Yes, Toy Story 4’s director knows how weird Forky made the Toy Story world

Photo: Pixar Animation Studios

Toy Story 4 debuted in a world that’s changed profoundly since the original Toy Story hit theaters nearly 25 years ago. Toy Story was the first-ever entirely computer-animated film; now CGI animation is common, and the hand-drawn cel animation it replaced is a shrinking rarity. Toy Story was considered a huge success because it made more than $300 million at the box office; the newest sequel was considered a mild disappointment because it didn’t meet the outstanding projections for its performance, meaning it only brought in $1 billion.

But more significantly, Toy Story dropped into a world where Pixar Animation Studios was still an unknown, rather than an industry-shaping inspiration. Expectations for the first Toy Story were modest. Expectations for Toy Story 4 were outsized in part because Pixar has been such a powerful industry force over the last 25 years, and the Toy Story series in particular has been such a critical, aesthetic, narrative, and financial success. It was a major legacy to live up to with a third sequel. With Toy Story 4 coming to home video, first-time feature director Josh Cooley — a Pixar vet who’s worked as a storyboard artist, writer, and shorts director on projects from Ratatouille, to the Cars movies, to Up and Inside Out — talked to The Verge about the biggest challenges on the film, from specific story beats, to character design, to making the perfect virtual spider.

What was your biggest challenge on Toy Story 4 from a technological perspective?

Josh Cooley: It would definitely be the antique store. We have about 10,000 items in that store, and each one had to be shaded and built and rendered, so there’s a lot of information for the computer to wrap its head around. And we knew we were going to be in that antique store for a big chunk of the film. There’s also dust, and spiderwebs, and all this detail. So at first, we weren’t even sure we would be able to fill a store that big with that much stuff. The tone I really wanted was like a jungle, like a crammed city jungle, just a lot of stuff, how the stores are. We did a test a couple summers earlier, and we were able to make it work, so it seemed like would be possible.

You’ve said you put a lot of visual Easter eggs in the antique store because you got “lazy,” so you put in renders of things like Bing Bong’s rocket from Inside Out. What else should viewers watch out for on home video?

[Laughs] I should verify that it wasn’t out of laziness. That was just a joke. We do actually have to re-render everything, it’s not as easy as just clicking and dragging something from an old film. We have to start over again every time. But my favorite thing is, in one shot, there’s a casting of a hand in the background. And that is Ed Catmull’s hand. Ed’s the [former] president of the studio, and it was the very first computer model that was ever created. He did it as like, a project in school. I think they even used it in Star Trek: Wrath of Khan or something. [Catmull worked on the film’s computer-generated Genesis simulation.] So we made it into a plaster statue that you can purchase at an antique store.

It’s so random.

Talking to Pixar over the years about its evolving technology, we’ve heard a lot about your light-renderers and how they change the textures of your world. How does your lighting interact with something as visually complex as spiderwebs?

Yeah, that’s a great question. I’m not exactly sure even how that works. I do know they had to build, basically, a virtual spider to design the webs realistically. They’d say, “Where exactly would you like to have spiderwebs?” And I’d point on the screen where I’d like them, and then they would send the spider into action that would create natural-looking spiderwebs. It was insane, it was amazing. To be able to direct that side of the film, the technological side, all I had to do was talk about the emotion I wanted, and the animators would go do their magic and come back and show me incredible stuff. It was like a magic trick. It was insane.

What was the hardest sequence to plan and design?

The big action scene in the store, when they’re rescuing Forky out of the cabinet. That was a tough one. There were a lot of moving parts, a lot of characters. The staging had to be very clear as to where the characters were. We use the lighting to help sell that. The light coming in from the front of the store is casting into the store, so in the beginning, Woody and the toys are in shadow, and then when they get into the cabinet, the light’s streaming in. So we really made a difference between the two parts of the set they were on. But there’s a lot of action, a lot of story beats within that action scene that had to be very clear. So that was a tough one.

 Photo: Pixar Animation Studios

What about from an emotional perspective? What was hardest to convey when you were trying to break down the narrative and get the script set?

