Why Bernie Sanders is right and wrong about female presidential candidates

Sens. Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren embrace after the Democratic presidential debate in July 2019 in Detroit, Michigan. | Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

And why we have to talk about it honestly.

The feud between Sens. Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders — and their supporters — over whether Sanders really questioned if the US would elect a woman president is now in its fourth day.

Before the debate, the Sanders campaign encouraged supporters to go negative on Warren, partly out of fear that she can’t win over “disaffected working-class voters.” Later, CNN reported that Sanders told Warren privately in 2018 that a woman likely couldn’t defeat President Donald Trump in 2020, something Sanders has denied.

During Tuesday’s debate, Sanders was asked by a moderator why he said he “did not believe that a woman could win the election.” “How could anybody in a million years not believe that a woman could become president of the United States?” he responded.

Meanwhile, Warren affirmed her original account of the conversation with Sanders, and after the debate there was an awkward encounter between the two. “I think you called me a liar on national TV,” she told Sanders.

Let’s set aside for the moment whether Sanders said what Warren says he said. The dispute between them touches on an important question that doesn’t admit any easy answers.

Is it true that it would be difficult for a woman to win a presidential election, especially against a misogynist like Trump? If so, what is unique about a presidential race that makes it different from congressional elections — where women candidates triumphed in 2018?

To get some answers, I reached out to Cornell University philosopher Kate Manne, author of Down Girl: The Logic of Misogyny.In a Twitter thread, Manne suggested that Sanders should have owned the implications of his remarks and admitted what we all know is likely true: sexism will be weaponized against a female candidate.

We discussed what she meant by that, and arguably an even more pressing question: How can we acknowledge this reality in a way that doesn’t reinforce it or turn it into a self-fulfilling prophecy?

A lightly edited transcript of our conversation follows.

Sean Illing

Let’s assume Sanders told Warren that a woman can’t defeat Trump in 2020. Is he right?

Kate Manne

I think he is wrong, but it’s not an unreasonable claim. And I should say that even if he said something much weaker than that, he has admitted to saying that Trump would weaponize sexism and misogyny against Warren, which is an odd thing to bring up unless you’re claiming that a woman wouldn’t have a realistic shot at the presidency.

But leaving that aside, I think he’s wrong for subtle reasons. It’s true that women are up against it in political races and we have anecdotal evidence from the last election where we had a far stronger female candidate beaten out by a terribly weak, incompetent, and immoral male candidate. And there’s just a wealth of empirical evidence from social psychology that when a man and a woman go head to head for a masculine-coded leadership position, there tends to be a market bias in favor of the male candidate and against the female candidate.

I say Sanders is wrong because there is also evidence that highly communal women can overcome that bias.

Sean Illing

What do you mean by that?

Kate Manne

Well, there are some excellent studies by Madeline Heilman of NYU and her colleagues investigating whether the market bias I’m talking about can be mitigated if a woman is shown to be super compassionate, or more accurately perceived as super compassionate, caring, empathetic, nurturing, and kind. When that happens, the bias against women seems to disappear, or at least it’s reduced significantly. So if Sanders is wrong, I think it’s because someone like Warren actually has a pretty good shot because she’s perceived as hyper-communal.

Sean Illing

What is it about Trump, in particular, that makes the gender bias such a pressing issue?

Kate Manne

It seems like he’s the kind of candidate that would bring out a lot of people who want to vote for a strong man, or a perceived strong man, over a female candidate. He’s going to be a lightning rod for the sexist and misogynistic voter, whether they’re driven by implicit biases or explicit beliefs that a woman can’t be sufficiently competent to be president. You’d have to be very optimistic about gender egalitarian progress not to think that he’s someone who would enable and empower the sexist and misogynistic voters.

Sean Illing

In other words, because he’s a misogynist, Trump puts misogyny on the table and therefore activates misogynist voters.

Kate Manne

Yes, that’s a really good way of putting it.

