Tools
Change country:

Perfectly Good COVID-19 Tests Are Going Unused

For months, public-health experts have been calling for a new line of defense against COVID-19. Antigen testing, also known as rapid testing, is cheaper and faster than standard testing, and it can happen at points of care—long-term-care facilities, prisons, schools, and doctors’ offices. The technology has been around since the spring, but the real investment came in August, when the federal government ordered 150 million Abbott BinaxNOW tests, which show the result on a card in just 15 minutes. At the time, the federal government hoped to use the tests to pinpoint outbreaks in long-term-care facilities and protect the elderly, while states looked to deploy them in schools and universities to get students back in the classroom. Faster, more frequent testing in these places could help mitigate the pandemic’s worst effects.

But the process of distributing those tests, and then reporting their results, has been slow and uneven. The results from most of the antigen tests that have been sent to states have been unreported, according to separate data from the COVID Tracking Project at The Atlantic and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, leaving gaps in our knowledge of the pandemic. In some cases, the tests are not getting used at all. Almost a year into this crisis, the U.S. still does not have a clear picture of how many people are being tested for COVID-19.

The value of antigen tests is based on a simple tradeoff. They’re not as sensitive as polymerase chain reaction (PCR) tests, which are the gold standard for diagnosing COVID-19, but they’re most effective when people with the virus are most infectious. And since they’re cheaper, faster, and easier to perform, the ability to do more tests can balance out the lower sensitivity. If their convenience means you take eight antigen tests a month, versus, say, two PCR tests a month, the antigen regime might catch cases that the PCR regime misses. One recent analysis suggests that using antigen tests on a population three days a week would be virtually as effective in catching infections as using the superior PCR test the same number of times.

But for an effective antigen-testing plan to work, the tests have to be given frequently and the results quickly reported. While PCR tests are done at labs, which are practiced in reporting results to health agencies, antigen tests are intended for places such as schools and nursing homes, which have to develop their own reporting systems. And that’s been a problem since the tests started going out in May. By August, the test manufacturers Quidel and BD combined to produce 3 million antigen tests a week. But by mid-September, states had reported only 215,000 antigen-test results. There was, as The Atlantic’s Alexis Madrigal and Robinson Meyer wrote then, “a hole where data about antigen testing should be.” At the time, only six states made antigen-testing numbers available (now 20 states do), and extrapolating those results suggested that only 1.4 million antigen tests had been conducted nationwide.

[Read: The plan that could give us our lives back]

The federal government pressed on with antigen testing, though, and ordered 150 million tests from Abbott when the company’s more advanced technology came online. In October, the Associated Press reported that while about half of the country’s testing capacity consisted of antigen tests, the overall reported test numbers didn’t reflect the flood of antigen tests that had made their way to states. In November, The New York Times found the same hole in the data, reporting that state and local public-health officials were on the hunt for rapid-testing facilities that were not disclosing their data.

And that hole doesn’t seem to have gone anywhere. On December 14, during a biweekly CDC call with laboratory representatives to address their issues in dealing with COVID-19, the Department of Health and Human Services said that a majority of the more than 50 million antigen tests that have been distributed to states “do not have test results flowing to HHS.” According to the CDC data, that number is now up to 94.4 million. Data collected by the COVID Tracking Project similarly suggest that states are not reporting antigen-test results. Out of more than 235 million test results reported since June, only about 9 million are clearly reported as antigen-test results. Admittedly, many states still don’t split out separate figures for antigen tests and PCR tests. But even among the states that do, antigen tests make up only about 10 percent of all tests they have reported. Extrapolated nationwide, that would be about 27 million tests, or a bit more than a quarter of the tests the federal government has distributed to date.

Collecting antigen-test results has been a struggle, says Richard Danila, the deputy state epidemiologist in Minnesota, which does report antigen tests separately. The state needed four people working full time for three weeks to set up a reporting system with its 300 nursing homes after they received the antigen tests—not just getting results from frequent testing, but ensuring that those results are always connected to the patient’s name and demographic information. In the best-case scenario, the department helped them create flat electronic files like Excel sheets, but some of the data came in as faxes or emails. “We certainly don’t have, probably, full reporting of the Abbott BinaxNOW positive tests,” Danila says. “You’re relying on the good nature of people that remember to report to us.” All in all, Minnesota has reported nearly 273,000 antigen tests during the pandemic, compared with nearly 5.7 million PCR tests. (Some of this gap, Danila says, is due to Minnesota’s investment in a saliva-based PCR test, making the state less dependent on antigen tests.)