Probably the Bo and Woody relationship. Overall, we kept a real close eye on it. It was so important. Because this is a movie about their relationship, we looked at a lot of movies about relationships. Often there’s not a lot of dialog to establish a relationship. It’s mostly the looks between actors and the chemistry you can feel when you’re seeing how someone will look at someone else for just an extra little beat. Really subtle little things. And so, whenever we had moments like that, we made sure when we were animating it to bring everybody into the room at the same time and look at all the shots back to back. We wouldn’t just look at a single shot, like we tend to do. We’d look at the whole scene in whatever state of animation it was, just to make sure that every beat was being timed correctly and was being acted in the correct way.

The boldness of the ending was a big surprise to a lot of fans of the franchise, but Pixar just released an alternate ending that went in the exact opposite direction, and it apparently got as far as the animatic stage. What kind of conversations did you have about how you wanted to end the film?

Well, the very first version — this was always just in animatics — all the toys, including Bo, came back to Bonnie’s house at the end, and it was kind of like, “Bonnie has a new lamp now, and everything’s reset the way it was, but now with Bo in the picture.” And it just wasn’t emotionally satisfying. We didn’t really learn anything in that version.

So we thought, “Let’s see what happens with a Casablanca-type ending, where they love each other, but they know they have different duties they have to perform now.” So that’s what you saw in the deleted scenes. And that wasn’t satisfying, either. And then we went on to the next step, which was, “Let’s see what it looks like if they both don’t return.” I had this thought — I remember walking through this pitch with the producers. Just talking about him staying with the love of his life and saying goodbye to his friends, and saying “To infinity and beyond!” with Buzz, my voice cracked with the emotion of that moment. I could feel that. So I was convinced that if I could put that emotion on the screen, it could mean something.

 Photo: Pixar Animation Studios

What were the biggest challenges in the design stage, particularly in designing Ducky and Bunny?

Well, the great thing is — my production designer, Bob Pauley, was a designer on the first Toy Story. He actually designed Buzz Lightyear. So he came in with the design aesthetic, knowing the world. Toy Story is all about exaggerated shapes seen from low perspectives, because that’s where the characters are going to be most of the time. He knows theatrical lighting and realistic textures are the things that defined Toy Story. With Ducky and Bunny, I said, “These are carnival toys. Most carnival toys are crappy. They don’t look like you can really hug them, because they’re made of this awful material that’s really cheap. These guys are designed to be as cute as possible, which will contrast perfectly with their actual personalities. So the designers showed me tons of different designs of cute animals, and we narrowed it down to two, who are attached and have these off colors, you know, with a bright blue Bunny and such.

Forky is a new visual element for this world, and he has to look like trash but still be a personable, relatable character. What were the discussions around his design?

There weren’t that many! [Laughs] He’s very simple, which is what I love about him. When we first started speaking about an artcraft becoming a toy, the very first drawing, I think, was of a spork. And when we all saw that, we all just kept drawing sporks with different types of arms and legs. It was just that sporks are funny. In a weird way — we didn’t even plan this, but the idea of a spork being a fork and a spoon also complements the idea that he’s trash and a toy at the same time. Even in his creation, he’s not even sure what he is. So there was just something really funny and entertaining about that.

People take Pixar movies so seriously, debating your timeline and your philosophy and so forth. And Forky freaked people out because they’re saying, “So can anything be a toy? Can anything in this world come to life, and then it’s alive forever?” Do you guys have these kinds of philosophical discussions? Did you talk about what Forky was doing to your world?

Oh yeah! That’s how he was born. We were in a room talking about our own kids, and how the rules of Toy Story are that toys come to life. We said, “Well, our own kids in real life, they will pick up a rock and play with it. If Bonnie does that, does that mean the rock’s alive?” So we started pulling the threads on the universe. But then we were like, “Well, wait, let’s embrace that! Let’s say what would happen!” And the fact is, that thing that was not a toy would come to life. It has never seen Toy Story 1, 2, or 3, so it doesn’t understand any of the rules of the world. And we were just busting ourselves up with how ridiculous that was.

