The Supreme Court Is Trump’s Enforcer

The Supreme Court has been battered in the past three years—by the Merrick Garland blockade, Mitch McConnell’s electoral weaponization of the nomination system, and the Brett Kavanaugh debacle; by President Donald Trump’s pointed attacks on “so-called judges,” on the chief justice of the Supreme Court, and on what he calls, in scare quotes, the “independent judiciary.” It would be odd if that process made no change in how the Court sees itself—all institutions, after all, inevitably evolve over time. Add two new justices who owe their elevation to Trump and the table is set for rapid, unpredictable transformation.

What role does the Court have in the Trump era?

These musings take on new urgency after the Court’s decision Wednesday to allow the administration to implement its new, restrictive rules for amnesty applications at the southern border. That decision was both premature and unnecessary, and it is part of a troubling pattern of deference to Trump’s wishes.

Here’s what I mean. In July, the administration announced new rules that forbid any person crossing the Mexican border to apply for asylum in the United States—unless they have formally requested, and been denied, asylum in Mexico first. Obviously, this rule does not apply to Mexican nationals seeking protection from their own government; but everyone else—Central Americans or refugees from elsewhere in the world—must first apply in Mexico and await a decision. This will have an immediate and sharp impact on asylum applicants who arrive at the border and find the rules have changed since they set out.

Such a rule might or might not be a good idea; but it seems to conflict with the Immigration and Nationality Act, which provides that “any alien who is physically present in the United States or who arrives in the United States … may apply for asylum,” and makes an exception only for “aliens … firmly resettled in”—not just passing through—“another country” before arrival. Federal District Judge Jon S. Tigar enjoined the policy across the country, concluding that it probably violated the statute, that the Department of Homeland Security had probably violated required procedures in adopting it, and that the decision to impose it flew squarely in the face of the record evidence and thus was probably “arbitrary and capricious.” This was only interim relief; Tigar set the case for trial. The Ninth Circuit then reviewed his nationwide injunction and modified it, meaning Tigar’s order would apply only to border areas in the Ninth Circuit—California and Nevada.

The appellate court then—as is routine—sent the case back to Tigar’s court for gathering of evidence. After another hearing, Tigar concluded that the immigrant-aid organizations who are plaintiffs had demonstrated they would suffer immediate injury if the policy were not stayed across the entire border. On September 9, he reinstated the nationwide injunction.

The government then did something that until recently was unusual: It immediately asked the Supreme Court to lift the injunction before the Ninth Circuit could hear a new appeal.

The Court granted that request last week, allowing the new policy to go into effect everywhere. While the appeal winds its way up, asylum seekers will be barred if they have passed through Mexico. And the Court has given a broad hint about how it will decide the issue when it comes up again. Until recently, such “emergency” action—proceedings in which the Supreme Court reaches down to abort or alter ongoing litigation—was pretty unusual. Now, Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote in a dissent to the asylum order, “it appears as if the mechanism is a new normal. Historically, the Government has made this kind of request rarely; now it does so reflexively.”

To buttress her point, Sotomayor cited a new study by the University of Texas law professor Stephen Vladeck called “The Solicitor General and the Shadow Docket,” which will be published in the Harvard Law Review this fall. (A preliminary version is available here.) Vladeck, who is not only an acute Court watcher but a sometime advocate, suggests that the Court’s treatment of the government’s “emergency” motions has changed since Trump became president.

These motions take three forms: Applications for an “emergency stay” of a lower court’s order, bypassing the normal appeals process; petitions for “cert. before judgment,” which bypass the lower courts and move the case directly to the high court’s docket; and petitions for a “writ of mandamus,” which would order a lower court to do something it has refused to do. Vladeck went through the past two decades of order lists; his findings are striking.

Under George W. Bush, the government in eight years asked for stays only five times; for “cert. before judgment” once; for mandamus, not at all. Under Barack Obama, the government in eight years petitioned for stays three times; “cert. before judgment” three times; and mandamus not at all. Under Trump, in less than three years, the government has asked for stays 21 times; “cert. before judgment” nine times; and mandamus three times.

The Trump administration seems to regard “extraordinary relief” from the high court as nothing more than its due. While the Court has not granted relief each time it has been sought, the government has gotten much of what it wants in high-profile cases such as the “travel ban,” the transgender military service ban, and the asylum rule. And, as Vladeck pointed out, until last week no one on the Court had even suggested that the government was abusing these procedures.

Sotomayor’s dissent breaks the silence. But the majority, and in particular Chief Justice John Roberts, have stayed mum, suggesting to Vladeck that the Court has shifted its view of emergency motions. “That silence,” Vladeck told me in an interview, “is certainly resonating in the Solicitor General’s office”—meaning that the government may now feel secure in asking the high court to rein in judges below.