If tests are being given but not reported, that doesn’t mean they’re completely useless; people and individual institutions can obviously take action based on the results. But it means that crucial information isn’t available to health officials. “This lack of visibility can lead to a lot of challenges, especially as the administrators are trying to conduct contact tracing or decide where to distribute additional testing supplies, and identify hot spots,” Kristen Honey, a senior adviser to the assistant secretary of HHS, said on the CDC call.

Perhaps more worryingly, officials on the same call said that in some cases, the antigen tests the government ordered are not being used at all. Marcus Plescia of the Association of State and Territorial Health Officials described a nationwide survey his organization had conducted in November about the use of Abbott’s BinaxNOW rapid tests. One of the highest priorities for these tests was using them in schools, to catch infections early and help keep facilities open. But “use in K–12 has not been substantial so far,” Plescia said. An antigen-testing program’s logistics can be daunting, and as an article in The New England Journal of Medicine put it, schools have received “strikingly little substantive guidance on testing” from federal and state officials. When ASTHO did its November survey, 60 percent of respondents were still in the planning stage. That may be changing: Massachusetts, for example, had been using rapid antigen testing for symptomatic students and staff in 134 of its 403 school districts since November, but is now rolling out pooled testing across the state for all students and staff, regardless of symptoms, which will greatly boost the number of tests being used. Other school systems, such as Chicago Public Schools and New Orleans Public Schools, had instituted remote learning, but are going back to in-person education with antigen-testing plans.

New technologies may ease and speed antigen-test reporting, filling in the data hole that’s been lingering for months. At-home tests that don’t require a prescription are going on sale this month, and the kit includes a device that transmits the results via Bluetooth to an app on the user’s phone. And the CDC recently launched a new interface, SimpleReport, to make it easier for institutions such as K–12 schools and universities to submit testing results. But these systems still require people and institutions to take the tests and choose to report their results. Better tests alone won’t solve that problem.