But also just the fact that the audience is coming in with all this knowledge of Toy Story. So to have a character show up that doesn’t understand it gives you so much leverage, comedy-wise. But also, it allows you to have an innocent character that can force Woody to explain what it means to be a toy. And then we could say, “Oh, now he’s supporting Woody’s story. Now there’s a real reason to have him in the movie.”

Load more
Read full article on:
unread news
unread news (Demo user)
Column: Kobe Bryant was L.A. — our dreams, our sweat and the drive that unites a far-flung city
Remembering a rare athlete whose greatness was matched by a desire to win
6 m
Grammys 2020: Billie Eilish wins Song of the Year for ‘Bad Guy’
It’s the song everyone can’t stop singing. Billie Eilish won the Song of the Year award at the 2020 Grammys at the Staples Center in Los Angeles, Calif. on Sunday, scoring the win for her hit “Bad Guy.” The 18-year-old took the stage with her brother Finneas O’Connell, 22, who co-wrote the song. “This is...
9 m
Why didn't FKA twigs sing during the Grammys' Prince tribute?
The Grammys' tribute to Prince featured FKA twigs' pole-dancing skills, but noticeably missing was her voice as Usher took lead on vocals. Twitter wasn't happy.
Lil Nas X and big Nas join forces at Grammys 2020
BTS also assisted.
Usher’s sloppy Prince tribute bombed at Grammys 2020
Sheila E couldn't even save it.
Nipsey Hussle celebrated at 2020 Grammys by Meek Mill, YG, John Legend, Roddy Ricch and more
YG, Roddy Ricch, Kirk Franklin, DJ Khaled and John Legend paid tribute to the late L.A. rapper Nipsey Hussle at the 2020 Grammy Awards
Dan Bongino: Trump's impeachment legal team 'decimated, destroyed, and annihilated' Dems' 'really awful' case
Former NYPD officer and Secret Service agent Dan Bongino said Sunday that President Trump’s defense team “completely decimated, destroyed, and annihilated the really awful, horrible, case” that House Intelligence Committee Chairman Adam Schiff, D-Calif., and other House managers in Trump’s impeachment trial, “tried to make.”
Wuhan coronavirus: Thousands of cases confirmed as China goes into emergency mode
The death toll from the Wuhan coronavirus now stands at 80, with almost 2,800 cases confirmed across China, as the country initiates emergency procedures to try and rein in the pathogen's global spread.
BTS Joined Lil Nas X for Their First Grammys Performance
It was the first time a Korean group performed at the American awards show
NYT: Bolton book draft says Trump tied Ukraine aid to political investigations
A draft manuscript of a book by former national security adviser John Bolton indicates President Donald Trump told Bolton in August that he wanted to continue holding military aid to Ukraine until the country helped with investigations into Democrats -- including former Vice President Joe Biden -- the New York Times reports.
Peru elects deeply split Congress with right-of-center tilt
Peruvians elected a fractured Congress with no clear leadership on Sunday, split among 10 parties with a center-right party grabbing the most seats with a tally of 24 out of 130, an Ipsos count of vote data reported by domestic media showed.
Kobe Bryant and Vanessa Bryant through the years
Their relationship lasted over two decades.
Three new cases of coronavirus confirmed in US, four more being tested in NY
The United States confirmed three new cases of the deadly coronavirus over the weekend — while officials in New York said four possible patients are being tested here. The latest confirmed cases — which were detected in Arizona and California — brought the number of people being treated for the infectious disease nationally to five,...
Grammy’s best dressed celebrities of 2020
It takes a lot to stand out in a sea of risk-taking artists on the 2020 Grammys red carpet. But at the 2020 show Sunday night at the Staples Center in LA, a few stars shone super-bright. While other Hollywood awards shows tend to be more about gorgeous gowns and elegant updos, musicians tend to...
Iraqi security forces kill protester, rockets hit U.S. embassy