Sean Illing

Are the dynamics for women candidates different in a presidential race? What makes the presidency different from congressional or gubernatorial races?

Kate Manne

I think we should be more attentive to the empirical evidence on this. There are some really nice studies showing that when it comes to races even for the Senate, men and women who are similarly described, there’s not necessarily a strong bias against women.

But there’s a study in which researchers manipulated the key variable and found that this changed as soon as you described a woman as power-seeking. So in one of the manipulations, they described the woman as “one of the most ambitious politicians in a state” who always “had a strong will to power” and has always been “hungry.” Now these are all keys to success in politics. And when men were described in these terms, they weren’t penalized. But when women were described this way, it became an issue.

So perceived power-seeking is a problem for women, and the presidency is probably the most powerful position in the world, so it’s not surprising that this would be problem.

Sean Illing

I’m curious if you think partisanship alters the logic of this in any way. If, for instance, an extremely hawkish conservative woman was running against Trump, does that play out any differently? Or does gender bias trump party politics?

Kate Manne

That’s a great question. So this is somewhat speculative, but my hunch is that there is a kind of mediating factor here that’s related to the perceived communality. So if a woman is perceived on the left as a hawk, she’ll be perceived as not communal and that’s going to really cost her. I think that’s especially true for center-left women. People who would otherwise vote for them are probably more suspicious of them than they would be of a male counterpart because they’re perceived as not empathetic and compassionate enough.

On the other hand, if you’re a right-wing woman, the way to be perceived as communal is to be more conservative, more emphatic on so-called family values, more inclined to defend the status quo when it comes to American interests abroad. So I think what you might find, and again, this would need empirical verification, is that perceptions of communality require different behavior depending on whether you’re on the left or right.

Sean Illing

There’s a tension here that I find difficult to navigate. How do we acknowledge the reality that sexism exists and that women face an enormous electoral disadvantage, at least in some circumstances, while at the same time fighting against it effectively?

Kate Manne

That’s the big question. I struggle with it, too. I think a lot of it has to do with the spirit in which these questions are raised. One reason people are suspicious of Sanders is that telling a female potential presidential candidate about these biases, at that stage, doesn’t seem diplomatic or helpful. But I do think there’s a way of acknowledging these biases that actually increases the chance of combating them successfully by saying, “Look, a woman would be really up against it in certain ways and we’re going to have to be vigilant in fighting for her if we believe she’s the best candidate.”

That’s what I’ve tried to say with respect to Elizabeth Warren. I think we have to be very careful about certain stories getting unwarranted traction or of double standards being applied. And maybe even more importantly, we have to be careful not to celebrate her on the wrong grounds. The research about hyper-communal women with power being acceptable worries me because it feeds into gender biases about how women are supposed to be — perfectly empathetic, perfectly compassionate, perfectly safe.

So we have to acknowledge that the biases really make this tough for women, but not impossible, and that there may be female candidates who are really worth fighting for, and then we have to go out and do that work. I don’t think it works to just live in denial about the biases.

Sean Illing

In the end, it feels like there just isn’t a good way to talk about this, especially if you’re a female candidate. If you bring it up, you’re playing “identity politics,” or the victim card. If you ignore it, it never goes away. It’s an inescapable trap.

Kate Manne

I completely agree with that. There’s no good way for Warren to bring this up that won’t hurt her with a significant number of people who share a very common implicit bias against women drawing moral attention to their own predicament. So I think this is true not only of politicians, but women generally, trying to draw attention to ways in which she faced sexism, and misogyny tends to attract more of it.

The only solution I can see is for her supporters and backers to bring up the fact that she is going to face a lot of these biases, that we have a moral responsibility not to be complacent in the face of them, but rather to fight against them. Otherwise, we’ll have a self-fulfilling prophecy on our hands where women can never win political office at this level, and instead of relying on her to bring up these factors, my preferred strategy is to try to be really clear about the biases that she’s facing and then to emphasize the fact that that doesn’t mean we should give up.