One common response to Vladeck’s statistics is that the Court’s aggressiveness has been spurred by an increase in so-called nationwide injunctions issued by district judges. “That’s way too easy,” Vladeck said. Although there has been an increase in such injunctions (it began in the Obama years), many emergency stays have been issued in cases where no nationwide injunction is at stake, or in more or less routine disputes over “discovery,” the information the government must provide when it is sued. To Vladeck, the real change is that the new conservative majority is willing to in essence decide the cases before they are briefed or argued—to predict that the government will win when the case finally reaches them, and thus should have its way in the interim.

In the article, Vladeck points out that one of the factors a court must decide is whether either party will suffer “irreparable injury”—either because an injunction is granted, harming the defendants, or denied, harming the plaintiffs. Thus, in a suit against the government, courts must balance the damage to the government caused by the delay of a possibly lawful policy against the harm to plaintiffs caused by being subjected to a possibly unlawful action. Under Trump, the government seems to be suffering all the harm. Vladeck argued that the Court should explain this shift. “If what’s going on in these cases is that the majority is no longer interested in considering the harm that these policies are—or could be—inflicting while they are in force, it would behoove them to say so,” he told me.

The government’s use of these procedures smacks of entitlement, of a sense that Republicans went to great trouble to tilt the Court in their favor and should now reap their reward. Similarly, some conservatives have muttered that lower courts are wandering out of their lanes, with one Trump defender attacking anti-administration rulings as “the judicial resistance.” Indeed, in a surly dissent in the census case last June, Justice Clarence Thomas branded District Judge Jesse Furman, who had ruled against the government at trial, “a judge predisposed to distrust” the administration. Thomas also claimed Furman had “create[d] an eye-catching conspiracy web” out of unrelated facts. As judicial conduct used to be measured, it was a shocking breach of protocol. Yet Thomas’s opinion was joined by Trump’s two appointees, Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh.

Which brings us back to my initial question. What is the Supreme Court today, in 2019? I fear it has taken on the role of enforcing Trump’s will against fellow judges.