Iraqi security forces shot at anti-government protesters in Baghdad on Sunday, killing at least one person, and unidentified men set fire to sit-in tents in a southern Iraqi city, police and medics said, as months-long civil unrest escalated.
‘Hillary’ docuseries hits hard at Bernie Sanders, tackles scandal claims at Sundance Film Festival
PARK CITY, Utah — Hillary Clinton threw a hand-grenade at the 2020 Democratic presidential primary election Saturday with her new documentary, “Hillary.”
Los Mavericks retirarán el número 24 en honor a Kobe Bryant
El dueño de los Mavericks, Mark Cuban, que ya había expresado a través de las redes sociales su pesar por la trágica muerte de Bryant
Impeachment’s proving a giant dud and other commetary
Impeach watch: The World-Historical Dud  At The Hill, Liz Peek snarks: “Is there a law against boring people to death?” If there were, Democrats could be indicted for initiating “such a profound undertaking, the overturning of an American election,” only to yield such a “dramatic dud.” Why do the proceedings make for such lame TV?...
Usher celebra a Prince en los Grammy, con la ayuda de unas ramitas FKA que bailan (pero no cantan)
Las ramitas de Usher, Sheila E. y FKA honraron el legado de Prince con una mezcla bulliciosa en los Grammys 2020
Fox News Town Hall with Pete Buttigieg: See the photos
Democratic nominee Pete Buttigieg appeared Sunday night on a Fox News Town Hall moderated by Chris Wallace in Iowa on Sunday, a week before the state's caucuses.
Kobe Bryant remembered by Conor McGregor at the 2020 Grammys red carpet: 'What a great man'
UFC legend Conor McGregor remembered fellow athlete Kobe Bryant on the red carpet for the 2020 Grammy Awards.
Democrats demand Bolton testify after NYT report Trump directly told him Ukraine aid tied to investigations
President Donald Trump told John Bolton he wanted to freeze military aid to Ukraine until it investigated his Democratic rivals, a report said.
College baseball coach dies in crash that killed Bryant
Longtime Orange Coast College baseball coach John Altobelli was killed in the helicopter crash that also took the lives of retired NBA superstar Kobe Bryant and Bryant’s daughter
Grammys: Demi Lovato returns to the stage for the first time since overdose with emotional performance
Demi Lovato returned to the stage for the first time since she almost lost her life last summer.
She did it: Demi Lovato nails powerful comeback performance at the Grammys
Demi Lovato took the Grammys stage with an assured performance of "Anyone," a song she wrote shortly before her June 2018 overdose.
New York fans, Madison Square Garden pay tribute to Kobe Bryant
Grief-stricken fans donned Kobe Bryant T-shirts on Sunday and flocked to Madison Square Garden, which was lit up in the purple and gold of the Los Angeles Lakers to pay tribute to the team’s legendary player. As the Knicks prepared to take on the Brooklyn Nets inside the arena, mourners snapped photos of the illuminated...
Dallas Mavericks to Retire No. 24 in Tribute to Kobe Bryant
In the wake of the tragic death of NBA legend Kobe Bryant and his daughter Gianna on Sunday, Dallas Mavericks Owner Mark Cuban has decided to retire the No. 24, Bryant's old number, in tribute to the fallen legend.
Kobe Bryant career highlights: From HS player of the year to his final game
1996: Graduates from Lower Merion HS outside Philadelphia as USA Today’s National High School Player of the Year June 26, 1996: Drafted 13th overall by the Charlotte Hornets in the NBA draft July 11, 1996: Traded to Los Angeles Lakers for Vlade Divac Feb. 8, 1997: Wins slam-dunk contest at NBA All-Star weekend Feb. 8,...
Pumas vence al campeón Monterrey y lidera el Clausura (Video)
Con el triunfo, Pumas alcanza siete puntos
Marc Leishman charges back for emotional Farmers victory
LA JOLLA, Calif. — The scene around the Torrey Pines clubhouse as the Farmers Insurance Open was coming to its climax Sunday afternoon was as surreal as it was frenetic. Emotions ranged from euphoria to devastation and profound sadness. There was a pall around the grounds as news of Kobe Bryant’s death in a tragic...