It means we should double down and fight harder if we believe she’s the best person for the job.

Load more
Read full article on:
unread news
unread news
Parasite Director Bong Joon-ho Greeted by Applause Upon Returning to South Korea
The crowd clapped and cheered at Incheon International Airport
9 m
Boyfriend of ex-"Love Island" host Caroline Flack speaks out
Caroline Flack, who was found dead Saturday, had hosted "Love Island" from its launch in 2015 before stepping down last year after being charged with assaulting her 27-year-old boyfriend Lewis Burton.
Pence Aide Says Trump Approved of 'Stop-and-Frisk' Under Giuliani, But Thought It Was 'Abused' Under Bloomberg
"He felt the policy was executed well under Mayor Giuliani," Marc Short told CNN.
Fotis Dulos, estranged husband of missing mom Jennifer Dulos, visited by his 5 kids before taken off life support
Fotis Dulos’ five children visited him in the hospital in New York last month before he was taken off life support after police found him unconscious from an apparent suicide attempt inside his Connecticut garage, according to a statement issued by the family spokesperson Saturday.
Roughnecks vs. BattleHawks prediction, line: Take the Under in XFL battle
In Week 2 of the XFL, the Houston Roughnecks (-7.5) play host to the St. Louis BattleHawks on Sunday (6 p.m., FS1). Houston quarterback P.J. Walker threw for 272 yards and four touchdowns in Week 1, and we saw why he beat out Connor Cook. The Roughnecks probably had the best overall performance in their...
Former Justice employees urge Barr to resign
More than 1,100 signed an online petition.
If William Barr Truly Believed in Rule of Law, He Would Resign
“Nothing could be more destructive of our system of government, of the rule of law, or Department of Justice as an institution, than any toleration of political interference with the enforcement of the law.” Those were William Barr’s words at both his 1991 and 2019 confirmation hearings, the words of someone who claimed to respect…
2/16: Face The Nation
This week on "Face the Nation," Senator Amy Klobuchar on her surprise finish in New Hampshire, and the latest on U.S. efforts to evacuate Americans from a quarantined cruise ship amid global fears of coronavirus.
Pearl River is nearing historic flood levels as Mississippi residents flee their homes
Hundreds of people in Mississippi's capital have fled their homes as authorities fear the swollen Pearl River will soon unleash catastrophic flooding.
Amanda Bynes shares photo with 'lover' after engagement announcement
Amanda Bynes is in love.
Amanda Bynes posts photo of ‘lover’ after engagement announcement
Amanda Bynes followed up Friday's engagement announcement with a photo of her "lover."
Robert Lewandowski equals Gerd Muller's Bundesliga record and eyes even more history
Bayern Munich's prolific Robert Lewandowski added his name to the Bundesliga record books by becoming only the second player in the history of the German top division to score 23 goals in the opening 22 games of the season.
McDonald's customer shares photo of metal rod in her sandwich: 'Nearly broke my tooth'
Chicken sandwiches taste better without metal.
Mississippi prison crisis: 18th state inmate dies since Dec. 29, second in 24 hours
An unidentified inmate died Sunday at Central Mississippi Correctional Facility, marking the 18th death state prisons since Dec. 29.
PragerU rakes in donations after Samantha Bee dis: 'The left validates what we say all the time'
Prager University [PragerU] founder Dennis Prager shot back at comedian Samantha Bee’s criticism of the nonprofit saying on “Fox & Friends Weekend” on Sunday that he takes the criticism as “a compliment,” adding that it’s also “a bit depressing.”
Jed Lowrie’s massive leg brace raises more Mets questions
There are more questions than answers surrounding Jed Lowrie. Upon his arrival to Mets spring training on Sunday, Lowrie was sporting a large brace on his left leg after being limited to nine games last season because of knee and hip injuries. Lowrie, 35, did take ground balls on Sunday but declined to discuss specifics...
Doctor accused of taking $26 million in health care fraud