Load more
Go to source
unread news
unread news (Demo user)
Tensions are High, Extremists are Expected to Attend. Here’s What to Know About the Pro-Gun Rally in Richmond, Virginia
Officials in Richmond are taking extra security precautions after threats of violence by extremists who plan to attend the pro-gun rally.
7 m
Knicks’ RJ Barrett likely will miss at least a week with ankle injury
RJ Barrett couldn’t recall the last time he missed a game because of injury, but the Knicks rookie guard will miss at least a week with a sprained ankle he suffered Thursday night against the Suns. The Knicks said their first-round draft pick will be reevaluated next Friday, but Barrett certainly will sit out Saturday’s...
Americans are saving up to $23,000 by refinancing
91-year-old LI woman at center of life support battle has died
The 91-year-old Long Island woman whose sons were locked in a heartbreaking court battle over whether to take her off life support died Thursday night, a court official told The Post. “She passed away last night,” Nassau Courts spokesman Dan Bagnuola said Friday of former school teacher Arline Lester. He declined to give further details, citing...
Lev Parnas: Trump would've traded an endorsement for political dirt from Ukraine's ex-president Poroshenko
President Donald Trump's efforts to pressure the Ukrainian government included an attempted quid-pro-quo with then-Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko, according to Lev Parnas, the indicted businessman who is a central figure in the impeachment scandal.
Elizabeth Warren’s evasions and other commentary
Eye on 2020: Warren’s Evasions The New York Times editorial board’s interview last month with Elizabeth Warren leaves the reader with one “nagging conclusion,” quips Commentary’s Noah Rothman: “She doesn’t think you’re very bright.” Among many examples: She snapped at Times editors for asking how she’d get her plans through Congress, asking if they “want...
Kings' Stadium Series jerseys honor aviation industry
When the Kings play the Avalanche in an outdoor game in Colorado Springs, Colo., on Feb. 15, their jerseys will pay homage to the city's strong ties to aviation industry.
Neo-Nazis Allegedly Discussed Opening Fire at Virginia’s Pro-Gun Rally Slated for Monday
Three more members of the same group were arrested Wednesday for an alleged murder plot.
Diaper thief threatened worker with syringe in Bronx robbery
Cops are hunting for a masked man who stole four bags of diapers from a Bronx Rite Aid — and threatened a worker with a syringe when he got caught, police said. The man, who’s approximately 22 years old and has a tattoo above his right eye, was inside the Grand Concourse store on Jan....
Fast-moving storm delays travelers across the country
The storm is on the move Friday evening, causing whiteouts and spinouts on icy highways throughout the Midwest.
China's new SARS-like virus is spreading
A new virus found in Wuhan, China, has killed a small number of people in the country. The virus has also been detected in Japan and Thailand.
Son's graduation was one man's dying wish
If you had one dying wish, what would it be? On tonight’s “On The Road,” we met a man who knew exactly what he wanted. Steve Hartman reports.
Rapper T.I.’s son King filmed fighting during bathroom brawl
An edited 8-second clip shows the aspiring rapper trading punches with another boy.
Juan Williams: Barr is targeting Comey, has become a 'thuggish attorney general'
"The Five" co-host Juan Williams called Attorney General William Barr "thuggish" Friday and accused him and the Trump administration of targeting former FBI director James Comey in the wake of a report that Comey is being investigated for allegedly leaking information while heading the FBI.
UFC 246: ‘More centered’ Conor McGregor set for intense return bout
LAS VEGAS — “Just For the Fight of It.” That should be the moniker that describes UFC 246 Saturday night at T-Mobile Arena, where Conor McGregor will make his return from a 15-month layoff against fan-favorite Donald “Cowboy” Cerrone. The much-anticipated welterweight bout, which will be streamed on ESPN Plus PPV, has been free of...
Trump gets a Ukraine probe, just not the one he asked for
Ukraine's criminal probe into alleged surveillance against former US Ambassador Marie Yovanovitch by people linked to Trump's lawyer Rudy Giuliani, provides a stark counterpoint to Trump's own attempt to coerce Ukraine's president to announce an investigation of his political rival--and what it reveals could deepen the controversy over Trump's actions beyond his impeachment trial, writes Asha Rangappa.
U.S. forces harmed by missiles get treatment
Despite assurances from President Trump that no one was harmed when Iran launched missiles at American forces in Iraq, some service members are being treated for injuries sustained in the attack. Holly Williams reports.
Video: Conor McGregor, Donald Cerrone have final intense faceoff at UFC 246 weigh-ins
All that's left for Conor McGregor and Donald Cerrone is the fighting.       Related StoriesWho ya got?! Fighter predictions for Conor McGregor vs. Donald Cerrone at UFC 246'UFC 246 Embedded,' No. 5: Conor McGregor's business-like approach continuesVideo: Conor McGregor, Donald Cerrone make weight for UFC 246 headliner
Royal Caribbean: Video shows grandfather knew window was open
For the first time, Royal Caribbean Cruise lines is telling its side of the story. They are releasing video of a toddler’s deadly fall last year aboard one its ships. David Begnaud reports.
This Baltimore courthouse is set to be renamed for the late Rep. Elijah Cummings
Just a few months after the passing of Rep. Elijah Cummings, Baltimore is honoring the former lawyer and lawmaker in a fitting way: renaming a courthouse.
Fantasy football: Play 49ers’ Raheem Mostert over Tevin Coleman
Tevin Coleman took the fantasy world by surprise in the divisional round. The 49ers running back 22 carries were more than he had in any game all season. His 105 rushing yards matched his season high. It was just his second multi-touchdown game of the season. Why was this such a surprise? It was the...
Greg Gutfeld: How impeachment is making Trump a better president
Greg Gutfeld said Friday on "The Five" that the impeachment of President Trump may actually be making him a better president.
South Dakota legislators facing backlash over bill criminalizing underage gender treatments
The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and others piled onto the South Dakota legislature as it considered a bill that would make it a felony to provide things like puberty blockers to underage residents.
