Pat Narduzzi’s Pitt is harder to figure out than usual, which is saying a lot

Pat Narduzzi

The Panthers took another step back in 2018 ... but won the ACC Coastal anyway.

Bill C’s annual preview series of every FBS team in college football continues. Catch up here!

Any decent high school prospect can put together a highlight film that makes him look like a star. Any major football program can put together a year-in-review highlight film that makes it seem like they went undefeated. And any head coach can put together a pretty strong achievements list after a while.

Pitt’s Pat Narduzzi can do better than most after his four years in charge.

Here they are in 2015, beating three bowl teams to improve from six to eight wins in his first season. In 2016, beating eventual national champion Clemson in Death Valley, on Chris Blewitt’s last-second field goal. In 2016, riding comeback kid James Conner and quarterback Nathan Peterman to a No. 4 ranking in Off. S&P+. In 2017, beating No. 2 Miami in freshman quarterback Kenny Pickett’s first career start. In 2018, coming back from 11 points down to beat Duke, then riding that momentum to four straight wins and a first-ever ACC Coastal title.

Top-five wins ... division title ... that’s a hell of a coaching job right there! Narduzzi is building something ferocious in the Steel City! About that:

Per S&P+, Pitt has actually regressed in three of its four seasons under Narduzzi. The 2016 team took a decent step to 23rd overall, but the Panthers fell to 47th and 61st in the next two seasons. They were 4-7 when Miami came to town in 2017, and 2018 comes with a “Well, somebody had to win this horrid division” asterisk.

To be sure, Pitt’s good fortune has changed of late. For years, the Panthers were an “almost” program. They were oh, so close to a breakthrough in Dave Wannstedt’s final seasons, but they lost three games by a total of 11 points in 2009, then went 1-3 in one-possession games in 2010. Then, in three years under Paul Chryst, they went 5-10 in such games, 1-5 in what should have been an excellent 2014.

Under Narduzzi, the close-game gods have been a hair kinder: Pitt’s 12-13 in one-possession finishes. And they perfectly timed a month’s worth of solid play in 2018, which allowed them to scoop up the Coastal crown that no one else wanted. But outside of that month, they went 3-7 last fall.

Pitt continues to rack up achievements while watching its foundation crumble. Four years in, I can’t even give a decent answer to the question, “Is Narduzzi doing a good job?” I can’t really tell what is in store.

I also can’t really figure out what to think about Pitt in 2019, as the Panthers’ strengths and weaknesses could completely flip. In 2018, Pitt rode a dominant run game (11th in Rushing S&P+) to compensate for a bad passing game (103rd in Passing S&P+). The defense benefited from an aggressive, occasionally play-making front while giving up too many gashes in the back.

In 2019, the Panthers return Pickett for a second full season of starting and bring back just about every wide receiver, too. Their secondary is loaded with experience as well.

They also lose just about all of their best players. Running backs Qadree Ollison and Darrin Hall combined for 2,357 yards and 21 touchdowns. They’re gone, as are four starters on the offensive line, two of last year’s top three defensive linemen, and three of last year’s top four linebackers.

So the strengths get weaker, the weaknesses get stronger, and the Panthers become even blurrier than normal.

I am rather confident, however, in saying another Coastal crown is going to be difficult. Per S&P+, Miami, Virginia, Virginia Tech, and UNC are projected to improve, Tech by quite a bit. On paper, Miami and Virginia were already better than the Panthers last year, and they could take further steps forward while Pitt is projected to stand still. Granted, they both have to come to Heinz Field this fall, but the road to a repeat is going to be tricky.


Pickett has most certainly made his moments count. He was 18-for-29 and steady enough to guide the Panthers ahead of imploding Miami in the last game of 2017, and he was brilliant in three of the four games during Pitt’s title-clinching streak last fall.

Against Duke, Virginia Tech, and Wake Forest, he completed 64 percent of his passes at 16.5 yards per completion, with six touchdowns, no picks, and a passer rating of 187.4. That’s between Kyler Murray-ish and Will Grier-ish. Receivers Taysir Mack and Maurice Ffrench combined for 26 yards per catch and five touchdowns in these three games.