A Florida doctor was charged by federal prosecutors on health care fraud for allegedly reaping millions from insurance companies for phony medical procedures.
Joe Biden Says He'd Be The 'Most Progressive' President in History, Tells Bernie Sanders to 'Disown' Misogynistic Supporters
He accused the Vermont senator of having "never gotten anything done" in his lengthy political career.
Utah police rush formula to house after mom calls 911 for hungry infant: 'It was really scary for me'
Any mom will agree that a hungry baby is definitely an emergency.
McCarthy: Picking Clinton would show Bloomberg knows he cannot win without 'cheating'
House Minority Leader Rep. Kevin McCarthy, R-Calif., responding to a report that Michael Bloomberg may choose Hillary Clinton as a running mate by claiming it reveals that the former New York City mayor lacks confidence in his ability to defeat Hew Hampshire primary winner Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt, on an even playing field.
Elton John cuts concert short in tears, says he's suffering from walking pneumonia
A visibly frustrated Elton John exited the stage early Sunday at his New Zealand concert, then revealed he'd been diagnosed with walking pneumonia.
Tony Fernandez, longtime Blue Jays shortstop, has died at 57
Tony Fernandez, a five-time Major League Baseball All-Star over 17 seasons, has died at 57, the Toronto Blue Jays tweeted on Sunday.
Iran: US sanctions 'create some problems'; talks possible with conditions
Iran says it would be willing to negotiate with the US if the Trump administration returns to the Iranian nuclear deal and drops economic sanctions.
Rhode Island man charged with two separate DUIs on Valentine’s Day
Love is blind … drunk. A Rhode Island man got arrested and charged with DUI twice in the same day on Valentine’s Day, according to cops. Patrick Cahill, 62, was first busted at 2:26 a.m. after state troopers pulled him over following “multiple calls” about him driving the wrong way on I-95 north near Warwick,...
Why the American passengers are mad about the evacuation
Officials: Mississippi Flooding Remains 'Precarious,' And Can 'Turn At Any Moment'
Flooding is rippling across parts of the state capital of Jackson. Officials say that with more rain expected, the inundation could worsen. Thousands of residents have already been affected.
Former President Obama on the Loss of Kobe and Gianna Bryant: 'Nothing Is More Heartbreaking'
Obama made the remarks at the NBA All-Star Weekend Newsmaker Brunch on Saturday.
No injuries reported in rocket attack near US embassy in Baghdad
BAGHDAD — At least four rockets hit near the sprawling US embassy in Baghdad and an Iraqi base hosting American troops inside the Green Zone early Sunday, but caused no casualties and only minor damage, US and Iraqi officials said. The attack came just before 3:30 a.m. local time, according to Col. Myles B. Caggins...
Face The Nation: Tom Steyer, Ed O'Keefe, Amy Walter, Eliana Johnson, Paula Reid, Holly Williams,
Missed the second half of the show? The latest on Tom Steyer, the 2020 elections and the humanitarian crises of the Syrian war.
It's so cold in the Midwest that thousands of ice balls have formed on Lake Michigan
Staff at Holland State Park in Michigan want you to know: "It's cold as balls out here!"
Vermont: Images of the Green Mountain State
Don Landwehrle / Shutterstock Today’s photo story is the sixth in a year-long Sunday series, focusing on each of the 50 states in the United States of America. Vermont is one of America’s smallest states by area, and is home to fewer than 625,000 residents. It is known for its picturesque mountains and valleys, ski slopes, spectacular fall colors, and its famous maple syrup. Gathered here are a few glimpses into the varied landscape of Vermont, and some of the animals and people calling it home.
John Kennedy on Trump's tweet: 'Just because you can sing, though, doesn’t mean you should'
Sen. John Kennedy, R-La., warned President Trump on Sunday against tweeting about criminal cases like he did with the one involving Republican operative and Trump ally Roger Stone.
Iran says it won't hold US talks 'under pressure'
