even do it justice.
January Jones shares rare photo of 8-year-old son Xander protesting
He held up a sign that read, "I CAN'T BREATHE."
Cops mistakenly handcuff residents instead of would-be looters: video
Dramatic video shows armed California business owners and local residents in a standoff with looters — then getting handcuffed when the cops finally show up. The footage shows two residents from a Van Nuys neighborhood and the owners of a liquor store, who are holding rifles, in a verbal beef with a small group of...
12 Father's Day gifts to order now before it's too late
He'll love all of these—and you still have time to get them.
Coronavirus ‘clinically no longer exists’ in Italy, doctor says
Italy — the first country in the world to surpass China's coronavirus death toll — was the first European country to lock down in early March.
Thousands in Germany Protest in Support of Black Lives Matter, Call for U.S. to End Human Rights Violations
Following Sunday's demonstration outside of the United States Embassy in Berlin, protestors gathered to support Black Lives Matter and demand an end to police violence and racism on Tuesday.
Government watchdog: Airport fever screenings for coronavirus raise racial discrimination, privacy concerns
Government civil liberties watchdog pushes back on White House plan to temperature screen for COVID-19 at airports
How imperfect game changed much more than the lives of Armando Galarraga, Jim Joyce
“It is going to be the first line in my obituary.” — Jim Joyce It is not this simple: Joyce missed a call and the Astros committed baseball sins that rocked the sport. It is not that kind of straight line. From there to here. A lot happened in between. And MLB was probably on...
Twitter suspends account that called for violence amid nationwide George Floyd protests
Twitter suspended an account named “Antifa _US” tied to the white nationalist group Identity Evropa on Monday after it posted messages calling for violence, according to Axios.
Only 5 Percent of Homeowners Approved for Forbearance Couldn't Pay Mortgage Without It, Survey Finds
Another 26.2 percent could have paid their mortgages, but would have had to skip other essential bills.
Lea Michele's 'Glee' costars claim she made working on the TV show 'a living hell'
'Glee' alumni Samantha Marie Ware and Alex Newell called out their former costar Lea Michele after Michele tweeted #BlackLivesMatter in honor of George Floyd.
NY AG Letitia James threatens to sue Trump over military deployment
New York Attorney General Letitia James has threatened to sue President Trump for mobilizing military forces to states to quell riots and looting that have broken out across the country in the wake of George Floyd’s death. “The President of the United States is not a dictator, and President Trump does not and will not...
Rihanna’s Fenty brands cease sales for Blackout Tuesday
The star has paused production for the day to support Black Lives Matter.
Feds expect coronavirus to drain trillions from US economy
The feds expect the coronavirus crisis to drain trillions of dollars from the US economy over the next decade, in the latest sign of the pandemic's economic devastation.
'Pokémon Go' Throwback Challenge Champion Event: Galarian Forms, Start Time & Everything You Need to Know
Catch a Genesect for completing the special research tasks.
People from UK's ethnic minorities up to 50% more likely to die from coronavirus than white people
People from the UK's ethnic minority communities are up to 50% more likely to die with coronavirus than their white British peers, a government review has found.
Pink slams ‘All Lives Matter’ supporters on Instagram
"You are the epitome of white privilege."
Exclusive: Lonza sets new goal to make Moderna COVID-19 vaccine ingredients
Lonza aims to speed completion of two commercial production lines for Moderna Inc's trial COVID-19 vaccine so manufacturing could start four to six weeks earlier than planned if the project is successful, the Swiss drugmaker's chairman said on Tuesday.
Virus-tracking app angers thousands in Moscow with fines
MOSCOW — When nurse Maria Alexeyeva caught coronavirus at work, she isolated herself at home and followed the rules set down by Moscow authorities: She checked in with doctors regularly, didn’t leave her apartment and downloaded a smartphone app required by the city to keep tabs on quarantined patients. The Social Monitoring app tracks users...