Load more
Read full article on: theatlantic.com
Emanuel Jackson, Capitol Rioter Who Beat Police With Baseball Bat, Turns Himself In
Emanuel Jackson handed himself in to police after images and video of him in Washington, D.C. were shared by authorities.
8 m
newsweek.com
Uganda accuses US of trying to 'subvert elections' after ambassador blocked from visiting Wine's home: report
Uganda accused the U.S. of meddling in "internal politics" on Tuesday after security personnel blocked the U.S. ambassador from visiting musician turned opposition leader Bobi Wine at his home this week, according to a report. 
foxnews.com
Paris Fashion Week: Highlights from the latest menswear shows
All the highlights from Paris Fashion Week's virtual menswear event.
edition.cnn.com
Barr ‘not surprised’ to see violence at Capitol, says it cannot be tolerated
William Barr, the former U.S. attorney general, said in an interview that aired Monday that he was not surprised to see “the kind of violence” that occurred at the Capitol earlier this month, and said questions about the election “precipitated the riots.”
foxnews.com
CNN correspondents on Biden's foreign policy challenges
CNN's international correspondents unpack the foreign policy challenges President-elect Joe Biden will face in the White House.
edition.cnn.com
Teen dies after being hit by as many as three cars, police say
13-year-old pedestrian killed on road in Washington suburb, according to police.
washingtonpost.com
A man was ‘scared to go home due to covid.’ So he spent three months living in Chicago airport, prosecutors say
Aditya Singh survived in part on food given to him by other passengers, grew out his beard, lectured travelers about Buddhism and Hinduism, and attempted to evade scrutiny by wearing an airport worker’s identification badge.
washingtonpost.com
A man was ‘scared to go home due to covid.’ So he spent three months living in Chicago airport, prosecutors say
Aditya Singh survived in part on food given to him by other passengers, grew out his beard, lectured travelers about Buddhism and Hinduism, and attempted to evade scrutiny by wearing an airport worker’s identification badge.
washingtonpost.com
More than 60% of all US Covid-19 cases were reported since Election Day. Now experts warn a variant could further fuel spread
The US has just surpassed 24 million Covid-19 cases -- and more than 60% of them have been reported since Election Day.
edition.cnn.com
Severe wind event promps fire threat in California
Severe winds gusting 65 to 80 mph will batter California Tuesday, raising the fire danger in the area. Meanwhile, scattered rain showers are expected in parts of the South and lake effect snow continues in the Great Lakes region.
edition.cnn.com
Final days: How Trump turned on Barr and embraced the ‘crazy’ Powell
President Trump has no lawyer to defend him in an impeachment trial rooted in his aggressive attempts to reverse Biden’s victory.
foxnews.com
Thousands of Californians could lose power as dangerous Santa Ana winds raise fire risk
Residents across nine California counties could be without power Tuesday as officials aim to reduce fire risk from the powerful Santa Ana winds expected to roar through the region.
edition.cnn.com
Why Putin wants to keep Navalny locked up
Alexei Navalny's brave gamble in going back to Russia to take on someone as ruthless as Vladimir Putin appears to have been a miscalculation, writes Michael Bociurkiw. Navalny was arrested when he returned to Moscow five month after being poisoned with a nerve agent. "The question now is whether Navalny's anti-corruption movement can survive with its incredibly telegenic and social media savvy leader isolated from the frontlines."
1 h
edition.cnn.com
Biden's homeland security pick would inherit major challenges
If confirmed by the Senate, Alejandro Mayorkas, the son of Cuban refugees, would lead a department facing a host of serious issues, both inside and outside the U.S.
1 h
cbsnews.com
UFC on ESPN 20 video: Michael Chiesa, Neil Magny burst into laughter during final faceoff
UFC on ESPN 20 headliners Michael Chiesa and Neil Magny had one final staredown before sharing the octagon on Wednesday.        Related StoriesUFC on ESPN 20 video: Michael Chiesa, Neil Magny burst into laughter during final faceoff - EnclosureUFC on ESPN 20 video: Michael Chiesa, Neil Magny on weight for main event - EnclosureUFC on ESPN 20 video: Michael Chiesa, Neil Magny on weight for main event 
1 h
usatoday.com
At least 4 wounded during string of ‘connected’ shootings in the Poconos
At least four people were wounded in a series of shootings that are believed to be connected in an area north of Mount Pocono on Monday night, police said. The gun violence began at about 5 p.m. in Tobyhanna, prompting a shelter-in-place order as cops searched for the suspects early Tuesday morning, according to police....
1 h
nypost.com
FBI searches home of Huntington Beach far-right extremist who posted about attending the Capitol riot
The FBI searched the Huntington Beach apartment of a far-right extremist who previously claimed to have attended the Capitol riot.
2 h
latimes.com
Mets general manager Jared Porter sent reporter unsolicited photos