Suspect wanted in string of bodega robberies in Brooklyn
Cops are on the hunt for a man accused of at least three gunpoint-robberies at Brooklyn bodegas, the NYPD said. The suspect, who’s between 20 and 30 years old, first struck at a deli on Coney Island Avenue on Nov. 16 at about 7:30 p.m., cops said in a news release Thursday. In the hold...
Defense Department To Overhaul Screening For Foreign Military Trainees
Officials said they want to "ensure the program continues." To that end, the department has reviewed "how we can use our resources to do enhanced vetting."
Trump's impeachment defense team announced
President Trump’s impeachment trial is likely to begin next Wednesday. The president will choose high-profile and controversial lawyers to defend him. Ben Tracy reports.
Fox Nation Host Predicts 'Civil War' And 'Major Uprising' If Democrats Continue To Pass Gun Laws
Fox Nation host Tomi Lahren railed against Democratic attempts to pass gun laws in Virginia Thursday, claiming their efforts could lead to "civil war."
Woman arrested for throwing bleach in Manhattan straphanger’s face
The deranged woman who allegedly threw bleach on a woman in an unprovoked attack in a Manhattan subway station this week was arrested Friday, the NYPD said. Lakeesha Tyler, 46, was hit with an assault charge for the attack, police said. Tyler is accused of randomly throwing bleach in the 37-year-old woman’s face while she...
FBI cracks down on white supremacist groups ahead of pro-gun rally
The FBI crackdown continues on white supremacist groups ahead of a pro-gun rally in Virginia. Three more suspected members of a nationwide neo-Nazi group were arrested in Georgia. Jeff Pegues reports.
No, Mr. President, It Does Really Matter
Trump has no clear rationale for killing Iran’s top general, or for much of his foreign policy.
Michael Moore calls for Warren and Sanders to share delegates, unite under one ticket
Filmmaker Michael Moore wants Sens. Elizabeth Warren, D-Mass., and Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., to put aside their differences and join the same ticket in order to beat President Trump in November.
'Make Iran Great Again!': Trump hits back after Khamenei's jibe
The remarks come in apparent response to Khamenei's sermon earlier Friday, where he lambasted the United States for the recent killing of Iranian Gen. Qassem Soleimani.
Dying man surprised by special graduation for his son
His son Blake will still have to finish out his final year of high school. But the milestone has now been marked, and the memory sealed.
Man Convicted of Killing Couple in Car Crash Gets Into Traffic Accident on Way to Sentencing
Sirvonte De Romeo Rice was a passenger in the vehicle. There is no word on the extent of his injuries.
U.S. will screen passengers from China for new illness
There is growing concern about a rare, flu-like virus that has caused at least two deaths and has spread from China to other countries in Asia. Errol Barnett reports.
Trump fires back after Iranian leader condemns him on Twitter: 'Make Iran Great Again!'
President Trump sent a scathing indictment of Iran's leadership on Friday when he told Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Khamenei to stop killing his people and to make his country "great again."
Mega Millions Drawing For 01/17/20: Friday Jackpot is $103 Million
The Mega Millions jackpot for 01/17/20 is $103 million, with a cash option of $69.5 million. The drawing will be held at 11 p.m. ET on Friday.
Millions are under winter weather alerts
At least 125 million people are under winter weather alerts as a powerful winter storm hits the U.S. WCBS Lonnie Quinn is tracking the storm.
3 more men linked to white supremacist group arrested in Georgia
Three more men linked to a white supremacist group were charged with plotting to murder a married Georgia couple who were part of the Antifa movement, authorities said Friday, a day after three other group members were arrested on federal charges in other states.
Fashion brand under fire for cultural appropriation with cornrow wigs
People are wigging out over these wigs. On Friday, Japanese fashion brand Commes des Garçons held a Fall 2020 menswear presentation in Paris — but it wasn’t the looks that rankled people on Twitter. The show featured models in oversized lace-front wigs designed to resemble cornrows, which were primarily worn by white models. Social media...
Avalanche kills skier as winter storm targets the Midwest and Northeast
An avalanche killed one skier and left another severely injured near Lake Tahoe in California. The storm is on the move, causing whiteouts and spinouts on icy highways throughout the Midwest. Adriana Diaz reports.
Trump adds celebrity lawyers — and their baggage — to impeachment defense team
With his impeachment trial now convened, Trump has picked an aggressive team of outside lawyers, including Alan Dershowitz, whose career was tarred by his ties to a pedophile, and Kenneth Starr, whose investigation led to the 1998 impeachment of President Clinton.
Kin of slain NYPD officers rip ‘early’ parole hearings for cop-killers
The families of two slain NYPD officers went before the state parole board Friday to decry what they called early hearings for the cops’ killers. Relatives of 34-year-old Officer Anthony Abruzzo, who was gunned down while off-duty in 1981, and family members of Officer Harry Ryman, 43, who was shot and killed while off-duty in...
Rebel Wilson flaunts amazing weight loss transformation after declaring 2020 her 'year of health'
Rebel Wilson has been working hard on her fitness.
Robert Hyde Claims Adam Schiff 'Likes to... Spy on Americans': 'You're a Scumbag… and the World Knows It!'
Connecticut Republican Robert Hyde also alleged that Lev Parnas planned to have Rudy Giuliani kidnapped in Ukraine in order to blackmail the president.
CNN calls Oscar contender 'Joker' 'controversial' due to 'potentially' inciting violence
CNN has labeled the Oscar-nominated blockbuster "Joker" as "controversial" over past concerns that it could "potentially" incite violence despite the film no longer having a strong presence in theaters.
Scarlett Johansson, Sterling K. Brown among actors to present at 2020 SAG Awards
Scarlett Johansson, Sterling K. Brown and Taika Waititi will be up for Screen Actors Guild Awards and also handing them out at Sunday’s ceremony.
Times Taps White Nationalist Organization for Thought-Provoking Perspective on Immigration
In 1997, one of the group's founders complained that immigrants were ruining the United States by "defecating and creating garbage." Makes you think!