In last year’s other 11 games, he completed 57 percent of his passes at just 9.4 yards per completion, with six touchdowns, six interceptions, and a ghastly 104.6 passer rating, worse than that of Miami’s N’Kosi Perry. Mack and Ffrench: 15 yards per catch, two touchdowns.

Pickett, Mack, and Ffrench return, and that’s good. But how good are they? The upside is obvious, but there’s been no semblance of consistency.

NCAA Football: Sun Bowl-Pittsburgh vs Stanford Ivan Pierre Aguirre-USA TODAY Sports Kenny Pickett

In an attempt to coax a bit more out of the offense in general, Narduzzi brought in a wise old hand: former UMass head coach Mark Whipple, who replaces Shawn Watson as offensive coordinator.

Once regarded as a pro-style innovator as head coach at Brown and UMass in the 1990s, Whip served as quarterbacks coach for the Steelers and Browns, coaxing a 3,300-yard season out of Miami’s Jacory Harris in 2009 as well. In his second stint as UMass’ head man, he never got the defense or run game where he wanted it, but the Minutemen could pass.

Despite dealing with QB injuries, UMass produced 3,577 passing yards and a 153.9 passer rating (16th in FBS) last fall. Whipple might not have a lot left in the tank as a head coach, but until proven otherwise, he’s still a QB whisperer. I like this move, and considering what star WR Andy Isabella did for UMass last year, Ffrench and Mack should like it, too.

This was basically a three-man receiving corps last year, and one of the three (Rafael Araujo-Lopes) is gone, so it would really help if someone like senior Tre Tipton, sophomore Shocky Jacques-Louis, or sophomore Dontavius Butler-Jenkins stepped up.

NCAA Football: Pittsburgh at Wake Forest Jeremy Brevard-USA TODAY Sports Taysir Mack

UMass ran the ball just 51 percent of the time on standard downs (112th in FBS) and 30 percent on passing downs (95th), each well below the national average and miles away from Pitt’s own tendencies (70 percent and 43 percent, respectively). But considering the run personnel Pitt loses, this might be the time for a drastic stylistic change.

Ollison and Hall were really good. Despite an unreliable passing game and run-heavy tendencies, they each made the most of the running lanes they found, combining for a 47 percent success rate and 26 carries of 20-plus yards.

Granted, their replacements produced similar numbers on a smaller scale — over 61 carries, A.J. Davis, V’Lique Carter, and Mychale Salahuddin combined for a 56 percent success rate and three carries of 20-plus yards.

Throw in four-star sophomore Todd Sibley Jr., and you’ve perhaps got more than enough talent in the backfield. But the experience level drops significantly, both at RB and on the line. Center Jimmy Morrissey has started 23 games for the Panthers; all other returnees have combined for nine starts, and five of those were at another school (Michigan transfer Nolan Ulizio was a part-timer for the Wolverines in 2017).


Just because you fielded good defenses as a coordinator doesn’t mean that’ll carry over when you become a head coach. Plenty of former defensive coordinators have become known more for offense as head coaches (Oklahoma’s Bob Stoops, for instance).

It’s still jarring, though, to see Pitt’s defensive numbers. In Narduzzi’s last four seasons as Michigan State’s coordinator, he and boss Mark Dantonio fielded defenses that ranked ninth, second, third, and 14th in Def. S&P+. In his first four seasons at Pitt, the Panthers have ranked 35th, 75th, 48th, and 53rd. That’s not horrible, but instead of growing stronger as Narduzzi’s recruits have filled the two deep, Pitt’s defense has basically stayed the same, even after Randy Bates took over as coordinator last season.

NCAA Football: Pittsburgh at Virginia Geoff Burke-USA TODAY Sports Rashad Weaver

Attrition could mean sketchy depth in 2019. Pitt could theoretically field a starting lineup of all juniors and seniors with almost nothing but unproven freshmen and sophomores as backups. A run of injury, especially in the front seven, could lead to total collapse.