Mets general manager Jared Porter’s standing with the team could be on shaky ground following a report late Monday night indicating he sent unsolicited texts and images to a female reporter in 2016.
2 h
foxnews.com
24-year-old Ohio cop fatally shot during hours-long standoff with armed suspect
A Toledo police officer was fatally shot on Monday during a standoff with an armed suspect wanted for vandalizing a cathedral, authorities said. Officer Brandon Stalker, 24, who was performing perimeter security at the suspect’s home, was struck once after the man walked outside and opened fire with two guns, police said. “He was an...
2 h
nypost.com
Los Angeles lifts air-quality limits for cremations amid a backlog of bodies caused by COVID-19
A California air quality agency has temporarily suspended limits on how many bodies can be cremated amid a lack of storage space for those who died from the novel coronavirus.
2 h
foxnews.com
China is hitting back at criticism of its vaccines with a dangerous disinformation campaign
With Chinese company Sinovac facing questions over the efficacy of its coronavirus shot, the country's propaganda apparatus is attacking other vaccines, undermining overall confidence in mass inoculations.
2 h
edition.cnn.com
Opinion: New York Mets must part ways with GM Jared Porter in wake of damning report
Jared Porter's behavior, as detailed in a startling and sickening ESPN report, should cost him his job as general manager of the New York Mets.       
2 h
usatoday.com
Tommy Hilfiger sells his $45M mansion, reportedly moving to Florida
Fashion icon Tommy Hilfiger has finally sold his massive Connecticut mansion for $45 million and will be moving more than 1,250 miles down south.
2 h
foxnews.com
UFC on ESPN 20 video: Michael Chiesa, Neil Magny on weight for main event
The UFC’s second main event of the year between Michael Chiesa and Neil Magny is official.        Related StoriesDana White: Neil Magny, Michael Chiesa deserve UFC on ESPN 20 main event spotUFC on ESPN 20 weigh-in results and live video stream (midnight ET)UFC on ESPN 20's Warlley Alves vows to reach potential, become champion 
2 h
usatoday.com
Mets must fire Jared Porter amid sexting scandal: Sherman
If Carlos Beltran had to go for sign stealing last offseason, then Jared Porter has to go now if the facts in ESPN’s story are true and the new Mets GM in 2016 sent a barrage of unsolicited text messages with lewd overtones to a female reporter. Beltran committed a baseball crime and never made...
2 h
nypost.com
Deshaun Watson is fueling Jets trade buzz — all thanks to The Post
Deshaun Watson may have given the first indication he’s interested in coming to the Jets. The Texans star’s official Instagram account liked a picture of The Post’s back page from Monday that said that Jets should do “Whatever It Takes” to acquire the disgruntled quarterback. The picture was posted by Yonkers entrepreneur Wayne Schneider. Watson,...
2 h
nypost.com
Lakers manage to show some of their championship mettle in loss to Warriors
The pair of LeBron James and Anthony Davis make the Lakers special, but they run into some problems in a 115-113 loss to the Golden State Warriors.
3 h
latimes.com
Amid virus surge, hospital chaplains on front line
As families are barred from visiting loved ones in hospitals to curb the spread of COVID-19, chaplains often are there to act as surrogates, holding the hands of the dying, praying with them and providing a connection with grieving loved ones. (Jan. 19)       
3 h
usatoday.com
Ohio police chief mourns an 'amazing police officer' who was killed during standoff
An Ohio police officer was shot dead Monday after a suspect, facing an arrest warrant, emerged from a standoff with police and started shooting, officials said.
3 h
edition.cnn.com
What to watch on Tuesday: ‘Frontline: President Biden’ on PBS
Tuesday January 19, 2021 | “Finding Your Roots” returns on PBS.
3 h
washingtonpost.com
Nets got sweet glimpse of a new James Harden
This was the sequence that defines James Harden, the good and the bad, the beautiful and the brazen and everything in between. Here, in the space of five seconds, maybe six, was enough for his detractors to jump on, enough for his supporters to fall behind, both sides able to state their cases in a...
3 h
nypost.com
Harry Brant, son of billionaire Peter Brant and supermodel Stephanie Seymour, dead at 24
Harry Brant — the flamboyant fashionista son of polo-playing billionaire Peter Brant and supermodel Stephanie Seymour — has died of an accidental drug overdose, his family said on Monday. He was 24. The gender-bending bon vivant — a hip couture icon along with his older brother Peter Jr. — was found dead on Sunday, just...
3 h
nypost.com
Clinton suggests Putin may have known about riot in Capitol, Pelosi wants 9/11 commission-type probe
Hillary Clinton, the former secretary of state, spoke with House Speaker Nancy Pelosi on her podcast about the riot at the U.S. Capitol earlier this month and hinted that Russian President Vladimir Putin may have been receiving updates about the chaos from President Trump. 
3 h
foxnews.com
‘Colbert’s’ Laura Benanti Delivers One Last Epic Musical ‘Fuck Off’ to Melania Trump