Iran has said will never hold talks with the United States under pressure, President Hassan Rouhani said on Sunday (February 16), adding that Tehran's help was essential in establishing security in the Middle East.
Innocent bystander caught in fatal gunfire in East Harlem
Purcell Gowie was struck by a stray bullet and declared dead at Harlem Hospital.
UN blacklist crushes cooperation that actually boosts Israeli-Palestinian ties
The depraved totalitarians, nefarious barbarians, two-bit gangsters, odious scoundrels and bigoted scum who run the United Nations recently set up a new “database” to help anti-Semites around the world target Jewish businesses in the disputed territories of Judea and Samaria — businesses that not only offer economic opportunities for Palestinians but opportunities that pay higher...
Work begins on $20M beach replenishment project in Virginia
A $20 million project to replenish a 5-mile stretch of beach in Virginia is beginning after scheduling delays
Chinese bank to destroy cash in areas hit by coronavirus
China’s central bank will reportedly destroy some cash in areas hard-hit by the coronavirus to prevent contagion. People’s Bank of China has ordered the return of paper currency in circulation at hospitals, animal markets and buses near the country’s hot zones in order to destruct potentially-contaminated bills, the South China Morning Post reported. Other locations...
'Bachelor' contestant Victoria Fuller apologizes for White Lives Matter controversy
"The Bachelor" contestant Victoria Fuller, who is competing for Peter Weber's love, spoke out after a photo of her modeling a White Lives Matter hat.       
1 h
Stop and frisk gets renewed attention in Bloomberg candidacy
Bloomberg long defended it, even after a federal judge found it discriminatory.
1 h
Kobe Bryant receives tribute from Queen Latifah at NBA All-Star Game
Queen Latifah is showing the late Kobe Bryant some love.
1 h
Democratic candidates zero in on Bloomberg as former mayor rises in the polls
Democratic presidential candidates are zeroing in on Michael Bloomberg, criticizing the former New York mayor as he rises in the polls.
1 h
Mets’ 2020 season will swing on these 10 ‘if’ players
PORT ST. LUCIE — If at full health — and considering the organization maybe that term should come with a laugh track — the Mets’ 26-man roster has little mystery. The full squad takes the field for the first time Monday and based on performance, lack of minor league options and salaries, there are 26...
1 h
NYC subway thief thanks Democrats after his 139th arrest, release: 'Bail reform, it’s lit!'
A New York City man who’s now been arrested 139 times thanked Democrats for guaranteeing his immediate release despite repeatedly swiping hundreds of dollars from unsuspecting subway commuters since the state’s new bail reform law went into effect Jan. 1.
1 h
MLB commissioner Rob Manfred defends sign-stealing punishment but not Houston Astros' apologies
Rob Manfred tells ESPN why he didn't punish Houston Astros players for sign-stealing, says MLB will work with team to help "put this behind them."       
1 h
Box office: 'Sonic the Hedgehog' breaks record for video game adaptation
"Sonic the Hedgehog" sets a record for a video game adaptation as "The Photograph," "Fantasy Island," "Downhill" lag; "Parasite" gets an Oscar boost.
1 h
UFC on ESPN+ 25 post-event facts: History made with multiple disqualifications
All the notable stats and figures to come out of UFC on ESPN+ 25, which saw Jan Blachowicz knock out Corey Anderson in the main event.        Related StoriesUFC on ESPN+ 25 Promotional Guidelines Compliance pay: Main event combine for $20k totalFight Tracks: The walkout songs of UFC Rio Rancho with Bon Jovi vs. Loverboy showdownCallout Collection: Who UFC Rio Rancho winners want next – and how likely they'll get them 
1 h
Donald Trump and Melania Trump scheduled to take lap at Daytona 500, sources confirm
A portion of the presidential motorcade, including President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump, will take a lap around the speedway before the start of NASCAR's Daytona 500 on Sunday a source familiar with the event and a White House official confirms to CNN. They'll be riding the car known as "The Beast."
1 h