That starting 11 could still be pretty good, though. End Rashad Weaver (14 tackles for loss, 6.5 sacks, four pass breakups) returns, and while Dewayne Hendrix is gone, junior Patrick Jones II could be ready for more responsibility. Three of last year’s top four tackles are also back, led by senior Amir Watts. The linebacking corps is pretty unproven, but the line should do the LBs some favors.

NCAA Football: Miami at Pittsburgh Charles LeClaire-USA TODAY Sports Dane Jackson

Last year’s secondary was all-or-nothing — 32nd in completion rate allowed, 90th in passing marginal explosiveness — which is certainly more exciting than simply being average. And in cornerback Dane Jackson (four TFLs, 14 breakups, four forced fumbles), the most all-or-nothing piece returns. So do safeties Damar Hamlin and Jazzee Stocker. If any youngster breaks into the starting lineup, though, it’ll probably be sophomore Paris Ford, a local and former blue-chipper whose career started slowly but still has plenty of time to pick up.

 Special Teams

Pitt’s been consistent, if nothing else, in special teams: the Panthers have ranked between 60th and 82nd in all of Narduzzi’s seasons. Place-kicker Alex Kessman improved by quite a bit as a sophomore and ranked 10th in field goal efficiency, but the rest of the unit lagged. Punting was a disaster with freshman Kirk Christodoulou (112th in punt efficiency), and the return game was even more all-or-nothing than the secondary — Araujo-Lopes (gone) and Ffrench (back) combined for three return scores but each ranked outside of the top 70 in punt and kick return efficiency.

If Christodoulou improves like Kessman did as a sophomore, this unit will improve, too.

2019 outlook 2019 Schedule & Projection Factors Date Opponent Proj. S&P+ Rk Proj. Margin Win Probability 31-Aug Virginia 41 -1.6 46% 7-Sep Ohio 82 8.2 68% 14-Sep at Penn State 14 -17.1 16% 21-Sep UCF 27 -5.4 38% 28-Sep Delaware NR 25.9 93% 5-Oct at Duke 65 -1.6 46% 18-Oct at Syracuse 56 -3.3 42% 26-Oct Miami 19 -7.6 33% 2-Nov at Georgia Tech 89 4.7 61% 14-Nov North Carolina 61 3.1 57% 23-Nov at Virginia Tech 30 -9.3 30% 30-Nov Boston College 72 5.6 63% Projected S&P+ Rk 59 Proj. Off. / Def. Rk 65 / 53 Projected wins 5.9 Five-Year S&P+ Rk 9.4 (36) 2- and 5-Year Recruiting Rk 51 2018 TO Margin / Adj. TO Margin* 2 / 7.6 2018 TO Luck/Game -2.0 Returning Production (Off. / Def.) 64% (64%, 64%) 2018 Second-order wins (difference) 6.8 (0.2)

From the Whipple-led passing game, to the young running backs, to Weaver and Jones in the pass rush, to Jackson and company in the secondary, Pitt has about as much upside as it’s had under Narduzzi.

But having a high ceiling hasn’t been the issue in recent years — consistency has been. And at first glance, there’s no reason to assume that will be suddenly fixed.

Just a little bit of extra efficiency could go a long way, though. While Pitt is projected 6-6 and just 59th in S&P+, eight games are projected within a touchdown or less. That Miami, UCF, and Virginia come to Heinz Field puts those games within winning range, but games at Georgia Tech and Duke are extremely losable.

A Pitt that finds more consistency in the passing game and avoids too many front-seven injuries could make a run at eight or nine wins.

Of course, a Pitt that doesn’t could lose eight or nine.

 Team preview stats

All 2019 preview data to date.