CBS“We’re planning sort of a great big goodbye to her that I’m really, really excited about,” Laura Benanti told me last month when I asked her if she was finally finished playing First Lady Melania Trump on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert. “It’s going to be pretty, pretty spectacular.”On Monday night, with about 36 hours to go until Joe Biden is sworn in as the 46th president of the United States, she delivered on that promise.What started as a standard farewell message about how “all good things must come to an end”—and “also this,” she added—Benanti’s Melania put her Tony Award-winning skills to work in an elaborate short film about moving back to New York for good after four long years of suffering in D.C.Read more at The Daily Beast.
3 h
thedailybeast.com
Mets GM Jared Porter acknowledges 'serious error in judgement' following report he sent unsolicited messages, lewd photos to reporter
The New York Mets are aware of an ESPN report that said GM Jared Porter sent unsolicited messages and lewd photos to a female reporter in 2016.       
3 h
usatoday.com
Joe Biden: Amnesty for Everyone Who Was Here on January 1
President-elect Joe Biden's amnesty plan will reportedly provide the glittering prize of U.S. citizenship to everyone who can show they were in the United States illegally on January 1, if Congress passes the wage-cutting, nation-changing legislation amid a deep economic recession.
3 h
breitbart.com
GOP Rep. Carl: Atmosphere Surrounding U.S. Capitol on Eve of Inauguration 'Creepy'
With a matter of hours to go until President-elect Joe Biden is sworn in as the 46th president of the United States, Washington, D.C., including the National Mall and the U.S. Capitol, remain on lockdown after riots broke out inside the Capitol earlier this month. The lockdown atmosphere has a "creepy" vibe to it, according to freshman Rep. Jerry Carl (R-AL).
3 h
breitbart.com
Jimmy Kimmel Furious Over Ted Cruz’s Capitol Riot Complicity
ABCOn Monday night, Jimmy Kimmel began his late-night monologue by honoring Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., a civil rights icon who was viciously targeted by the U.S. federal government and whose revolutionary thinking has been softened by U.S. history classes for decades.“Thank you for joining us on the day we honor the life and legacy of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., a real patriot, great man who lost his life to the same sick mentality that permeates this country to this day,” said Kimmel. “If Dr. King were alive today, he would probably watch the news and go, ‘Let me be more specific about this dream I had.’”The comic then turned to The New Yorker’s shocking footage from inside the U.S. Capitol riot. Read more at The Daily Beast.
4 h
thedailybeast.com
Country that refused to lock down learns a hard lesson
What's now mundane for much of the world is remarkable for Sweden: government-issued mandates on limited store capacity. Once lionized by anti-lockdown advocates, Sweden now has a new law granting the government power to do things the country previously refused to do. CNN's Max Foster reports. 
4 h
edition.cnn.com
Opinion: Carli Lloyd keeps on grinding after injury because that's what Carli Lloyd does
Carli Lloyd had not played in a USWNT game since March after injuring her knee, but looked as strong as ever.       
4 h
usatoday.com
Ohio police officer shot and killed following hours long standoff
Officer Brandon Stalker was just 24 years old.
4 h
abcnews.go.com
Trump is handing Biden a more dangerous world. There's only so much the new president can undo
As US President Donald Trump he hands power to Joe Biden on Wednesday -- however reluctantly -- he also hands his successor a far more dangerous world than it was four years ago.
4 h
edition.cnn.com
Trump is handing Biden a more dangerous world. There's only so much the new president can undo
The recent attack on the US Capitol served as a sobering wake-up call: Not only have the Trump years left America deeply divided, they've also transformed it into a theater of political violence.
4 h
edition.cnn.com
Live Updates: Eric Swalwell brings political baggage as impeachment manager
Swalwell was given the heavy responsibility of being on the team to present the case against Trump to the Senate in his impeachment trial
4 h
foxnews.com
Live Updates: Acting Secretary of Defense weighs in on concerns of insider threat to Biden's inauguration
Miller said that the department is "leaving no stone unturned in securing the Capitol."
4 h
foxnews.com
Live Updates: Congress gears up as hearings for Biden's Cabinet nominations set to begin today
The first hearings for President-elect Joe Biden's Cabinet nominations are set to begin on Tuesday, one day before his inauguration on Jan. 20.
4 h
foxnews.com
How fast do you cancel streaming services? It's a problem for Hollywood
A new report suggests more than 60% of people who dropped a streaming service did so after they watched the show or movie that got them to sign up.
4 h
latimes.com
Trump leaves America at its most divided since the Civil War
Donald Trump ends his tumultuous presidency with the nation confronting the greatest strain to its fundamental cohesion since the Civil War.
4 h
edition.cnn.com