Amazon's Echo Buds are on sale at an all time low price
For the first time ever, Amazon's Echo Buds are available at their lowest price ever. Normally $129.99, Amazon's true wireless earbuds are just $89.99 with free Prime shipping.
K-pop's BTS and yodeler Mason Ramsey join Lil Nas X for kitchen-sink 'Old Town Road' Grammy jam
Lil Nas X performed with rapper Nas, K-pop stars BTS and that yodeling kid Mason Ramsey for his Grammy performance of "Old Town Road."
Camila Cabello brings dad to tears with heartfelt Grammys performance
Camila Cabello's emotional tribute to her father had the audience in tears following Kobe Bryant and his daughter Gianna's deaths.
Grammys 2020: Demi Lovato cries performing new song ‘Anyone’ after 2018 overdose
Demi Lovato got emotional during the performance of her new song, “Anyone,” at the 2020 Grammys, marking her first performance since her 2018 overdose. Taking the stage at the Staples Center in Los Angeles, Calif. Sunday, the 27-year-old started to sing and her voice cracked, forcing her to start over. “I tried to talk to...
"I thought he was going to live forever": Magic Johnson's tribute to Kobe Bryant
"I was supposed to pass away. He was supposed to talk about me. This is a sad day," Magic Johnson tells CBS Los Angeles.
Juárez sale bien bravo (Video)
El equipo de Gabriel Caballero llegó a 4 puntos para salir momentáneamente de la parte baja de la tabla
WATCH: Las Vegas' new slogan 'What happens here, only happens here' has landed
The new slogan launched Sunday with a 60-second commercial aired at the 2020 Grammy Awards. It replaces 'What happens here, stays here.'
Dense fog impaired visibility at time of crash that killed Kobe Bryant
The dense fog in the area of the helicopter crash that killed nine people in Calabasas is likely to be a focus of the federal investigation into its cause, experts say.
Ruben Diaz Jr. drops out of mayoral race, will retire from public office
Bronx Borough President Ruben Diaz Jr. said he is dropping out of the mayoral race and will retire from public office once his term ends in 2021. The 46-year-old, longtime Bronx politician, who kicked off his political career 23 years ago when he was elected as a state Assemblyman, will formally announce the decision to...
Grammys 2020: Here's why fans are upset about Usher's Prince tribute
The Grammy Awards' tribute to Prince Sunday night featuring Usher, FKA Twigs and Sheila E. left fans talking.
Kobe Bryant: 5 heartwarming moments of the NBA superstar and his daughter Gianna
Moments after basketball legend Kobe Bryant and his 13-year-old daughter Giana died in a helicopter crash, along with seven others, in Calabasas, Calif., Sunday morning, the Internet exploded with pictures and videos of the father-daughter duo, who shared a love and drive for basketball.
Alicia Keys References Trump's Impeachment, Tells President to 'Get Out' and Cardi B to Enter Politics at Grammys
"Commander in chief impeached. Ya'll get out. Let's bring Cardi B," Alicia Keys sang.
Grammys 2020: Best fashion on the red carpet
In pictures: The 2020 Grammy Awards
The 62nd Annual Grammy Awards are underway in Los Angeles.
Aerosmith and Run-D.M.C. reunite at 2020 Grammys for snarling 'Walk This Way'
Aerosmith and Run-D.M.C. joined forces at the Grammy Awards to perform their rap-rock classic take on "Walk This Way"
Abby Hornacek: Reflecting on Kobe Bryant's legacy
With the loss of Kobe Bryant, we mourn the death of an all-time great who didn’t just cause ripples with every splash from an off-balanced shot beyond the arc against a double-team but also generated a tidal wave in the spirit of the game that would continue to carve out the future of basketball.
Ariana Grande makes return to the Grammy Awards
It's official: Ariana Grande no longer has a problem with the Grammys.
Des Moines Register endorsement gives Warren an opening
Fading in the polls, the Massachusetts senator's campaign sees an uptick in energy a day after receiving the support of Iowa's biggest newspaper.