Load more
Read full article on:
Michael Conforto spent ‘frustrating’ MLB pause as Mets’ union voice
Michael Conforto’s stress level surged during baseball’s layoff, well beyond the concern of his strained oblique or the coronavirus outbreak that threatened the season. As the Mets’ union representative, Conforto was charged with conveying information to his teammates in May and June as the MLBPA and owners battled over an economic plan that would allow...
President Trump Lists Those to Be Included in American Heroes Garden
President Donald Trump addressed the nation on Saturday during his Salute to America celebration from the White House, where he announced the first round of historical figures to be included in the National Garden of American Heroes.
Trump praises founding fathers, military in fiery 4th of July speech
"Our country is in great shape," the president told an audience filled with soldiers and medical workers on the South Lawn of the White House.
Trump maintains divisive tone in Independence Day remarks
President Donald Trump maintained a divisive tone in a speech during an Independence Day celebration at the White House. The remarks were similar to those he delivered at Mount Rushmore on July 3. CNN's Jeremy Diamond has more.
Trump's powerful message of rage
Breathe easy, America. President Donald Trump's got this. A deadly pandemic is tearing through the country, but the statues are going to be all right, writes Michael D'Antonio.
Rocket Lab declares Electron launch failure
The innovative Electron rocket suffered a malfunction while its second stage was firing.
Death row inmate Scott Erskine, who murdered two boys in San Diego, dies of COVID-19
The 57-year-old had been on death row since 2004 for murdering two boys he abducted and tortured in 1993. The case went unsolved for eight years.
Yankees’ DJ LeMahieu and Luis Cessa test positive for coronavirus
Two Yankees have tested positive for coronavirus before coming to New York, manager Aaron Boone told reporters on Saturday. DJ LeMahieu, one of the Yankees’ top hitters, and spot starter and reliever Luis Cessa have tested positive for COVID-19. They both are isolating at home. Boone said LeMahieu is asymptomatic while Cessa has shown mild...
Ghislaine Maxwell could be back in New York in days, report says
Ghislaine Maxwell could be back in New York as soon as Sunday — but not to the same jail where doomed pedophile Jeffrey Epstein died, according to a report. Instead, Maxwell — nabbed Thursday at a secluded New Hampshire estate after months on the run from child sex abuse charges — is expected to be...
Drive-in movie theaters making a comeback amid coronavirus pandemic
As the coronavirus pandemic forces Americans to social distance, an old trend is making a welcome comeback. Drive-in movie theaters allow people to get out of the house while maintaining social distance and keeping safe. Mireya Villarreal reports.
1 h
Angels pitcher Julio Teheran missing from camp for second day in row
Angels right-hander Julio Teheran was absent from team workouts again Saturday, and manager Joe Maddon did not disclose the reason.
1 h
Seat back safety standards in U.S. cars under intense scrutiny
About one child dies every week in the U.S. due to unsafe car seat backs, the safety standards for which have not been updated since the 1960s. Now, lawmakers are pushing to have the standards updated within two years. Kris Van Cleave reports.
1 h
Texas sees highest number of coronavirus cases recorded since start of pandemic
Texas on Saturday reported its largest daily rise in confirmed coronavirus cases since the start of the pandemic -- 8,258 -- following a facial mask mandate from Gov. Greg Abbott in an effort to slow the uptick in cases.
1 h
Epstein's alleged accomplice pictured posing on British throne with Kevin Spacey
The British royal family has been dragged once again into the Jeffrey Epstein scandal as a photograph emerged showing the late financier's alleged accomplice posing on a throne at Buckingham Palace.
1 h
Epstein's alleged accomplice pictured posing on British throne with Kevin Spacey
The British royal family has been dragged once again into the Jeffrey Epstein scandal as a photograph emerged showing the late financier's alleged accomplice posing on a throne at Buckingham Palace.
1 h
Heat wave impacting 200 million Americans
About 200 million Americans are experiencing unusually high temperatures over the July 4 weekend. By mid-week, several cities may experience temperatures that feel like they are near or in the triple digits.
1 h
England reopens pubs and other businesses as infection rates drop
Britain is slowly reopening businesses as coronavirus infection rates drop. But many are resuming with extra caution and improved safety measures to prevent further lockdowns. Roxana Saberi reports.
1 h
Americans adjust to muted July 4 celebrations amid coronavirus pandemic
The Fourth of July weekend is typically a boisterous celebration with firework displays and crowded beaches. But the coronavirus pandemic is putting a limit to those traditions, and in some places canceling them entirely. Michael George reports.
1 h
President Trump holds July 4 celebration at White House
President Trump held a Fourth of July celebration on the White House South Lawn one day after attending an event at Mt. Rushmore. This year's celebration is a massive scale back from last year's event, which featured military vehicles and flyovers. Nikole Killion reports.
1 h
"CBS Weekend News" headlines for Saturday, July 4, 2020
Here's a look at the top stories making headlines on the "CBS Weekend News" anchored by Major Garrett.
1 h
Coronavirus cases continue to spike nationwide amid Fourth of July weekend
Fourth of July weekend will have an unusually somber tone this year as the coronavirus pandemic rages on. Cases are increasing in 40 states, many of which have had to pause their reopening plans. Lilia Luciano reports.
1 h
Swiss zookeeper killed by Siberian tiger inside enclosure
A Swiss zookeeper was killed Saturday after she was attacked by a Siberian tiger in front of horrified visitors at the Zurich zoo. The onlookers raised an alarm after watching the tiger, named Irina, attack the 55-year-old keeper, according to The Associated Press. Other zoo workers rushed to the woman’s aid and lured the tiger...
1 h
Catching up with legendary Mets broadcaster Howie Rose
Longtime radio sports announcer Howie Rose, who is the current Mets play-by-play man for WCBS 880-AM, makes the call to do some Q&A with Post columnist Steve Serby. Q: What are your thoughts on the 60-game MLB season? A: It will be with the most trepidation I’ve ever approached an Opening Day, to be sure....
1 h
First LAPD officer dies of COVID-19
Another 287 LAPD employees are currently quarantined at home after having been exposed to the novel coronavirus.
1 h
How Ghislaine Maxwell once sat on Buckingham Palace thrones with Kevin Spacey
In a newly surfaced 2002 photo, the just-captured accused Jeffrey Epstein madam sits on Queen Elizabeth II’s throne during a private Buckingham Palace tour — with actor Kevin Spacey at her side.
1 h
UFC, MMA notables celebrate 4th of July on social media
UFC and MMA fighters' patriotism was in full force in a variety of ways for Independence Day in the U.S.        Related StoriesGilbert Burns comments on 'devastating' removal from UFC 251 after positive COVID-19 testTony Ferguson to Khabib after father's death: 'He will be front row' when we hopefully fightGilbert Burns tests positive for COVID-19, out of UFC 251 headliner vs. Kamaru Usman 
1 h
Stream It Or Skip It: ‘Midway’ on HBO, Roland Emmerich’s CG-Explosion Homage to a Handful of World War II Heroes
A litany of stars -- Josh Lucas, Dennis Quaid, Woody Harrelson -- play generically rendered war heroes.
1 h
Protests stop Brooklyn-bound traffic on the Brooklyn Bridge in New York
A protest march on Saturday has led to the closing of all Brooklyn-bound lanes on New York City's Brooklyn Bridge, officials say.
1 h
President Donald Trump hosts Independence Day celebration at White House
President Trump and First Lady Melania Trump welcomed visitors to the White House's South Lawn to celebrate the Fourth of July.       
1 h
9/11 Memorial reopens after closing amid COVID-19 outbreak
The iconic 9/11 Memorial opened to family members of victims, first responders and frontline workers Saturday after being closed for nearly three months because of COVID-19. The Memorial, which will now require masks and social distancing for visitors and employees, opens to the general public July 5, ending the temporary closure since early March. The...
1 h
"Not your typical Fourth of July": Americans celebrate amid pandemic
Communities across the country are canceling or dialing back traditional fireworks.
1 h
Yankees players outraged after terrifying Masahiro Tanaka video goes viral
Some Yankees players were upset with video being circulated of Masahiro Tanaka on the ground after being drilled in the head by a Giancarlo Stanton line drive during Saturday’s simulated game at Yankee Stadium. Aaron Judge could be seen and heard yelling at someone in the stadium about shooting video and later took to Twitter...
2 h
Watch Live: President Trump Delivers Independence Day Speech
Watch President Donald Trump's speech at "Salute to America" live on Saturday, the Fourth of July, in Washington, DC, at 6:40 p.m. EST.
2 h
Woman who went on anti-Asian tirades facing arrest on separate battery charge
A woman, whose racist, anti-Asian tirades last month shocked the public and the city of Torrance, has a warrant out for her arrest in connection to a confrontation separate from those recently captured on cellphone videos at a park.
2 h
Biden Offers Optimistic July 4th Message in Sharp Contrast to Trump’s Divisiveness
While the president tried to fan the flames of a culture war at Mount Rushmore, Biden said the country faces a historic opportunity for progress.
2 h
Analyst: You can sue the goverment, but chance of success is slim
CNN legal analyst Elie Honig joins Ana Cabrera to answer viewer questions about the rights of private citizens as governors implement stronger restrictions as the coronavirus pandemic rages on.
2 h
The questions that still need answering about Jeffrey Epstein’s death
Even before prosecutors announced they were likely shipping Ghislaine Maxwell to the the scandal-plagued New York lock up where Jeffrey Epstein died, alarm bells were pealing over her safety.
2 h
Trump Signs Small Business Loan Program Extension
The Paycheck Protection Program, enacted to help small businesses dealing with the coronavirus pandemic, had expired Tuesday. With Trump's signature Saturday, the new deadline to apply is Aug. 8.
2 h
Opinion: A handful of people at IMS watch Scott Dixon dominate GMR Grand Prix
Scott Dixon won the 2020 GMR Grand Prix at empty Indianapolis Motor Speedway, using tire strategy to bend the field to his will.       
2 h
2 officers accused of repeatedly using stun gun against man charged with his murder
Jared Lakey, 28, died two days after he was repeatedly shot with a stun gun by the officers.
2 h
Passenger removed from Spirit Airlines flight for refusing to wear a mask
Footage on social media shows a passenger being confronted by Port Authority officers for failing to comply and wear a mask during the flight.       
2 h
Mets will open 2020 MLB season at home against the Braves
The Mets’ 2020 season is set to begin just as the last one ended — with a home game against the Braves. MLB is expected to release the official schedule this week, with the Braves at Citi Field on July 24 to kick off the Mets’ season, The Post has learned. The NL East rivals...
2 h
Stream It Or Skip It: ‘Los Futbolisimos’ on HBO, a Spanish Kiddie-Sports Comedy That’s a Real Kick in the Head
It's a Spanish, soccer version of the Bad News Mighty Bearducks.
2 h
A rare case of brain-destroying amoeba has been confirmed in Florida
A case of a rare, brain-destroying amoeba has been confirmed in Florida.
2 h
Biden Urges America to 'Rip Out' Systemic Racism in July 4th Message
Former Vice President Joe Biden urged Americans to commit to ripping "out the roots of systemic racism" on Saturday when delivering his Fourth of July message to the nation. 
2 h
Florida inmates will comfort dogs frightened by Fourth of July fireworks
For most people, the Fourth of July means cookouts, sunny afternoons by the pool, and evenings full of fireworks.
2 h
Trump wants to give Americans 'a worthy show' for Independence Day in 'Salute to America'
President Trump, who has railed against the "cancel culture," refused to let the coronavirus pandemic close down a grand Fourth of July celebration in Washington, despite objections from local officials over rising infection rates.
2 h
Trump has revealed his 2020 campaign strategy
There's a reason Trump is focusing on the controversy surrounding monuments, writes Julian Zelizer. It's his latest effort to use the culture wars to overcome the huge gap that exists between his economic policies and the bread-and-butter needs of middle-class Americans.
2 h